|
| Journals |
| Name |
Visits |
Posts |
Pics |
Videos |
| | TheHoskensProject | 50,657 | 138 | 397 | 3 | Yesterday | Dome-ville, central, FL |
| | Seven-Peaks-Faswall-... | 28,415 | 46 | 302 | 1 | Sunday | Graeagle, CA |
| | Barrel-Race | 1,454 | 25 | 75 | 0 | Wednesday | Houston, TX |
| | Tanglewood | 64,785 | 744 | 2,148 | 42 | | 6/2/2013 | Colorado Springs, CO |
| | NorthPoleHome | 23,576 | 31 | 117 | 0 | | 5/5/2013 | North Pole, AK |
| | Dream-Build-Austin-T... | 782 | 3 | 0 | 0 | | 4/17/2013 | Austin, TX |
| | The-Last-Rodeo | 5,100 | 21 | 10 | 0 | | 4/17/2013 | Angel Fire, NM |
| | Family-Affair | 6,466 | 3 | 0 | 0 | | 12/26/2012 | |
| | Eschete-Dome | 17,405 | 30 | 53 | 0 | | 12/24/2012 | Lafayette, LA |
| | HudsonHouse | 4,074 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 12/22/2012 | Omaha, NE |
| | OwensNewHome | 49,905 | 102 | 381 | 0 | | 11/25/2012 | Chandler, AZ |
| | Miami-FL-country-hom... | 2,320 | 2 | 1 | 0 | | 11/20/2012 | Miami, FL |
| | Beaver-Creek-Ranch | 24,795 | 18 | 292 | 0 | | 11/16/2012 | Hayfork, CA |
| | ChapelHillNCBob | 2,502 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 10/23/2012 | Chapel Hill, NC |
| | The-Skimino-Bluff | 3,056 | 3 | 13 | 0 | | 10/13/2012 | Williamsburg, VA |
| | Octagon-in-Glencoe-C... | 41,167 | 144 | 11 | 0 | | 10/8/2012 | Glencoe , CA |
| | nateshomemtpeakview | 2,018 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 9/29/2012 | |
| | sherman | 14,987 | 22 | 156 | 0 | | 9/27/2012 | Downers Grove, IL |
| | Omaha | 4,244 | 3 | 8 | 0 | | 9/13/2012 | Omaha, NE |
| | Holy-Hill-House | 10,829 | 35 | 53 | 0 | | 8/27/2012 | Richfield, WI |
| | Omega-CEO | 2,616 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 8/13/2012 | Manassas, VA |
| | JayHouse | 7,300 | 7 | 19 | 0 | | 6/22/2012 | Sebastopol, CA |
| | 302 | 24,628 | 23 | 77 | 0 | | 5/20/2012 | Belfair, WA |
| | SunburnStateHome | 3,359 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 3/6/2012 | Charlotte County, FL |
| | VICTOR-MONTANA | 4,736 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 2/22/2012 | Victor, MT |
| | Houston-72012596 | 3,970 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 1/21/2012 | Houston, TX |
| | Workshop | 12,095 | 6 | 3 | 0 | | 1/8/2012 | Florissant, CO |
| | Our-simple-home | 8,310 | 22 | 308 | 0 | | 12/5/2011 | LaPorte, IN |
| | ICF-Construction | 13,425 | 5 | 0 | 0 | | 11/11/2011 | Elkridge, MD |
| | Little-Help-from-my-... | 8,806 | 11 | 15 | 0 | | 11/4/2011 | Rockwall, TX |
| | YaNYca | 10,995 | 8 | 1 | 0 | | 10/29/2011 | Boston, MA |
| | The-Man-Refuge | 7,479 | 3 | 1 | 0 | | 10/19/2011 | San Antonio, TX |
| | mckernanmc | 8,300 | 3 | 2 | 0 | | 10/6/2011 | Amite, LA |
| | 1860s-Texas-rehabnew... | 37,815 | 43 | 191 | 0 | | 9/26/2011 | Boerne, TX |
| | Large-Family-Compoun... | 4,686 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 9/23/2011 | Covington, GA |
| | Woodchuck-Ridge | 7,134 | 4 | 8 | 0 | | 9/12/2011 | Akron, OH |
| | Forever-Home-Sweet-H... | 14,501 | 34 | 31 | 0 | | 8/24/2011 | Issaquah, WA |
| | Clarksville-MD | 5,896 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 8/22/2011 | Eldersburg, MD |
| | steve-n-carolyn | 12,871 | 4 | 14 | 0 | | 8/21/2011 | Sun City, CA |
| | Old-York | 5,221 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 7/27/2011 | Bridgewater, NJ |
| | Carriage-House | 12,848 | 20 | 28 | 2 | | 7/24/2011 | Ft. Collins, CO |
| | DomeSweetDome | 16,841 | 18 | 29 | 1 | | 6/4/2011 | Suffolk, VA |
| | Goodpasture | 17,112 | 56 | 288 | 0 | | 5/28/2011 | Westminster, CO |
| | TheCastle | 6,784 | 1 | 6 | 0 | | 5/25/2011 | Cheshire, CT |
| | Marks-Log-Cabin | 10,823 | 39 | 221 | 0 | | 5/12/2011 | Altoona, PA |
| | Bill | 13,851 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 5/4/2011 | Tucson, AZ |
| | Mueller-Dream-Home | 6,038 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 4/15/2011 | |
| | Oklahoma-Steel | 7,741 | 6 | 5 | 0 | | 4/13/2011 | Minco, OK |
| | DutchG | 5,610 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 4/5/2011 | |
| | HiddenInOhio | 7,251 | 9 | 13 | 0 | | 4/1/2011 | Elyria, OH |
| | MagnoliaHouse | 6,008 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 3/29/2011 | Houston, TX |
| | Buffaloader | 9,781 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 1/11/2011 | Valley Center, KS |
| | SouthernEcoHome | 20,421 | 20 | 21 | 0 | | 1/9/2011 | Blacksburg, VA |
| | Austrian-Chalet | 10,368 | 7 | 8 | 0 | | 1/2/2011 | Twin Lakes, CO |
| | Vista-Ridge | 9,601 | 21 | 66 | 0 | | 12/21/2010 | Swanton, OH |
| | OurFarmstead | 20,706 | 60 | 189 | 0 | | 12/10/2010 | Pennsylvania |
| | AirparkHome-Remodel | 24,498 | 22 | 46 | 0 | | 11/8/2010 | Hillsboro, OR |
| | Holloway | 8,050 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 11/7/2010 | Petersburg, VA |
| | Building-Our-Lakefro... | 6,945 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 11/5/2010 | Piscataway, NJ |
| | SunburyGalena-Build | 6,326 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 11/3/2010 | Galena, OH |
| | BUILDING-OUR-GREEN-D... | 7,052 | 8 | 0 | 0 | | 11/2/2010 | Pattison, TX |
| | RR-Homestead | 17,838 | 31 | 74 | 0 | | 10/26/2010 | Janesville, CA |
| | Casa-Paradiso-Vieque... | 7,028 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 10/19/2010 | Chelsea, MA |
| | Millerbuild | 8,181 | 5 | 11 | 0 | | 10/1/2010 | Carstairs, AB |
| | VilanoBeachCasa-de-S... | 17,410 | 38 | 117 | 0 | | 9/20/2010 | Saint Augustine, FL |
| | Delisledigs | 8,566 | 3 | 0 | 0 | | 9/16/2010 | Jacksonville, FL |
| | h20dave | 8,423 | 4 | 3 | 0 | | 9/10/2010 | Waterloo, AL |
| | Mountain-Idyl | 8,137 | 9 | 0 | 0 | | 9/9/2010 | Asheville, NC |
| | High-over-Lake-Granb... | 11,118 | 12 | 23 | 0 | | 9/8/2010 | Granbury, TX |
| | Homestead | 30,872 | 64 | 85 | 0 | | 9/8/2010 | Smithville, MO |
| | philandjan | 8,992 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 9/2/2010 | |
| | Commons | 7,297 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 8/21/2010 | Atascocita, TX |
| | Our-First-OB-home | 7,553 | 3 | 0 | 0 | | 7/27/2010 | Gardner, KS |
| | Louisiana-Mediterran... | 16,652 | 31 | 187 | 0 | | 7/21/2010 | Sunset, LA |
| | Crows-Nest | 7,042 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 7/20/2010 | |
| | Patterson-Project | 7,713 | 4 | 0 | 0 | | 7/16/2010 | John's Island, SC |
| | Hidden-Meadow-Home | 9,393 | 2 | 10 | 0 | | 7/13/2010 | Murrieta, CA |
| | New-house-in-Selah-W... | 7,392 | 1 | 4 | 0 | | 7/4/2010 | Belfair, WA |
| | Arnold-CA-Alpine-cha... | 16,478 | 22 | 10 | 0 | | 7/2/2010 | Arnold, CA |
| | Working-Wilton | 35,662 | 34 | 301 | 0 | | 6/16/2010 | Wilton, NH |
| | JJ-Residence | 6,757 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 6/7/2010 | San Antonio, TX |
| | Thompson-Valley-Home | 8,062 | 3 | 3 | 0 | | 6/6/2010 | Monticello, FL |
| | Naperville-Webster-S... | 20,959 | 23 | 6 | 0 | | 5/21/2010 | Naperville, IL |
| | Gary--Suzi | 7,998 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 5/7/2010 | |
| | crystal-falls-home | 23,181 | 20 | 27 | 0 | | 5/5/2010 | Cedar Park, TX |
| | Kapoho-Retirement-Ho... | 8,097 | 1 | 3 | 0 | | 5/4/2010 | Santa Ana, CA |
| | NC--New-Construction | 7,813 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 5/3/2010 | |
| | Collins-on-Cobblesto... | 8,339 | 21 | 91 | 0 | | 4/30/2010 | Waynesville, NC |
| | Dwight--Colleen-Hart... | 8,820 | 1 | 3 | 0 | | 4/30/2010 | Vaughn, WA |
| | Riley | 24,849 | 32 | 95 | 0 | | 4/29/2010 | Cave Creek, AZ |
| | The-New-Ries-Homeste... | 11,265 | 19 | 98 | 0 | | 4/21/2010 | Polk/Richfield/Erin/Hartford, WI |
| | The-Season | 6,859 | 1 | 3 | 0 | | 4/10/2010 | Mount Airy, NC |
| | The-Naas-Place | 7,299 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 3/30/2010 | Pittsburg, CA |
| | Phil-and-Lauras-home | 10,300 | 4 | 0 | 0 | | 3/20/2010 | Tulsa, OK |
| | Southport-NC-Home | 13,430 | 20 | 128 | 1 | | 3/18/2010 | Southport, NC |
| | Loris | 17,102 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 3/11/2010 | |
| | Seaton-Station | 7,409 | 1 | 4 | 0 | | 3/10/2010 | Siloam Springs, AR |
| | Backwoods-Project | 11,174 | 3 | 9 | 0 | | 3/4/2010 | Jeffersonville, GA |
| | ICF-in-Ann-Arbor | 22,613 | 29 | 371 | 0 | | 1/25/2010 | Dexter, MI |
| | DancingPines | 8,256 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 1/25/2010 | Clinton, LA |
| | Log-Cabin | 7,797 | 1 | 5 | 0 | | 1/23/2010 | indianapolis, IN |
| | The-Kinzel-House | 7,096 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 1/21/2010 | New Orleans, LA |
| | PahrumpProject | 14,005 | 5 | 39 | 0 | | 1/17/2010 | Spokane, WA |
| | TheBeachHouse | 11,637 | 13 | 20 | 0 | | 1/16/2010 | Shoreline, WA |
| | Artist-Haven-Home | 11,948 | 9 | 7 | 0 | | 1/13/2010 | Kansas City, MO |
| | SOPHIA--SAMUELDELAWA... | 13,179 | 11 | 31 | 0 | | 12/2/2009 | Smyrna, DE |
| | Plant-City-Craftsman | 14,077 | 4 | 10 | 0 | | 11/22/2009 | Plant City, FL |
| | WestermanFarm | 8,535 | 1 | 3 | 0 | | 11/10/2009 | Dickson, TN |
| | Shane | 15,898 | 6 | 0 | 0 | | 10/31/2009 | San Antonio, TX |
| | ADCountryHome | 9,724 | 11 | 3 | 0 | | 10/31/2009 | Fort Worth, TX |
| | ICF-Keller-Tx | 47,149 | 32 | 122 | 0 | | 10/6/2009 | Roanoke, TX |
| | digs | 16,468 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 9/30/2009 | Tracy City, TN |
| | threegables | 16,621 | 20 | 134 | 0 | | 9/29/2009 | Hartland, WI |
| | LittleLakeCorner | 64,340 | 101 | 604 | 0 | | 9/29/2009 | Groveland, FL |
| | Utah-Casa | 8,612 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 9/28/2009 | Saratoga Springs, UT |
| | Tornado-Reconstructi... | 8,365 | 8 | 0 | 0 | | 9/24/2009 | Port Neches, TX |
| | toolehouse | 44,141 | 89 | 145 | 0 | | 9/20/2009 | Reno, NV |
| | Bobs-Blog | 48,329 | 61 | 414 | 0 | | 9/16/2009 | New Florence, PA |
| | Blessings | 7,250 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 9/11/2009 | farmville, NC |
| | Schrammelot | 12,709 | 7 | 90 | 0 | | 9/11/2009 | Pierson, FL |
| | PennsmithLostValleyT... | 30,995 | 55 | 215 | 0 | | 9/9/2009 | Dripping Springs, TX |
| | River-House | 7,726 | 2 | 2 | 0 | | 9/7/2009 | Clinton, NJ |
| | SantaFe-in-AJ | 7,583 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 8/28/2009 | Apache Junction, AZ |
| | Dennis-Dream-Home | 24,479 | 38 | 505 | 0 | | 8/27/2009 | Readington Twp, NJ |
| | Massive-Undertaking | 8,785 | 11 | 0 | 0 | | 8/26/2009 | Wimauma, FL |
| | Lafayette | 7,524 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 8/11/2009 | Cramerton, NC |
| | Dream-site-on-the-La... | 8,202 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 8/5/2009 | La Porte, TX |
| | Williams-New-Home-Si... | 7,378 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 8/2/2009 | Windsor, NC |
| | Cobblestone-Lane | 7,690 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 7/30/2009 | Great Falls, MT |
| | PensacolaBeachHouse | 7,497 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 6/22/2009 | Gulf Breeze, FL |
| | 12YEARSINTHEPLANNING | 8,043 | 1 | 2 | 0 | | 6/16/2009 | LADSON, SC |
| | The-Cortes-Adventure | 13,611 | 3 | 2 | 0 | | 6/13/2009 | Snowflake, AZ |
| | Steinys-Hideaway | 7,961 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 6/9/2009 | Venice, CA |
| | DreamHome | 25,879 | 26 | 190 | 0 | | 6/7/2009 | Orlando, FL |
| | CastleHeims | 17,045 | 21 | 59 | 0 | | 6/5/2009 | Cedar Rapids, IA |
| | Utah-Warehouse | 7,342 | 2 | 2 | 0 | | 5/20/2009 | Fairview, UT |
| | Where-to-start | 9,101 | 6 | 1 | 0 | | 5/16/2009 | Lemoore, CA |
| | Castle-Rock-Lakehous... | 13,250 | 10 | 84 | 0 | | 4/27/2009 | Necedah, WI |
| | Oleg | 17,822 | 3 | 6 | 0 | | 4/22/2009 | San Diego, CA |
| | MoeCompound | 7,353 | 3 | 4 | 0 | | 4/9/2009 | Camano Island, WA |
| | Huckleberry-Home | 7,741 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 4/8/2009 | Williamstown, NJ |
| | Vonk | 16,302 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 4/7/2009 | Zeeland, MI |
| | Small-Timber-Frame | 11,557 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 4/2/2009 | Central Mass, MA |
| | EatonLoch-Haven | 8,321 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 4/1/2009 | Roanoke, VA |
| | windowsnsiding | 7,626 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 3/28/2009 | Long Island, NY |
| | Arkansas-First-Timer | 21,108 | 39 | 88 | 0 | | 3/27/2009 | Trumann, AR |
| | Back-Home-In-Crisp | 9,486 | 11 | 151 | 0 | | 3/22/2009 | Ennis, TX |
| | Victor--Susan-08 | 16,872 | 21 | 121 | 0 | | 3/17/2009 | Ruckersville, VA |
| | Rick-and-Tinas-dream... | 8,864 | 1 | 2 | 0 | | 3/14/2009 | Auburndale, FL |
| | Keener-Road | 10,145 | 4 | 10 | 0 | | 3/11/2009 | Elizabethtown, PA |
| | NC-Newbie | 8,132 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 3/10/2009 | Boone, NC |
| | MadisonGA | 8,278 | 1 | 13 | 0 | | 2/26/2009 | Madison, GA |
| | Techbuilt-Scammed | 9,601 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 2/25/2009 | Rebew, LA |
| | choanne831 | 7,478 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 2/9/2009 | charlotte, NC |
| | WilliamsinVegas | 30,148 | 30 | 119 | 0 | | 1/29/2009 | Henderson, NV |
| | PhilesBryant | 9,299 | 2 | 6 | 0 | | 1/20/2009 | graham, WA |
| | MortgageSmart | 7,622 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 1/19/2009 | Cocoa, FL |
| | QuarterlyHouse | 51,406 | 136 | 99 | 0 | | 1/12/2009 | Orlando, FL |
| | RabbitRun | 16,364 | 31 | 169 | 0 | | 1/11/2009 | Afton, VA |
| | Sonave-Sunsets | 7,781 | 1 | 2 | 0 | | 1/9/2009 | Yucca, AZ |
| | Heart-of-PA | 12,453 | 9 | 16 | 0 | | 1/6/2009 | Lewistown, PA |
| | Krusehome | 8,613 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 12/27/2008 | Lake City, FL |
| | BrunkHouseAlmaKansas | 11,759 | 2 | 6 | 0 | | 12/26/2008 | Garden Grove, CA |
| | Raider-Bills-Tenn-Ho... | 11,777 | 6 | 32 | 0 | | 12/22/2008 | Largo, FL |
| | Andel-Ranch | 24,492 | 33 | 402 | 0 | | 12/17/2008 | Rogers, TX |
| | Elijahs-Home | 8,959 | 4 | 6 | 0 | | 12/6/2008 | Vero Beach, FL |
| | ranch-house | 7,806 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 11/25/2008 | springfield, IL |
| | Howard-Georgia-Retir... | 12,046 | 6 | 7 | 0 | | 11/9/2008 | Harlem, GA |
| | The-Woods-Journal | 8,490 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 11/6/2008 | Doraville, GA |
| | StansTLH | 12,485 | 10 | 9 | 0 | | 11/1/2008 | Tehachapi, CA |
| | Kevin--Kerrys-Dream | 8,805 | 3 | 5 | 0 | | 10/17/2008 | Northvale, NJ |
| | Katabatic-Wind | 9,183 | 4 | 7 | 0 | | 10/16/2008 | Huntsville, AL |
| | Elmhurst-Modern | 10,812 | 1 | 2 | 0 | | 10/14/2008 | elmhurst, IL |
| | Accessible-House | 8,744 | 3 | 10 | 0 | | 10/14/2008 | Munford, TN |
| | Cherry-Valley-Vista | 7,945 | 1 | 2 | 0 | | 10/5/2008 | Duvall, WA |
| | Jon-and-Mollys-House | 14,188 | 1 | 5 | 0 | | 9/25/2008 | Ellicott City, MD |
| | Proctor-ICF | 8,912 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 9/25/2008 | Fredericksburg, VA |
| | Hawaiian-Bungalo | 14,683 | 11 | 102 | 0 | | 9/23/2008 | Holualoa, HI |
| | Pete--Rhiannon | 9,980 | 4 | 3 | 0 | | 9/19/2008 | Springfield, MO |
| | 2008-Cedar-Ln | 13,651 | 14 | 35 | 0 | | 9/19/2008 | Seaville, NJ |
| | dmaceld | 16,760 | 14 | 88 | 0 | | 9/16/2008 | Nampa, ID |
| | Help-with-Goulds-and... | 9,953 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 9/16/2008 | tampa, FL |
| | Consulting | 7,532 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 9/2/2008 | Orlando, FL |
| | AlaskaICFREMOTEHouse | 13,163 | 19 | 38 | 0 | | 8/17/2008 | Wasilla, AK |
| | NC-Pond-House | 8,722 | 3 | 2 | 0 | | 8/4/2008 | Wilmington, NC |
| | MargaritaVilla | 8,331 | 2 | 4 | 0 | | 8/4/2008 | Raleigh, NC |
| | Latest-update | 9,642 | 8 | 10 | 0 | | 8/4/2008 | Sierra Vista, AZ |
| | ANDREA | 8,139 | 4 | 0 | 0 | | 8/2/2008 | Dallas, TX |
| | The-Ridges | 10,526 | 11 | 13 | 0 | | 7/31/2008 | Logan, UT |
| | Avenida-Del-Sol | 12,021 | 13 | 52 | 0 | | 7/31/2008 | Peoria, AZ |
| | dream-home-ohio | 8,534 | 6 | 0 | 0 | | 7/30/2008 | Zanesville, OH |
| | Penetang-Craftsman | 8,066 | 3 | 6 | 0 | | 7/27/2008 | Penetanguishene, ON |
| | Tristan-- | 8,359 | 6 | 0 | 0 | | 7/25/2008 | Lebanon, NJ |
| | Dreamy-Design-in-Glo... | 12,907 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 7/9/2008 | Clifton, VA |
| | need-help-Jim | 8,662 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 7/8/2008 | Bandon, OR |
| | deltona-fl-custom-ho... | 9,534 | 4 | 14 | 0 | | 7/6/2008 | Deltona Beach, FL |
| | Ingraham-House-Chape... | 8,725 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 6/29/2008 | Cary, NC |
| | famborgie | 7,473 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 6/26/2008 | Lockhart, TX |
| | 95821-Addition | 17,502 | 7 | 14 | 0 | | 6/24/2008 | Sacramento, CA |
| | Cajun-Homestead | 14,283 | 12 | 93 | 0 | | 6/22/2008 | Lafayette, LA |
| | West-Texas-Ranch-Hou... | 9,866 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 6/18/2008 | Andrews, TX |
| | Quail-Bluff-Pasco | 9,546 | 9 | 29 | 0 | | 6/10/2008 | Pasco, WA |
| | Spyders-Web | 7,598 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 6/10/2008 | Norman, OK |
| | mike-and-tori-darnle... | 10,109 | 5 | 1 | 0 | | 6/2/2008 | Rainbow, CA |
| | Lin-Washington | 7,838 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 5/29/2008 | Fresno, CA |
| | Capernall-House | 8,442 | 4 | 2 | 0 | | 5/15/2008 | Belleville, MI |
| | Hidden-Valley-Texas | 7,954 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 5/7/2008 | Southlake, TX |
| | cosdreamhome | 36,937 | 73 | 147 | 0 | | 5/5/2008 | Colorado Springs, CO |
| | Sowle-Family-House | 10,412 | 5 | 9 | 0 | | 4/29/2008 | South Burlington, VT |
| | Cyberdoc-Residence | 8,367 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 4/25/2008 | San Diego, CA |
| | Fortune-House | 8,222 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 4/17/2008 | Mooresville, NC |
| | Joeb | 20,506 | 4 | 0 | 0 | | 4/15/2008 | Oakland, FL |
| | Alvin-House | 8,283 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 4/14/2008 | LaPorte, TX |
| | Thomas-Home--Raintre... | 17,753 | 27 | 180 | 0 | | 4/9/2008 | Lee's Summit, MO |
| | Greg--Kathys-New-Hou... | 9,498 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 4/3/2008 | Barryton, MI |
| | Where-is-Waldo | 24,915 | 44 | 83 | 0 | | 4/2/2008 | Marion, OH |
| | Nimmerrichters-Fores... | 7,436 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 4/2/2008 | Waldorf, MD |
| | Mayfield-House | 8,075 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 3/31/2008 | Mayfield, UT |
| | beamanhouse | 7,930 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 3/27/2008 | Manistique, MI |
| | Kanak-ICF--Virginia | 12,086 | 9 | 0 | 0 | | 3/26/2008 | Fredericksburg, VA |
| | Sheldon-St | 11,419 | 3 | 0 | 0 | | 3/21/2008 | Orlando, FL |
| | Bert- | 18,494 | 3 | 1 | 0 | | 3/20/2008 | Southern, CA |
| | Our-Ohio-ICF-home | 18,725 | 20 | 27 | 0 | | 3/20/2008 | Mansfield, OH |
| | ericdc | 8,426 | 3 | 1 | 0 | | 3/8/2008 | Uniontown, PA |
| | EurekaHouse-ICF | 11,637 | 5 | 15 | 0 | | 3/6/2008 | Berkeley, CA |
| | Superstition-Views | 12,434 | 28 | 160 | 0 | | 3/6/2008 | Mesa, AZ |
| | Blue-Springs-Project | 10,090 | 8 | 23 | 0 | | 2/24/2008 | Broken Arrow, OK |
| | Our-House | 7,676 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 2/24/2008 | Miami, FL |
| | httpownerbuilderbook... | 10,420 | 8 | 3 | 0 | | 2/19/2008 | Clayton, NY |
| | JourneyBackHome | 7,759 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 2/3/2008 | Oviedo, FL |
| | Collier-Home | 9,890 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 2/1/2008 | Little Rock, AR |
| | DDs-ICF | 9,442 | 3 | 3 | 0 | | 1/27/2008 | New Smyrna Bch, FL |
| | EurekaMT-Timberframe | 9,182 | 14 | 3 | 0 | | 1/24/2008 | Augusta, MI |
| | The-Larnerd-House | 10,692 | 5 | 21 | 0 | | 1/21/2008 | Newport News, VA |
| | Casa-Bella | 8,546 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 1/14/2008 | Pueblo West, CO |
| | Gordon-Lake-House | 12,537 | 17 | 51 | 0 | | 1/3/2008 | Oakland, IA |
| | STEPHANIES-DREAM | 9,528 | 17 | 57 | 0 | | 12/30/2007 | Lower Burrell, PA |
| | Florida-Waterfront-C... | 11,995 | 3 | 1 | 0 | | 12/29/2007 | PB, FL |
| | 6158-in-Montgomery-T... | 8,636 | 4 | 1 | 0 | | 12/23/2007 | Conroe, TX |
| | ClearwaterHills | 10,848 | 2 | 6 | 0 | | 12/14/2007 | Paradise Valley, AZ |
| | BobDonna | 7,168 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 12/12/2007 | Sacramento, CA |
| | AboveTheAppleTree | 7,441 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 12/8/2007 | La Farge, WI |
| | Casa-Nostra | 9,399 | 2 | 3 | 0 | | 12/2/2007 | Bangor, PA |
| | Building-the-Dream-i... | 10,879 | 7 | 0 | 0 | | 11/29/2007 | Gladstone, OR |
| | Ingram-Fleming-ICF-H... | 12,600 | 4 | 8 | 0 | | 11/29/2007 | Plant City, FL |
| | inniagara | 6,752 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 11/24/2007 | Niagara Falls, ON |
| | SchnabelEstate | 7,931 | 2 | 4 | 0 | | 11/16/2007 | Avon, IN |
| | WeAreBuildingAgain | 16,730 | 27 | 56 | 0 | | 11/15/2007 | Orlando, FL |
| | Lake-Pleasant | 7,739 | 2 | 1 | 0 | | 11/14/2007 | Erie, PA |
| | Green-for-Dean | 7,841 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 11/10/2007 | San Jose, CA |
| | The-Ponderosa | 9,492 | 8 | 22 | 0 | | 11/4/2007 | Perry, OK |
| | FlagholeRoad | 7,950 | 2 | 6 | 0 | | 10/25/2007 | Franklin, NH |
| | Beckynray | 8,946 | 3 | 0 | 0 | | 10/24/2007 | Powhatan, VA |
| | Spicewood-TX | 9,524 | 3 | 3 | 0 | | 10/20/2007 | Austin, TX |
| | Powderhorn | 20,248 | 48 | 176 | 0 | | 10/4/2007 | Florida |
| | Luray-VA-1stTimeBuil... | 12,024 | 7 | 3 | 0 | | 10/4/2007 | Luray, VA |
| | kittyfhughesnet | 7,672 | 2 | 5 | 0 | | 9/27/2007 | Noblesville, IN |
| | Scott-Family | 8,006 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 9/25/2007 | Trinity, AL |
| | Taking-the-Plunge | 10,605 | 6 | 18 | 0 | | 9/18/2007 | Springfield, OH |
| | RozBuildingAdventure | 8,188 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 9/14/2007 | San Pablo, CA |
| | Helpful-Tips | 8,929 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 9/13/2007 | Encinitas, CA |
| | Poplar-Creek-Farm | 10,258 | 5 | 25 | 0 | | 9/10/2007 | Oakland Park, FL |
| | TheWillemsHome | 17,643 | 17 | 5 | 0 | | 9/10/2007 | Galloway Township, NJ |
| | ComfortHome | 8,429 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 8/30/2007 | Dublin, OH |
| | 10000-sq-feet | 33,055 | 22 | 26 | 0 | | 8/26/2007 | La Habra Heights, CA |
| | Bird-house | 9,632 | 3 | 40 | 0 | | 8/22/2007 | Ithaca, NY |
| | Circle-S_ICF_House | 30,858 | 46 | 264 | 0 | | 8/21/2007 | Sparta, IL |
| | New-England-Saltbox | 8,056 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 8/16/2007 | Columbia, SC |
| | RamblewoodatJeterFar... | 8,738 | 6 | 33 | 0 | | 8/10/2007 | Kansas City, MO |
| | Kraemer-Collinwood-H... | 8,444 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 7/21/2007 | Delano, MN |
| | BigOakBuilderTX | 11,340 | 2 | 7 | 0 | | 7/20/2007 | Wharton, TX |
| | Johnson-Family-Dream | 8,371 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 7/20/2007 | Normal, IL |
| | 19225-ROBERTSON-ST | 14,778 | 14 | 25 | 0 | | 7/12/2007 | Orlando, FL |
| | Thattle-Dew-Farm | 8,262 | 2 | 2 | 0 | | 7/12/2007 | Halls Harbour, NS |
| | WindyJ | 12,076 | 11 | 26 | 0 | | 7/2/2007 | Knoxville, TN |
| | Vistoso-Green-Home | 9,490 | 3 | 1 | 0 | | 6/28/2007 | Tucson, AZ |
| | Lewis-Chapel-House | 13,042 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 6/25/2007 | Dunlap, TN |
| | father-daughter | 7,874 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 6/25/2007 | Loveland, CO |
| | davewhite | 8,833 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 6/24/2007 | Nanaimo, BC |
| | NutmegWedgefieldOrla... | 9,881 | 6 | 0 | 0 | | 6/22/2007 | Orlando, FL |
| | 4600SF-Dream-Home-in... | 11,874 | 4 | 1 | 0 | | 6/19/2007 | Mooresville, NC |
| | Coeur-dAlene-Idaho-H... | 9,478 | 2 | 4 | 0 | | 6/13/2007 | Coeur d Alene, ID |
| | Tampa-Bay | 10,957 | 4 | 9 | 0 | | 6/10/2007 | Ruskin, FL |
| | Dream-In-Progress | 11,164 | 5 | 4 | 0 | | 6/7/2007 | Shawnee, KS |
| | todd-in-tullahoma | 8,259 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 6/4/2007 | tullahoma, TN |
| | TheOwens | 8,888 | 3 | 0 | 0 | | 6/1/2007 | Dickson, TN |
| | Country-Cleaver | 8,990 | 1 | 4 | 0 | | 5/29/2007 | Springfield, IL |
| | South-Dakota-Lake-Ho... | 9,333 | 6 | 11 | 0 | | 5/23/2007 | Sioux Falls, SD |
| | Gods-Home | 8,462 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 5/18/2007 | Eustis, FL |
| | hammock | 8,373 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 5/14/2007 | Martinez, GA |
| | Grove-St-Rocklin | 8,488 | 3 | 0 | 0 | | 5/13/2007 | Orangevale, CA |
| | Gardeners-Delight | 9,196 | 3 | 3 | 0 | | 5/13/2007 | Norristown, PA |
| | Newman-Family | 9,314 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 4/26/2007 | oralndo, FL |
| | do-over-house | 9,321 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 4/25/2007 | Roseville, CA |
| | Mountain-Building | 8,686 | 3 | 7 | 0 | | 4/21/2007 | Hiawassee, GA |
| | Alaskan-Log-Home | 9,795 | 1 | 2 | 0 | | 4/15/2007 | Tok, AK |
| | Warner-Dream | 10,172 | 6 | 0 | 0 | | 4/11/2007 | Astatula, FL |
| | RehmannSchreiner | 10,778 | 18 | 15 | 0 | | 4/2/2007 | Maple Grove, MN |
| | outspokenbikeguy | 10,975 | 4 | 14 | 0 | | 3/29/2007 | Sanford, FL |
| | SmelltheForest | 30,635 | 47 | 148 | 0 | | 3/23/2007 | Colorado Springs, CO |
| | PolkCityProject | 12,430 | 7 | 11 | 0 | | 3/21/2007 | Norcross, GA |
| | DwaynePam | 9,267 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 3/21/2007 | Normal, IL |
| | cypressknoll | 8,473 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 3/20/2007 | Palm Coast, FL |
| | candlepower | 15,337 | 24 | 155 | 0 | | 3/20/2007 | Lansing, IA |
| | Team-Rosa | 9,316 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 3/19/2007 | Springfield, VA |
| | GLOUCESTER | 8,839 | 1 | 2 | 0 | | 3/17/2007 | Newport News, VA |
| | Ohiodreamhome | 9,267 | 4 | 14 | 0 | | 3/16/2007 | Reynoldsburg, OH |
| | Gypsy-Love | 9,817 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 3/12/2007 | Highland, NY |
| | Forrest-Towne | 9,030 | 2 | 2 | 0 | | 3/10/2007 | Brinnon, WA |
| | Dreams-Come-True | 8,289 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 3/8/2007 | Glen St Mary, FL |
| | Almost-A-Country-Gir... | 8,200 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 3/7/2007 | Addison Township, MI |
| | BrandonBuildingBlog | 9,130 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 3/4/2007 | Layton, UT |
| | SafecreteHouse | 10,299 | 3 | 0 | 0 | | 3/4/2007 | Raleigh, NC |
| | newbie- | 9,199 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 2/21/2007 | North Plains, OR |
| | BuzzardsNest | 11,503 | 3 | 1 | 0 | | 2/14/2007 | Saint Lucie, FL |
| | woodfamilyhome | 9,882 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 2/10/2007 | Keno, OR |
| | vegascastle | 9,073 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 2/3/2007 | Henderson, NV |
| | newsteel | 9,252 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 1/28/2007 | Florence, SC |
| | Dream-Home-2007 | 9,434 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 1/27/2007 | Gwynn Oak, MD |
| | DelgadosAdobeAbode | 10,173 | 2 | 0 | 0 | | 1/18/2007 | San Diego, CA |
| | bobindeltona | 11,687 | 2 | 5 | 0 | | 1/14/2007 | Deltona, FL |
| | Highland64 | 9,707 | 3 | 0 | 0 | | 1/8/2007 | New Orleans, LA |
| | SmallProjectSilverSp... | 13,728 | 10 | 2 | 0 | | 1/7/2007 | Silver Springs, NV |
| | BeehlerHome | 18,029 | 11 | 64 | 0 | | 1/3/2007 | Kalamazoo, MI |
| | eveningshade | 9,460 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 12/25/2006 | Evening Shade, AR |
| | Bruce in Petrolia, O... | 8,833 | 1 | 2 | 0 | | 12/21/2006 | Petrolia, ON |
| | smahmud | 8,841 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 12/18/2006 | Alexandria, VA |
| | 1000-hours-to-liftof... | 9,987 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 11/25/2006 | Uniontown, OH |
| | FettConstruction | 10,078 | 4 | 6 | 0 | | 11/24/2006 | Vincennes, IN |
| | Northeast-Ohio-Home | 10,182 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 11/10/2006 | Parma, OH |
| | Buchanan-Mountain | 14,587 | 14 | 59 | 0 | | 11/1/2006 | Dickson, TN |
| | Our-Future-on-Badin-... | 10,058 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 10/24/2006 | New London, NC |
| | nowi-fe-haven | 9,320 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 10/22/2006 | Griffin, GA |
| | klonus | 9,330 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 10/16/2006 | Madison, WI |
| | OurAddition | 13,852 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 10/13/2006 | Chuluota, FL |
| | bigal | 10,381 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 9/30/2006 | Whittier, CA |
| | Stella-Maris-II | 10,055 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 9/11/2006 | Orlando, FL |
| | Lake-House | 11,467 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 9/6/2006 | Kansas City, MO |
| | My-First-House | 23,200 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 9/5/2006 | APO, AE |
| | Angie-Mossy-Oak-Acre... | 12,844 | 7 | 4 | 0 | | 8/15/2006 | Lake Helen, FL |
| | Peaceful-Valley-in-M... | 9,913 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 7/23/2006 | Republic, MO |
| | Lake-Wales-Fl | 9,852 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 7/17/2006 | West Palm Beach, FL |
| | JohnKat | 10,300 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 7/16/2006 | Fort Worth, TX |
| | Cedarcrest | 10,886 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 7/15/2006 | Sparrows Point, MD |
| | MRailey | 11,052 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 7/13/2006 | Dallas, TX |
| | Villa-Di-Capri-Hacie... | 14,469 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 7/10/2006 | Hacienda Heights, CA |
| | New-2-This | 12,970 | 4 | 37 | 0 | | 6/26/2006 | Stafford, VA |
| | End-of-the-Road | 10,672 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 6/26/2006 | Homer, AK |
| | shapiro | 9,968 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 6/21/2006 | Camp Verde, AZ |
| | ShangriLaw | 11,177 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 5/27/2006 | Lebanon, IN |
| | Kokinos-ICF-Project | 12,531 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 5/16/2006 | Los Gatos, CA |
| | Jennifer-and-Darko | 10,628 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 5/8/2006 | Holly Springs, NC |
| | LeFamily | 11,080 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 4/29/2006 | Irvine, CA |
| | jrh | 21,232 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 3/25/2006 | North Bend, WA |
| | Pete-Maniscalco | 11,250 | 1 | 0 | 0 | | 3/8/2006 | Welton, AZ |
| | H3brewing | 11,612 | 1 | 1 | 0 | | 3/2/2006 | Cleveland, MO |
| | 85-Hall-Ln | 13,705 | 10 | 0 | 0 | | 3/1/2006 | |
| | Michigan-Owner-Build... | 10,948 | 6 | 13 | 0 | | 11/13/2005 | Ray Twp., MI |
See all journals...
Current Top-Rated Posters
| Rating | Posts |
|---|
| Mark in Seattle, WA | 5.00 | 72 | | Michael in Cave Creek, AZ | 5.00 | 181 | | Kenneth in Lees Summit, MO | 5.00 | 936 | | Neil in New Albany, OH | 5.00 | 9 | | Lara in Driftwood, TX | 4.00 | 1 | | David in Ocoee, FL | 4.00 | 227 | | Deborah in Las Vegas, NV | 4.00 | 5 | | David in Los Angeles, CA | 4.00 | 3 | | Arla in Gilbert, AZ | 4.00 | 2 | | Ted in Marstons Mills, MA | 4.00 | 1 |
|
|
|
|
2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/23/2004
I had my structurals done, in CO (expensive, but not quite as high as CA) and it ran me about $2,400. For this I got
- Stamped footing/foundation design and plan/drawings
- Open hole inspection (to verify soils report/foundation design/soil match)
- Spec'ing beams, spans, interior footings, and rebar schedules for walls
- Locating bearing walls, spec'ing headers and blocking for those walls
Hope this helps.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/30/2004
Kelly,
I am installing geothermal and have done a bit of research. I'll dump it here and hopefully it will give you a starting point.
The most important thing is the quality of the installer, period. You can take the nicest equipment and make it work horribly if the installer doesn't know what they are doing.
I have looked at waterfurnace and several other brands of geothermal units. (www.waterfurnace.com, www.eposch.com). Esentially, a geothermal unit is a heat pump (common in the midwest) that is tied to the ground (with a loop of piping or to a well) and energy is pulled from that loop instead of the air, meaning that the heat will work even when it's really cold. The websites above will give you details on how this works. Your electric bill will be higher, but your gas bill will be almost zero (hot water heating, and that will be lower since a geothermal unit can pre-heat your hot water using a device called a desuperheater). In the summer, the heat pulled from your house when you run the air conditioner is used to heat your hot water, and there is generally enough heat that in the summer, you get all your hot water for free just for running your AC.
Geothermal is kinda tough to bid and price, because in some areas, there are not many qualified installers. I've had some great installers out here, but they try to sell the technology like it's space shuttle parts because they don't think you have anyone to compare too. However, there are web-based dealers of geothermal systems that can give you a system price for your house and let you check the local guys.
On my project, I'm having a local guy install the loop field (the most important part, since you can't get at it easily later) but I'm buying my geothermal unit from a vendor in another state, because I'm saving about 40% on the unit cost.
I have heard of people having problems with geothermal, and it has always fallen into one of these two categories:
1) Loop field sized improperly or installed incorrectly. Let me stress this - Don't skimp here.
2) Using the latest new wave geothermal units. Some manufacturers (and virtually all furnace makers (trane, etc) sell geo units) have had problems with first generation products (bad circuit boards, etc) that had some bugs. most of the common ones now have solid records.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/1/2004
Geothermal has actually been around a while, and the technology is identical to the air based heat pump that people have been installing a while. What is new is that more homeowners like us are looking at them for residential use.
For my system, which is tied to radiant heat, it's important that the radiant heat be designed to be fed by a geothermal system, but I can swap in a boiler if I choose. I'm still planning on a geothermal system, but I went over budget on my excavation (lots of nasty rock hidden deep below) so I may fall back to an efficient boiler and upgrade some time in the future.
A good dealer/installer will tell you what assumptions he is making about the loop design, and what "fudge factors" he is building in to give a little extra margin to make sure that your system will work well. (For example, they might assume that the ground is a couple of degrees colder, and thus lengthen the loop. Although it would cost a bit more (1%) it would ensure that there is adequate heat transfer from the loop).
I highly recommend talking to Heidi at eposch (www.eposch.com) even if you buy somewhere else. She has been selling geothermal units for 17 years I believe, and has been very knowledgable and helpful.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/1/2004
Oh, and also, one thing that you don't want them to do is "fudge" the load calculation to size the heating/cooling unit. If you put in too big of unit, you spend more than you need and end up with problems with dehumidification & such, depending on your climate.
It's really important to make sure your installer does a load calculation to size the unit. (That is good advice for any heating/cooling system, but geo it's really good advice). A lot of HVAC guys don't know how to do this right and just guess from similar houses that didn't have callbacks. The guys who do know how will show them to you.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/7/2005
Nothing surprising there... masonry fireplaces are getting pretty rare. Walk through the McMansion neighborhood down the road, and you won't see a single one... cost, building envelope efficiency... but the biggest factor is the EPA! Around here, labor is so expensive that a masonry fireplace (unless it's a prefab) can only compete with the most expensive ($6K+) direct vent units. All depends where you want to spend your money, but when the guy mixing mortar takes home $180 a day in cash, it's gonna be expensive. Building envelope - regular fireplaces are flues for your heated air, even with a damper. The damper also becomes a conduction zone, where you have cold and hot on each side of a surface with a high thermal coefficient, so it's not going to be as efficient, although all (even DV) fireplaces have some of these issues. Finally, in my county, and most of my state, you cannot install a regular masonry fireplace... only EPA-approved wood burning or gas inserts - which means an engineered combustion chamber with fans and whatnot if you want to burn wood, otherwise, gas/DV. I suspect this will be more and more common, but has been the norm here for quite a while.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/27/2005
Every bank will be different, so if you have a good person to talk to,
it will help.
Generally, they are looking for a list of materials that will dictate
the quality and level of finish, so that they can properly value the
project. Then, you have to build your house, and these materials need
to be the minimum level finish. For example, if you tell the bank that
you are putting in granite countertops, and then get short on money at
the end and put in Formica, you'll be in violation of these specs, and
then comes the problem - If your appraisal doesn't have enough equity
because of a lower finish/quality, then you might not be able to
qualify for the permanent financing and the bank would be stuck with
the house...
My advice - If you are pretty sure you are going to have enough equity
to qualify for your construction loan with a completed house value of
moderate finishes, spec the moderate finishes, and when you put in
what you really planned (stainless steel appliances, granite, wood
floors, etc.) you'll just be building above spec. Where this doesn't
work is if you don't have an expensive enough house to justify the
money you are spending with the equity you have... For a good project, you really do want to know as much as you can. For
the mid details, give your best guess. Your framer/panelized company can
help with headers/lumber/structural bits.
Things they will want:
Roof type and grade/warranty Siding/Exterior type and quality
Flooring type/quality
Fixture type/quality
appliance type/quality Window type wood/vinyl Insulation type
Stud framing type (2x4 or 2x6) or other materials
Foundation type
Perimeter drain present?
Sanitary system type
Water supply type Heating type Plumbing supply material type...
A word of caution - Some of these things are used by some banks to
decided if they should finance the project. Any really weird house
might have problems getting financing (by really "weird" I'm talking
about straw bale, rammed earth) because the bank doesn't understand it.
Weird shapes are OK though. :)
Good luck,
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/10/2006
"In this house we obey the laws of thermodynamics" - Homer Simpson
I would research it, but be VERY WARY. I have a degree in heat
transfer, and perhaps this could be an _effective_ R-value, for a
particular climate, a-la radiant barriers in attics, etc., but it sounds
like marketing hype, since EPS tends to be on the 3-R to 6-R/inch scale.
It might FEEL like R-60, especially if the seams are detailed
properly. The biggest heat loss is generally air
infiltration. You can fix a lot of air infiltration with
housewrap.
This kind of marketing is common everywhere - all building products,
especially now that building energy efficiently is becoming more
important, are trying to sell using claims, some valid, some not.
For example, many ICF manufacturers advertise their ICF's has having an
'effective R-50' wall. I live in an ICF house, and it's great, and
perhaps, feels and heats like an R-50, especially subjectively when
compared to an average stick-frame house. But if I take the
approximate R-value of the components, which is 2 5/8" of ~R-3.6 foam on
each side, and 6" of concrete at R-0.9 per inch, I get a real value of
R-19.4 for the foam and R-5 for the concrete, so it's "really" an
R-24...
Virtually every manufacturer is doing this kind of stuff. Local
window companies here are advertising R-30 windows, which are not
really. Every building material has some value... Some house
companies offer a wall with a particular R-value, but to get that R-value, they are counting the insulative properties of the drywall (low,
but there) and the air boundary layer transitions on the inside and
outside of the walls (again, small)...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/6/2005
You can't do any "real" planning until you have your plans - all other
prices/quotes/estimates will be based on other ballparks or other
plans. And you really need numbers that match what you are building, so
that it matches your budget. Get your plans as early as possible, once
you know what you want. Then spend the next year (it will be a lot of
work) and plan out every detail, and locate every supplier and sub, and
start meeting and building a relationship with them. It will make your
project go much smoother. Get them early, so that all of your hard work
is relevant.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/20/2004
If you live near water, it can be MUCH cheaper to install
geothermal. A properly designed geothermal system (read SYSTEM!)
will give great comfort. Some things to keep in mind:
1) Low plenum temperatures do need to be overcome, but is usually done
with a higher mass flow rate (volume of air). Designed right, it
will feel the same.
2) It's great if you couple it with radiant, since then you are using water-> water.
3) It's not really free, but it is cheap - Probably equivalent to
running your AC for both heating and cooling. Geoexchange units
are typically rated with a COP (Coefficient of Performance) of 2-3 or
so, meaning for every Btu/watt of energy you put into the compressor,
you get out 2x-3x (even high 3's, e.g. 3.5) the amount of energy from the
ground. In heating mode, the electricity consumed mostly
generates heat, which helps heat your house. In the summer, with
an option called a desuperheater, you can actually heat all of your
domestic hot water with the hot air you remove from inside your house.
4) If things go wrong with the loop field, you are looking at some bucks
to get things fixed. In my case, we would have used six 180'
vertical bores, each with a loop of pipe in it (down and back out) and
grouted with a thermally enhanced grout. This would be tied to a
geoexchange unit that would convert the geothermal temperature
difference to ~120 degree water, used to feed my radiant and pre-heat
DHW. Loop fields are typically:
a) Pond or lake field - A big loop of pipe on the bottom of a lake or pond. Low cost, best heat transfer.
b) horizontal trench - Dig hundreds of feet of trench, lay pipe in, backfill.
c) Vertical wells - Used in rocky soil, size constrained lots.
d) Open system - Pull water from one well, extract heat, put down another well.
I ended up not installing geothermal - Too expensive for me (~$13K more than AC and a 95% efficient condensing boiler).
Hope this helps.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/4/2005
North of Denver, two acres will run you $165K. In the Boulder area, an acre will top $800K, if you can find it. People buy houses on
1/4-acre lots for $750K, and then bulldoze the house without ever
walking in it...
Kinda sad...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/22/2006
Marsha,
I hope this gets to you before you get into problems. The Form-a-Drain is 8" thick, meaning your footings will be 8" thick, but they should be located deep in the ground. The exact depth will depend on your location, and is mandated by the local building departments. Generally, this depth is 24"-48", depending on how cold things get in your area. The idea is that moisture in the ground can freeze and cause a footing to heave, wrecking your house, unless the footing is buried deep enough. So the Form-a-Drain is correct, but you need to have dug down to put the Form-a-Drain in the ground.
Once the footings are poured, you will need to pour a cement or block wall to go from the footings to above grade, and then the framing (wood) portion of your house sits on this short wall, called a stem wall.
Also, ICF walls are heavier, and may require thicker footings, although my ICF walls were formed up using Form-a-Drain.
Generally the building department will want to inspect everything BEFORE you pour any concrete.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/27/2004
I am midway through construction of my ICF house. It will likely cost you more than people are letting on. It's one thing to check sheets for a typical construction (framing) house, another to ensure footings and rebar are all spec'ed right, that your steel for lintels, slump, aggregate size, and wood-> ICF connections are correct.
I ended up paying $2,400 for the engineering on my ICF house, (2,700 sf + full size basement) - Also, depending on the jurisdiction, you may have to pay the engineer or his agent to inspect the walls, because many building departments are shirking the responsibility when it comes to ICF walls, even though they are pretty much identical.
Finally, from the sound of your project, I'd highly recommend hiring someone local for your engineering. Ideally, your engineer should design your footings for your soil and the ICF walls extra weight, and when you get into problems with a building inspector who doesn't understand the wall, your engineer will be very valuable, as a PE can trump an inspector virtually everywhere.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/7/2005
I started out keeping a log and tracking every set of blueprints - then I realized I was spending so much time nagging and chasing plans, I gave up. A big advantage to designing your own plans, instead of buying internet plans, is that often you can get the drawings. My contract with my designer stipulated that I owned the plans. I got plot files and AutoCAD drawings, and that it couldn't be reproduced without MY permission. Kinda turns the tables a bit. I paid ~ $1.20 per finished square foot to turn my plans (done in Home Designer) into plans to take to the building department. See the other plans threads; I'd have done them myself if I had realized how easy the building department was to work with. When my designer was done, I got a full set of plot files to take down to the blueprint place, and a full set of AutoCAD files for my own future editing.
Anyway, I digress. I evolved to where I would only print 3-7 sets of plans, and I would tailor the set, i.e. the mechanical guys didn't need sheets with details on trim or cabinetry, etc.
As construction progressed, I began updating my drawings in AutoCAD, so that the drawings would reflect as-built conditions, and that eliminated any mess-ups - Of course, I did also involve a concrete saw on a window opening before I started doing this... :) Not sure about the best way, but hopefully these ideas will help.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/2/2005
I have a flat roof, no deck on it. There are systems for putting
a deck over a roof, the deck has little adjustable risers that you
raise/lower to get the deck level; Water falls through onto the roof
below and drains as normal.
After lots of research, my dream roof would have been welded stainless
steel. Expensive, durable, and hard to find. I've only
found one guy from Europe who would come over and do it, I suspect his
travel costs were more than my entire roof installed.
I chose a fully adhered commercial 65 mil EPDM roof, installed over a
3/8" dens-deck class A fire rating underlayment, over 3/4" OSB
sheathing on trusses.
Alternatives are ballasted EPDM (but the rocks can blow off in high
winds, and have to be moved/offloaded to inspect the membrane), single
ply TPO (new, usually white, but not as long of track record as EPDM)
or BUR (Built up roof). Nobody around here will even do built up
on residential work, the insurance costs are too high.
The fully adhered allows easy inspection. I beefed up the trusses
over a section where I plan on installing a 15x25 patio some day, using
one of the leveling systems.
Hope this helps,
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/15/2004
If you drawings are really good, then it might be worth a try, but I
found that incomplete drawings (lacking engineering, steel schedules,
etc) pretty much just resulted in subs giving me a WAG (Wild A$$ Guess)
that was high. Once I had my full set of drawings complete, then
I was able to get real bids and the numbers were much closer to what I
ended up paying.
One the plus side, talking to people early helps you adjust your design
construction to save money or add features. On the minus side, a
lot of subs will pretty much laugh at you if you look like you don't
know what you are doing. Some folks I dealt with were like
that until I had some other details.
Don't start seriously until you have a complete set of drawings.
A lot of the details in those drawings can mean a lot of things price
wise.
You might look at some of the home user cad packages to get a basic plan which might help.
Good luck,
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/16/2004
Don't forget that a lot of these guys have to rent their equipment, or purchase and maintain it. I've found excavation to be expensive relative to other trades, for the amount of time they are actually "working" (e.g. compared to roofing or stucco).
Not that that price seems even close to reasonable. I'm getting a 1,500-gallon tank with a leach field for four bedrooms (tank sized for five) for $5,750, but that includes several hours of probing for a diggable area to set the tank (probing between subsurface boulders) and then piping to everything. My leach field is around 300 feet from my tank, with some wicked rock-intensive digging between points A and B. Even after adjusting for higher costs of living in CA, the bid seems high. Don't forget transport costs of the rock/pipe/etc. If you are a ways from the rock supplier, import/export costs can add up. Do you have to export the extra fill/material? Don't forget to add that on too.
Also, find out what type of pipe they are using. Code here requires a specific heavy grade pipe on each side of the tank, but cheap guys will save $40 by switching to the lightest stuff they can once they get past the tank, whereas the better installers will use the heavy gasketed pipe throughout the system. My excavator/neighbor said that the lighter pipe will fail over time, especially if you ever have to have the line chased/cleaned.
As Ken alluded to earlier, don't fall into the trap of getting sick of subs and doing the work yourself (not that you were about to, but just as a rule). I constantly have to keep myself from jumping in and doing stuff because it's easier for me to do it than to find a good sub and get it all explained. Even with detailed specs and plans, you still have to keep a close eye to make sure it's done how you want. I have started to have some great experiences with some of my subs (plumbing, electrical, stucco) and these guys just get things done right, and ask me when there is a question. My project goes from an angry monkey on my back (when I'm working on it every night after work) to a fun process when I have good subs and keep myself from doing too much.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/18/2006
Maria,
A rough guess for early planning would be 20', but you will not be able to build your house in most locales without an engineer designinging and specifying the types of beams and supports. The exact spacing will depend on what material, size, and grade of beams and posts you are using, what the house is like above the basement (bearing walls, flooring, radiant heat, etc) as well as other loads such as truss bearing and snow loads. An engineer will need to specify this in most cases.
Sorry I can't be more helpful, but there are too many variables to be able to say for sure.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/31/2005
Pete,
I used the soy-based stuff (biobased), the installer is in
Longmont. It costs around $1.55 psf for me, and definitely sealed
things up very tight. Icynene was similar in cost.
Drawbacks - Well, it took the installer about 2 1/2 weeks to
spray my house (2,900 sf), which was painful on my schedule. And
it costs a fair bit more than most other insulations.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/9/2005
Yep! The air infiltration is the big difference with icynene and
biobased. I used biobased, the 'soybean' based foam.
Actually, soybean oil is used as the spray agent, the foam is the same
as icynene I believe. At any rate, it tastes terrible, and the
rodents wouldn't eat the leftovers in the dumpster outside.
In our house, we specifically wanted the 'conditioned attic' type
installation now allowed by IRC2004 amendment (and even preferred by a
lot of building science folks) - Our attic was pretty small, but you do
build it exactly like a fridge - No leaks at all. This does have
the advantage of reducing roof penetrations, knocking my flat roof
venting needs from 27 'pop up vents' to zero, so I now have only 3
plumbing stacks and 2 boiler in/out flues.
My walls were ICF, so we didn't have the issues of if the sub would seal around the windows.
I found the price difference between the two (Icynene vs biobased) to
be less than 1%. There is exactly one decent (returns calls,
gives bids) installer of each in the state of Colorado. :)
Hope this helps,
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/11/2005
Wow! 2 things to clarify:
1) The biobased guy I used had just started. His bid was $1.55 psf
(after I wrangled with him) for attics only. His inexperience
cost him and me money, it took him weeks to spray the attic with 11" of
biobased. In a lot of places, I probably have 18". It took
him a while, but I'm happy. This was also just about a year ago,
before katrina, oil, building materials, etc. His pricing may
have been too cheap.
2) The Icynene guy who bid out my project only does 6" of Icynene,
period. He sprays a lot of fancy custom homes here at the ski
resorts, and even there, 6" of icynene. He says by stopping the
air infiltration, that provides the majority of savings, and that
inches beyond 6" are just a waste of money.
I had it made up in my head that I wanted 11"... That went nicely with my ICF walls.
Unfortunately, the biggest expense of this foam has to be A) the special
equipment these guys invest in and B) the setup and masking, etc.
Based on what my Icynene guy said, adding insulation below would be a
smart idea, and easy to do. I only had my garage sprayed with 3",
to seal things up and keep the decking above the dew point, and
although I have radiant out there too, I don't turn it on.
Bringing the warm cars in (a truck and a VW beetle) seems to keep the
garage above 60 non-stop thus far, but I'm sure that will fall some as
things get colder.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/23/2004
On the note of construction guides - there are a wide variety, some are
really bad from what I've seen, and some are great.
I'm using a guy, who is not affiliated with any "big" company - he has
his company, (you are basically paying for his and his office staff's
service) and does budgets, initial schedules, etc., which he supplies in
binders (including things like site maps, lien waivers, contracts,
insurance-verification sheets, etc). He then supplies a list of
pre-approved contractors and suppliers that he has worked with. This list is gold. He updates it every week, and I get the latest
copy.
I am the only one who really manages the project, but when I stumble
into a problem, say, low water pressure, he knows various solutions,
and better yet, various people I might want to talk to for more
ideas. Anytime I have questions, a phone call or email helps me
out. And every week or so, he stops by and walks the site with me,
pointing out places to watch or things that are looking good.
Required? Absolutely not - I do think it helped me with the
planning phase, though. He charges a flat fee per finished
square foot.
The subs on his approved list are pretty much gold - some of them do so
much work for this guy's clients that they have learned where to bid to
be cost competitive, and they have a vested interest in keeping the
quality of the work up. My electrician and plumber came from this
list, and are fantastic guys you could trust with anything. And
when I find people I might consider working with (other sites, phone
book, etc.), my consultant will go verify their work, do a background
check, verify insurance and references, check supplier accounts,
etc. Just makes things easier for me.
So I think I'm getting my money's worth - but it is not required.
If I built again, I'd do it without, only because I'm pretty knowledgeable now.
J
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/11/2005
What type/model of grinders are you guys using for these?
Great work. They look fantastic.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/16/2005
Joe,
Well put. Absolute poetry. I've not heard anybody describe the big potential pitfall of getting too deep in owner-building so well. Yeah, you might be able to do each of these better than most of your subs... But can you really afford it, and is it worth what it can do to the rest of your life?
Smart advice.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/4/2004
I ended up writing my own spec sheets. It really helped me to cement what I wanted, and get it all in writing. I started out by writing a bulleted, organized list of every detail and grade/quality I wanted. (With a new document for each subsystem/trade). Then I talked to subs, and often, would realize that I needed to add to my specifications... i.e., the Electrician would ask if I wanted an ATS (Automatic Transfer Switch)... I did, but didn't have it in my specs, so I would go back and update my specs. By the time I got done bidding with 3-5 guys, my specs were pretty solid, and were simply attached to my contract. Put a version and date at the top, so you can be sure that you know what version people are referring to. The other thing you may find, is that some guys don't read the specs, and end up calling you to ask questions that are identified/listed in the specs. If they do, then that should be a red flag that they don't have enough attention to detail to really understand your project.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/5/2004
Both... Sortof... Most lumberyards will do a takeoff for you on materials they sell. I built using ICF - My ICF Distributor did the takeoff. As I was drawing and refining my plans, I did get bids, but didn't expect them to be the numbers I would go with, since the plans were changing, and on many things, I was 6-12 months out. (i.e. my stucco guy also did drywall, and gave me a bid for both while I was still doing footings). But absolutly talk to your potential subs while you are designing - Making changes then doesn't cost anything (per se) and they can help you make things better and/or cheaper. For instance, on my house (you can see details on my website to the left) we had a "U" shape in the foundation, to form a courtyard with a framed view of the foothills behind us. It's great because from there, you can't see any sign of civilization, 'except the house. I digress. We had designed the U shape, because the courtyard was a feature we wanted. Working early with one potential ICF sub, he pointed out that I could pour the basement/foundation wall straight across, while also pouring the "U' that we had designed in. The U supported the walls above, while a structural concrete slab roof would form the patio. For about $800 in additional materials, and a weekend of my labor, we added a 14x14 wine cellar/vault. The extra material cost was also offset by less waterproofing and less backfill. (The Vault has been great for an OB that does some work myself, because I put a door on it and was able to lock all my tools in there safe.) So talk to everyone early. If you listen, most of these guys will tell you all sorts of stuff that will make your life easier and help you get a better productl. Do keep in mind that your bids will expire... Material costs pretty much always goes up (inflation and specific events/shortages (i.e. steel)). So expect your costs to go up, depending on your area.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/6/2004
See my post in another thread about drawing your own plans -
These plans won't include specific engineering for soils, excessive
wind/snow. They may not come with electrical sheets. Plan
on spending quite a bit of money on engineering/stamps, even if an
architect stamps it, depending on your area. A plan company
cannot provide an engineered foundation - the foundation design has to
be done to exactly match your soils and lot.
If you are in an area with few engineering requirements, it might be the way to go.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/28/2005
Be sure to check your local/state codes. Capturing water
from your roof and doing anything other than letting it go on it's way
to the natural "general drainage" here in Colorado is technically
illegal. It's not like there are "impoundment police" that come
around and inspect where your gutters drain to, but if you have plans
showing a water catchment system, it might get static if your
jurisdiction is governed by a state engineer.
Here, all impoundments (stopping water, by dam, tank, etc.), wells, etc.
all fall under the state engineer. By capturing water on my roof
and using it for watering my garden, technically I'm depriving some
senior or junior water-right holder in that "basin" of some of their
water... you certainly wouldn't find a development here
reprocessing their neighborhood gutters/storm drains for water to water
the golf course; that would violate the whole "flow" and mess up
someone's water rights...
It's a big mess, water taps outside of an urban area in an area that
has municipal water are over $30K now, just for the water-supply
tap. If I had spent $30K on water in 1970, I could sell those
water rights for over three million right now...
Anyway, my only real point here is to just advise that you walk
lightly/quietly unless you know your area's rules. (If they are
encouraged, great!)... water law is weird, and I suspect
Colorado, being a state with a lot of headwaters, gets more scrutiny
than states farther down the line. My gutters happen to drain to
a very flat pasture, where, presumably, the water could continue to
flow down to the proper water-rights holders... my pasture just
happens to absorb a lot of it on the way. :)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/1/2005
Because of excavation difficulties (250' of solid rock between my
electric and the house!) I bought an 8,500 watt generator and ran that
until I could get my service feeders run. All I can say is the
cost of the generator is nothing. Expect to burn a
minimum of 5 gallons a day of gas, and by the time you get dried in and
your electrical in, the generator will probably need a rebuild.
It's hard on it. I didn't have to worry about theft, but it's a
very legitimate worry. I actually had an old generator that died
my 3rd day of construction that I left out as a "token" but nobody took
it. :( It gets real old hauling gas up to your site every other
day. I used 3 5 gallon gas cans, and would usually have to fill
them up every other day. At the current gas prices here, it
was $30 per fill up, usually 3 fills per week. Plus the noise. When I got real power, I was in heaven.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/18/2005
There is a converse to this - if your sub supplies the material, and it
is defective, he's the one who fixes it. If you supply the
material, you have to do the fight yourself... This is of course,
assuming you have a decent sub.
I ran into a problem where my basement slab was poured, by a sub who
let it dry out too quick. I got shrink cracking, which while not
a real structural problem, was a cosmetic problem.
Now, I saved some money because I bought the concrete, and I had
negotiated with the concrete companies myself, building an ICF
house. I paid the sub a flat per square foot rate for
pouring/finishing.
When I got the shrink cracking, I called him up to the site. He
looked at it and says 'this is the problem', 'er, that is the
problem'... When I pinned him down, he says 'Bad concrete, not my
problem'. Now, I know the concrete is great, and that it was the
pouring/finishing problem. The same concrete was great for my
other four flatwork pours (different finisher), all my ICF walls, my three
footing pours, etc. But I have the choice of A) Getting an
expert, paying out of pocket, and trying to get something done, or B)
suck it up, deal with the cosmetic cracking, and move on. I chose
B, but there is some merit to having/letting subs supply materials.
Some trades (framers) expect you to supply the materials, others (plumbers/electricians) generally want to supply them.
If you are getting good bids from lots of subs, usually they wont be
beating you up too bad. Also, if you're short on stuff (missing a
plumbing fitting, short on wire, etc.) you can expect your sub to really
sock it to you when he has to make an extra trip.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/3/2004
I thought I had my lighting all figured out, and we had found many
fixtures we liked online, at great prices.
On a whim, we stopped by a new lighting store near our site. One of the
salesladies there only does new construction, and is currently training
for a particular and rare lighting design certification. She will do a
full lighting design for $100, and credit it back if you buy fixtures
from her. She knew that we had been shopping and was going to give us
their contractor price up front, and then knock another 10% off. Free
delivery to our site (which we pay only 2.9% tax at).
So, feeling like there were some weaknesses in our lighting design
(despite many hours working on it) we gave her a shot. She put
together a fantastic layout, which included several site visits (with
and without us) to get a good feel for the room layouts. She also did a
walk-through with us and our electrician.
Now here is the thing - she actually SAVED us a ton of money. Being
that our home was generally considered a "luxury" home, we did our best
working from things we liked, the Parade of Homes, other floorplans,
and our draftsperson. This expert removed quite a few expensive cans,
made the shape and distribution of light very precise, and made all of
the lighting much more dramatic.
I suspect we got great service partially because it's a new
store
working on getting established, but their prices beat almost every
internet price. She matched prices on some killer deals we had on
specific fixtures we knew we wanted. And the service has been topnotch, even working code compliance issues while helping us develop
some ideas that had never been seen before.
I think most of us have found some great deals on the Internet, and put
ourselves at a big advantage over many "real builders" by using these
new resources, but it makes it all too easy to forego some of the
service and help that people in your area (besides your subs) can
offer. Don't forget to give them a try!
Still, hard to beat the Internet for information and keeping good 'ol American competition going...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/7/2006
It should be doable, no problem. Here in the US this kind of
architectual feature is called a cantilever, and is done using wood TJI
beams, or steel beams. With 35 cm of bearing, you ought to have
no problem.
In the US, we would have to have an engineer specify the type and
placement of beams. Otherwise, your lumber or steel people ought
to be able to size them for you.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/6/2006
It's good to be there for another reason - It's a little known secret,
but 99% of the time, the building inspector IS YOUR FRIEND. It's
another set of eyes, making sure things are done right.
As mentioned above, being there can answer questions for him and make
things pass, but also, you can get feedback from the inspector.
Things might be legal and meet code, but look sloppy, or could have
been done better. You can then go back to your sub (whom you've
not paid in full yet, hopefully) and say "I don't like that this looks
like x, to be done properly it really should be y) and 99% of the time,
they will come fix it to get that last 10%. Managed right, it's
like having a paid inspector reviewing work.
Of course, many building inspectors don't care... But if managed
right, the inspector can be excited about your project, and his work
will be better too. He's used to dealing with GC's and subs all
day who are trying to skate by on the cheapest cra$ that they can get
away with, as long as the finished product 'looks' OK. Here he's
working on a project with someone who can be genuinely interested in
good work, and in his opinion. YMMV.
My building inspector was great, and generally never had any
problems. In fact, he gave me my CO without my kitchen sink being
installed (it was sitting on the floor) because he knew as an O-B, I
would finish my sink, and he was happy with the quality of the
project. He failed an HVAC termination, and I was glad he did, I
had missed it. And he was hard on my framers (what little framing
I had) but that was good, because after he beat up my framers for
missing some nails, they spend a day double/triple nailing, bracing,
pressure blocking. They went way beyond what was required, thanks
to a good lashing by the inspector.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/23/2006
The exact inspections required will vary based on your local codes/inspectors and your specific house - Some houses will require different inspections based on the types of materials or methods you are using. A safe rule of thumb is to not cover anything until the inspector has seen it.
Here is a rough list, not all of these are required in all places, and keep in mind that in some localities, inspection protocols might be different.
If I recall correctly, I had the following inspections.
(I'm also listing a few that didn't apply to me, but are common in my area, to give you an idea)
Many inspections are sometimes performed at the same time as other inspections, for example, the building setback and footing inspections are performed at the same time, and occur on the same day as the wildfire hazard inspection, but the wildfire hazard inspection is a different inspector...
-Open hole soil inspection (post excavation), Wildfire hazard, building setback/location, footing width/reinforcement (pre-pour)
-ICF or foundation wall inspection, pre-pour (This had to be done by my engineer at my expense, the county inspectors won't inspect ICF over 8' high).
-In-ground plumbing inspection
-Electrical service in-ground inspection, electrical service temp power inspection
-Radon Mitigation inspection, footing drain inspection
(They didn't care to inspect the radiant piping in my jurisdiction).
Main level ICF wall inspection (pre-pour)
Framing 4-way inspection (Framing, HVAC, Plumbing Rough, Electrical Rough)
Weatherboarding/Stucco Inspection, mid roof inspection (getting firedeck on roof inspected before covering with roofing)
Insulation Inspection (spray foam walls and attic, sealed attic. Otherwise just walls here, then attic is inspected at building final.
Sheetrock/drywall inspection
Electrical Trim inspection
Building Final (Building overall, firedoors, health/safety, plumbing/HVAC trim, roof, etc inspected here).
There are others. Some jurisdictions require mid stucco inspections, deck inspections (done at building final here).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/8/2004
We got our loan in February, mostly so we could get
our utilities and road started (the banks won't want you having any
work done before they have signed your loan, since they want first lien
position). March - Finalized plans, applied for F&F (footing
and foundation) permit. My plans were pretty much finalized, but my
designer still had some little interior details to clean up. By
applying for an F&F permit, we were able to get going, but in our
case, we knew that the incremental changes would not change anything we
were doing for the next few months, so it was OK. In our jurisdiction,
they turned around the F&F permit in two days, and the full permit in
10, but call your building department and ask. (In hindsight, I
should have drawn our plans - I have the CAD skills, but was worried
about working with the building department. I've found the building
department is very easy to work with, and wish I had done them myself - we would have started a month or two earlier and saved a lot of money). April
- Started digging. We ended up digging and blasting rock for over three
weeks, went over budget and over schedule, starting in excavation. May 10th - Poured footings, started ICF June - July - Finished basement ICF, framed floor, stacked and finished pouring main level ICF's around the 4th of August. August - Waited for truss plant to get act together September - Waited for framers to get act together. October - Got framing done, had membrane roof installed November - Electrical and tin done (in a week!) Plumbing still going on. If
you look at my schedule, I'd be WAY ahead if I had better resolved the
problems with my truss plant and my framers. But I wanted my particular
framers (experienced with ICF). The ICF's went up ahead of schedule. We
actually almost caught up with the three weeks we lost due to excavation
until we hit the truss delay. If you can, order your trusses
early! I wanted to wait until I knew my walls wouldn't move (i.e. were
poured) so I could make sure that everything fit exactly, but that was
more a constraint on the architecture. Truss plants usually have an 8-week lead time out here. Good luck, John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/27/2004
I think generally, you never want to connect additional drains to
your subterranean footing drain... Imagine if you get a big downpour,
fill a surface drain or gutter connected to your footing drain - You
then provide a direct pathway to get water _TO_ your footings, a bad
idea. Keep the two drains separate. 6:00 is a good idea, or
using the black corrugated pipe with lots of perforations you don't
have to worry. Be sure this pipe goes to daylight.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/28/2004
I really liked them, but was told by a window guy who sold pella that they have had some problems. I did however find a product that attached to the inside of windows and french doors at home depot that creates a similar solution, although it is a unit mounted flush inside the glass instead of between the panes, but should work on almost any window/french door.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/28/2004
I'll drop my $.02. I researched a bunch of ICF's, and ended up doing
my ICF work. But in all my research and classes, I did learn a lot. 1)
Anyone who says you don't need to brace is fooling themselves or has
lax standards for straight and plumb. Even regular concrete walls are
usually braced. As Ken said, you need something to walk around on
while you pour. I watched guys with ladders run up and down as the pump
moved along on a largely unbraced ICF installation. It's hard work, you
need a lot of ladders, it's dangerous, and you don't get a good
finish/level on the top of the wall because you are moving the ladder
so much. My ICF distributor rented me braces/scaffold system for $5.00
per level per brace. I needed around 100 braces on each level. (A brace
at every corner, every opening, and every 6'). ICF bracing on the
other hand, lets you walk along the entire wall with the pump at a good
height for control and safety. Plus, you can adjust plumb to get good
straight walls. No matter what wall system you use, good bracing and
work platforms are a really good idea. Before you commit to a
system, go to several pours of the system, and similar systems. My ICF
of choice changed 3 times over a one-year period as I found newer and
better systems. I ended up using Nudura, and the courses lock together,
so there is no gluing any joints unless you make a bad cut, in which
case you glue them back toegether. Some forms need gluing, some don't.
Some say they don't, but they really do (hence the need to go to pours and
watch). Concrete wall systems is a fledgling industry, and a lot of the
contractors and suppliers will beat each other's kidneys out
(badmouthing, lies, etc) so you really have to do you own research.
There are some great guys out there, and some fantastic products. On
average, we did about 1,200-1,500 square feet of wall per day, 2 guys.
However, that is a bit deceiving, and a big false selling point of many
systems (SIPS generally excluded, they do go fast). Sure, I had my
walls up in 3 days. It takes a lot of time to do the little things,
like installing window bucks, bracing weak spots, installing utility
penetrations, installing beam/truss/ledger pockets, etc. We generally
took about 3 weeks per level, starting from footings, stacking block,
doing all the windows/doors/penetrations, installing bracing, pouring,
waiting a couple days to let things set up, and tearing everything down
and cleaning up (2 guys). (These
numbers are for square foot of
foam wall). I paid about $2.75/sf for foam form (it has gone up now,
with fuel prices), and then quite a bit for rebar (probably $.80/sf,
including rebar for footings) (I had #5, but your engineer will spec
it). Concrete went for around $1.15/sf, Bracing rental cost $.33/sf,
misc. supplies (tape to keep the top edges of the ICF clean for the
next
level, foam glue, soda's, etc.) was another $.35/sf. Window bucks cost
me around $1.00 per square foot, using Vbuck, and buying the fancy
corner bracing. Pump rucks cost another $0.52 per square foot. There
were some other expenses too. Truth is, putting up the walls is
easy. The scary time is when you have the pump trucks there, the
concrete there, and you have a lot of people who don't know what they
are doing, everybody's learning. I had the distributor there, pumping and
vibrating concrete right alongside me, along with a hired experienced
ICF guy helping me the entire time. And it was still tough. Your
family/friends had better be really committed to working on it, or your
pours will be tough. I was really lucky. Good luck! Do
lots of research. There were a few nights I was thinking I had made a
mistake, but all in all it worked out good.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/28/2004
(Oh, BTW - The only thing I ever considered a possible mistake was the DIY part... I'm glad I did it though, just be sure you can really commit the resources you need, and have the support of your family).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/2/2005
Utility Penetrations - I was DIY, so mine was a bit different. As
Ken said, basically you are blocking out anything that you want to go
through the wall to the exterior. I used PVC pipe for most of
them, sized per the needed pass-through (make them a bit larger than the
pipe you need to pass so that if the pipe needs a pitch, you can do
it.). Small penetrations, like wires for exterior outlets and
lights, don't worry about. My plumber installed PVC pass-throughs
for all the ICF penetrations at underground rough-in time. It's
easy to do though, if you are DIY. After the utility is through
the block-out, I filled them in with the low-expansion ICF foam glue
(really similar to Great Stuff foam). You can add block-outs for
special things too, i.e. sat TV, etc. You can do a 12' opening -
I have four, plus 8' openings over the garage doors. In the 12'
cases, you will probably need an engineer to spec the steel type and
installation. In my jurisdiction, I had to have an engineer
design the entire foundation and inspect the steel. All
foundations, even poured wall for stick frame, require a site/soil
specific design here, so it wasn't really any extra cost over stick-frame. If you screw up on the penetrations, all is
not lost. I forgot my DV fireplace opening, but a local guy core
drilled a 9" hole in the wall for me in around 10 minutes. $50
later, problem was fixed. But every penetration you can remember
will save you headaches later. For beam pockets, we built
a plug out of scrap foam that had the furring strips in it, and screwed
several layers of foam together. We then cut the beam pocket,
wrapped the plug with the smooth brown packing tape, put it into place,
and put a scrap of OSB over it. We vibrated these areas a lot,
and after the concrete cured, a claw hammer would pull the plug out,
leaving a nice, smooth pocket for the beam. One utility
location had my washer on an exterior wall, so we channeled the foam in
these locations. Ideally, you can run all of the plumbing in
interior walls, and electrical goes in with an electric chainsaw or
router. My electrician didn't blink, he just bought a new
electric chainsaw, set the depth for 2" with a homemade depth stop,
and cut away. This put the wire well past the minimum depth,
while keeping the wire from touching concrete (I have 2 5/8" of
foam). He then filled the slots back in.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/3/2005
A VERY rough rule of thumb that some folks, and indeed, the building
department here use is that labor will be about 50% of the total price
of the project, including materials, etc. So if you spent
$20K on materials for framing, you'd expect to spend another $20K on
labor. It will vary from area to area. Our geography is
expensive, but I'll bet yours might be higher for labor.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/9/2006
Just a thought on getting a local company to buy extra resources on your lot - It will likely depend on the economy in your area. I've had little luck with my resources - rock. I have thousands of tons of moss rock, sandstone from blasting, etc. Most companies don't want to mess with an one-time shot for a local supplier.
I had strong interest if I was willing to let a local rock company come haul out at will, every rock they wanted... But I didn't want to turn things into a quarry. I'm trying to work with a local landscape materials supplier to trade some of my sandstone boulders (I have 500-700 ton) for a credit for landscape materials. They would be getting them for a song, but they would have to mobilize the equipment to haul them out, so it's a big expense. Unless there is enough material (wood/rock/apples/whatever) to make it worth mobilizing the equipment, it won't be worth it to them...
I think the current supplier I'm talking to is considering it, but I can tell it's on the edge. They are
only five miles away, so trucking won't take long, but running two trucks and a huge trackhoe could very well cost $300 per hour, and they would probably need 16 hours, so their could would not be inconsequential...
Anyway, just a bit on my experience. Hopefully you have better luck, but if you do have good trees, it can't hurt to try. If it works, let us know how you approached them and what worked!
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/28/2005
Using propane for our on demand hot water and stove during the summer
(no heating turned on) we use about 7 gallons per month. We also
heat with it, and during the winter, usage is higher. We have a
500 gallon tank that we located in a pretty hidden but accessible area,
and screed with moss rocks.
A better alternative is to bury the tank - it requires a special type
of tank and inspection, and you usually have to buy the tank, although
some companies will lease buried tanks with long enough lease.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/21/2004
Even with good soils, keep a little bit of a contingency. My soils report said I had good, low expansion soil, with bedrock at 15'. I did, for one room of the house. The rest of the house was located in nearly solid rock, and I pretty much wiped out my contingency in the first 3 weeks of construction blasting!
Soils reports are good, but keep in mind that there can still be things hiding below the surface! Probably rare, but it would depend on your locale.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/26/2004
We're at drywall now, so it's a bit late. Our contingency (5%)
covered the blasting with a small pad left. :) On smaller homes,
I would probably suggest bumping up the contingency a bit. (7-10%?)
We had the soils done when we purchased the lot, four years before we
built. Where the bores were located, we originally had three done,
all in corners of the house. After the house design was finished,
and we laid it out, we had two in the house and one in the garage. No
matter what bores you have done here, your soils engineer has to do an
open hole inspection and your structural engineer has to verify that
the soils are consistent with the design.
For us, we wanted to know when we made the land offer if we were going
to need caissons and piers (common in our area) and figuring we had to
do the soils anyway, did it with the land purchase contract (as a
contingency).
With a million dollar view, we'd have paid the blasting costs either way. :)
Even our excavator, who lives in the area (next door), was
fooled. Talking with our geologist, he explained what happened. -
Over the eons, the hillside and glaciers had deposited "dobies" (bus
sized boulders) and topsoil down the hillside. Our house is built
on a "knob" on the side of the hill, where these "dobies" happened to
deposit and get filled in with soil over the millions of years.
(which makes sense, the rest of the hill is covered with moss rock and
rattlesnakes).
What I should have done (in hindsight) is have dug several "test pits"
to get a better feel for the digging. The core drill was able to
"miss" the boulders on two of the bores until they hit 12' and 15'...
Hopefully, this helps other folks. We did get a good price
(relatively) on our land - they came down around $40K once we pointed out
that we would need a significant road ($15K) a water line ($18K for the
line, $27K for the tap) and power ($7K). We did the soils
tests with an out in our contract, knowing that if a pier/caisson
foundation (which can run $40K in our area) was required, we could find
a different lot (although certainly not one with the space or view).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/16/2006
Flat is the easiest to touch up without having to repaint the entire
panel. Also, if you use a ceiling paint, pick a brand and stick
with it, and you can usually "match" even years later if needed.
(We had good luck doing this with Glidden ceiling white).
Good luck,
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/1/2005
See the other threads in these forums for geothermal
information. A well-designed geothermal system will be the
cheapest to operate, and the most expensive to install. In some
areas, geothermal can be 2-4x the cost of "conventional" propane or
natural gas to install. Propane prices increase
along the same factors as natural gas, but are generally more expensive
than natural gas and more volatile. Another thing to
keep in mind in some areas, most of our electricity is generated using
natural gas, meaning electric rates will continue to climb with natural
gas rates... Eventually alternative systems like PV and the
like will be cost competitive. But the market will decide...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/2/2005
Geothermal needs large amounts of electricity to heat and cool by
moving the hot or cold to/from the ground. Geothermal systems (in the
context of residential housing) do not produce electricity. You could
buy a big propane/diesel generator to run a geothermal system, but not
the other way around. Geothermal is essentially like an
air conditioner that you run year-round. On a normal air conditioner,
you cool the inside and push the heat out to your air conditioner
condenser in the yard where a big fan blows on it. In geothermal
cooling, you cool the inside and push the heat into the ground outside.
For
heating, the cycle is reversed, akin to if you had moved the condenser
into your house. Heating, you run the compressor in reverse,
extracting the heat from the ground and pushing it into the house.
Now,
some interesting things about how this works. I'm going to describe
the heating cycle here in more detail, but cooling is similar, although
reversed. The big thing about geothermal cooling is if you purchase a
system with a desuperheater option, in climates with a high cooling
load, the heat you extract from inside your house can be used to
pre-heat your domestic hot water, and will usually do all the water
heating during high cooling times.
(The system I describe here
is a closed-loop system - Open loops can work, but require an input
well and a second well to output water to, and can sometimes have
problems with minerals, etc. gunking things up). Out here in the west,
water is more valuable than gold, so no such thing would ever be
allowed. Your area may be different. The temperatures I use below
will be very different based on your climate, house, system, soils, and
loop field lengths. The numbers are just for illustration, but probably
pretty close to what I was expecting had I gone forward. Note also
that these temperatures could change during the course of the heating
system, especially if the loop field design was not done properly, as
more heat could be extracted or injected than the loop field can handle,
and things would start cooling down or heating up. Also, the loop field
should never be near any utilities (water, septic, leech fields, etc.)
as it could freeze your utilities up during heating.
Now, in a typical geo-heating loop, the heat-transfer fluid,
usually some kind of special low temp non-toxic antifreeze, would
be pumped into the loop field from the geothermal unit. It night leave
the house at 30 degrees (yes, below freezing) and then, after traveling
around the loop field in the balmy 55 degree temperatures underground,
come back at 52 degrees. The temperature difference there (22 degrees)
is run through a phase change in the geothermal-unit compressor, and
extracted to a higher temperature potential, say, radiant-heating
water, where the input water from the radiant system is at 90 degrees,
and exits the geothermal unit at 120 degrees. Bigger systems have
bigger flow rates and can do more heating, but because of the phase
changes properties, there are pretty significant upper limits that must
be designed for when doing geothermal work. So, keep in
mind, that by installing a geothermal system, your gas bill could be
zero, but your electricity bill will go up significantly. If
electricity is very expensive in your area, you should do an analysis
to see if it will work for you. Most good geothermal guys have
software packages that will analyze your house, determine what
geothermal unit you would need and how much piping, etc. for your
climate, and then give you a comparison and a time to return your
investment when compared to say, 85% gas furnaces and electric heat.
I
found that the energy efficiency of my house _increased_ the time to
pay back the cost of the system from 8 years (conventional
framing/insulation/windows) to almost 18 years (ICF, spray-in EPS
attic, radiant). With the expected lifetime of a geothermal unit
being long, it was probably still not a bad idea, but I could get much
quicker ROI's using other technologies, and keep my propane as a backup.
Hope
all this helps foster ideas. I think it's a great technology, but
still expensive. I found some dealers/installers sold this stuff like
it was space-shuttle parts, and others that sold it like it was nuts
and bolts at the hardware store. The quality of the installation is
critical, but it's not exactly rocket science. Doing geothermal, be
sure you really do your research on your installer, because every poor-performing system (there are many described on the Net) is due to bad
installation/design.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/22/2005
Also here in Colorado, sheetrock, lumber, steel, concrete, and plumbing
prices have risen sharply. My drywaller was up fixing a booboo (door
handle) and said that the jobs he is finishing now, that he bid two
months ago, he's finishing at a loss. I stumbled across my
plumber, and he's raising rates too. The supply houses typically raise
prices monthly, unless the item is really volatile.
El Rey, a stucco manufacturer, has been directed by the feds to send two
trucks of Portland cement to the gulf coast each week. This is a
company that has their own cement plant to make a cement-based product,
and they are being redirected. Concrete companies here have
rations for a lot of folks. Same in NM. Many contractors
can only get 20 yards a week.
The concrete issue was already occurring because China is buying a ton
of cement that used to get shipped here. Katrina just exacerbated
things.
Building costs are going to SKYROCKET.
If you have bids locked in and execute within the bid period, you
should be okay (If your subs are honoring their bids). But keep in
mind, if they are, they might be working for nothing other than their
name. If you don't have bids, it's probably too late.
If you are ordering things off of the Net, and indeed, everything arriving via truck, shipping costs have followed fuel.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/25/2005
Good points!
Two things -
Most of our cement is actually imported - and China/India are buying
it, in the free market. Hurting our price, but there really isn't
anything you can do there, short of paying subsidies.
Our steel would be cheaper than it is, but our government uses
protectionism to protect the steel mills. Understand, steel is
cheaper for everyone else than it is us, because of the tariffs.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/25/2005
If you do closed loop geothermal, it's not really a well, it's a
deep hole (usually done by a well driller!) Say, 100 or 200 feet
deep. You might save if you had a well dug and they dug all the
vertical bores for the geothermal at the same time. With closed
loop, the tubing runs down and back out, and fluid runs through the
tube, but never leaves the tube. Open loop, you draw water from a
well, run it through the geothermal unit, and then send it back down
another well.
However, with your acreage, unless it's solid rock,
you can do geothermal horizontally and save a lot of money on it.
They use long trenches instead of vertical bores. Finally,
on water sources - everyone is always more comfortable in a real estate
transaction with a municipal water source. A tap here costs
$27K-$30K, so I envy your tap fees! That said, having a well has
it's own advantages (most of the time).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/19/2005
ICF's definitely cost more up-front, period. But over the long
haul, you won't regret it. HVAC savings will vary based on what
units you choose, but ICF will make all of them use less energy.
Now, if you are heating/cooling basement space, compared to an uninsulated foundation, the savings will be huge.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/21/2005
I installed and poured all my forms myself - that saved a bunch of
money; installed-PSF of wall prices here are outrageous. My cost
for all materials, window wells, structural steel, rebar, form-a-drain,
VBUCK and braces, concrete, and ICF's was about $9.15 per square foot of
wall.
ICF's go up slower - I've worked on or followed closely 6 different ICF
projects now, and they all go up slower than stick-framing. The
foundation/basements take about the same amount of time as a
conventional foundation, but the main levels suffer in schedule
compared to stick framing.
Costwise - cement rises just like lumber, so I've found the delta to
be pretty consistent, although less volatile with ICF. A lot of
cement is being redirected down to Katrina, and you'll see it in cement
prices. I saw an 82-lb bag of Portland jump from $7.28 to $8.34
overnight here at evil orange.
Hence my assertion that ICF's cost more - my timing was similar to
Ken's, and ICF was pretty darn competitive with stick-framing as I built
my house, but the time, extra planning, sometimes extra engineering,
etc., all add up. But after living in the house, I'd do it all
again.
A few weeks ago, we had a big cold front come in. Now, we live on
a foothill at the edge of the mountains, so when a front comes it, it
comes in... With 60-80 (higher?) mph gusts, pallets move
around in the kind of wind that hits now and then... Anyway, I heard
the front coming in at night, after we were in bed, and got up and shut
the window so it A) wouldn't howl, and B) wouldn't get pulled off the
house. About a half-hour later, my wife woke up from a sound sleep,
grumbled that I should leave the windows open, and went over to open
it... As soon as the casement got open an inch, a monstrous howl
shook the room, and she quickly closed the window again... "Oh, THAT's
why you closed the window"...
You won't hear anything.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/21/2005
Check with your local plumbing supply house -- Often they have the
software for design and will sell you a package for a great price, with
local service. There are also many internet sites,
including radiantdirect.com, radiantec.com, etc. I would caution you
to look closely at all of these - There is a BIG difference in the
designs of the system. There are some things that I would avoid (some are
because of codes, some are because of energy transfer). I bought
my package from an internet vendor, and am very happy with it, but I did
see a lot of variety in the solutions and components.
1) Open systems -- If your radiant supplier cannot put together
a good closed-loop system (each heat exchanger that they add will drop
your efficiency) I'd keep looking. My code expressly forbids
open-loop systems and hot water heaters. 2) Circulators --
Some systems are designed to use a pump for each zone, others use
valves. Each pump takes electricity to run, so your overall
energy efficiency will drop. Look for a system with a minimum of
pumps -- Obviously, you need circulators, and the quantity will vary
with the number of zones, but a circulator per zone can get expensive
and use a lot of electricity.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/19/2005
Our costs here tend to be higher, but we paid ~ $1 psf for cutting a
road. Your costs will be lower, since the terrain is
flatter. Figure minimum $.50 psf of road for basic road base.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/13/2005
Do your research beforehand... If Seattle is anything like our area,
things are 'progressive' now... And subdividing will require
significant hoops and cost... If I were to try to subdivide into
anything smaller than 35-acre lots here, we'd do the following...
1) Pay a surveyor and engineer to draw up a new plat. You'll need
to supply new drainage, access, stormwater/water quality and
road/utility accesses. The road access stuff has to stipulate the
number and size of culverts, etc.
2) A portion of the acreage would need to be placed into perpetual
conservation easement. Typically, unless you can get approval for
a full subdivision, you might get three or four lots of two acres each, with the
residual being perpetual conservation 'open lands'. This is the
biggie. If you have enlightened politicians and committees, your
land prices will be outrageous like ours.
3) Once you have the plat from your surveyor and engineer, you submit
it to your county's planning department. Here they will look
through it. There might be public meetings where you have to post
and let neighbors comment. Here we have to do that several times,
and work with another group of politicos called the 'Rural Land Use
Program'.
4) Submit it for final approval, pay the surveyor to set pins, and get
everything recorded. To get stuff recorded, you might have to go
ahead and install the roads, water lines, soil test for lots, power,
gas, etc... The county here does this to prevent developers from
selling lots that are not ready to be built...
Good luck! I looked at doing it, and said, nah.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/13/2005
With the PB tubing, radiant was a problem. My plumber installs
10,000 sf a week, and after 8 years, the only leaks are where
framers ignore the warning signs and shoot nails into the
tubing...
Honestly, barring the 10 million dollar Aspen (ski area) homes that had
PB tubing everywhere, the only bad comments I hear from radiant are
from builders who don't want to spend the money on it, or don't' want to
slow down the project to do it. I do believe it adds some
complexity and delay to the scheduling, it did on my project. The
same reasons that builders don't like to try anything new, or build
energy efficient houses, etc.
I installed radiant, with 2,000+ sf of hardwood over it, no
problems. I used the Owens Plankfloor, which has an engineered
substrate and a fully-refinishable wood surface (you can refinish it
the same number of times as a regular 3/4" T&G floor) but the
engineered substrate has proven to be darn solid. So far no
problems at all. It's fantastic and feels great. It
installs just like 3/4" T&G or glues down.
It is really an incredible treat. I'm going to lower the setpoint
on my boiler this winter - Our ICF house only calls for heat about
every 48 hours during the winter, which means that the floors are only
warm for a little while every few days. By lowering the setpoint
and letting the boiler modulate (calling for less gas/heat) the run
times will be longer, hence floors 'warm' longer.
Now, the warm floors is a real treat, bare feet on tile or wood.
But the amazing thing is how comfortable it is 24/7, even when it's not
'actively' warm. It's also totally quiet. I've never lived in a
house so comfortable.
Finally, this is goofy, but we had an old dog with respiratory tract
problems - the dry air from our forced air furnace (with a humidifier)
had her coughing all the time... Once we moved, she quit
coughing. We also find that we don't dust very much now. I
suspect radiant would be beneficial for folks with allergies.
It is more expensive, and more complex. There is a risk for
leaks, but there are no joints in any areas that don't have direct
access. If someone is comfortable putting in pex for hot/cold
water, they shouldn't blink using it for heat - The pressures in a
radiant heat system are very low relative to even domestic water supply
lines.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/13/2005
Wood, prepared propery, will be the same. The trick is in the prep. It takes a lot of labor.
For painted trim, oil paints give a smoother finish than latex - But they are obviously more challenging.
For stained trim, you can get a very nice finish over stain using a
clear poly or lacquer. After the sanding, sanding sealer, and
stain, apply a coat of clear (poly, etc). Once the poly has
dried, rub every inch of wood with a 00 fine steel wool. This
takes forever. Follow up with a tack cloth.
Repeat the poly / steel wool / tack cloth 2 x times, for a total of 3 coats poly.
After the steel wool, things are smooth as can be... Not sure
what your friends was, but we did this. I still have to do the
final rub on my door casing, but it really makes things smooth and
cleaning is a breeze.
(It would have come out better on a harder trim, mine is knotty pine, and the grain raises a bit with the first coat of poly).
You might check with painters. This level of effort was very
uncommon in my area - The exterior painter and cabinet guys agreed with
the method, but would have charged irrational amounts to have their
guys do it.
One trick - Get a coat of poly onto the baseboard/trim before it is
installed. Most trim carpenters don't like this, because they
have to do better work. The poly/lacquer will seal the wood from
stains, and keep dull spots from appearing where nailgun holes are
filled. The second and third coats are done in place, after
filling nail holes, touchups, sanding marks are cleared, etc.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/6/2006
You're lot will qualify as equity/down payment in the project, if it is
an adequate precentage of the project, you will get conventional
construction loan rates rather than inflated/fee laden 100% type
loans. There are exceptions everywhere, but the lot does
generally (always?) count as a down payment if you have equity in it or
own it outright.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/12/2005
I'll post a picture when I can, but you can swap in posts pretty easily
if your engineer has designed in a "smaller" post. If you want
fancy joinery, and really beautiful timber trusses and corbels, well,
then it will cost you. If you want to throw logs in place of the
typical 4x4's or other columns supporting porches, decks, etc, it's
actually pretty easy. Talk with your engineer, you'll need to
stain the wood with a good penetrating perservative/sealer, andraise
the bottom of the logs off of the concrete. Simpson makes a plate
for just that, for 4, 6, and 10 inch logs. Using logs for
horizontal structural members gets a lot more complex, because you have
to be more particular about the size and species than typically simple
vertical posts.
I saw the front of a house out here that was just like every house in
the neighborhood, but the covered front porch was supported by 6"
peeled logs, and stained a deep red oak... It really made the
house stand out.
Most small wood product specialty places (fencing, etc) and sawmills
can get or make peeled logs. Machine peeled logs are more uniform
and cheaper, hand peeled logs are most rustic and obviously,
expensive. For interior, I'd go hand peeled as the machine peeled
logs on really close inspection (15") you can see the machine spiral.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/13/2005
It's a threaded shaft that you can use to raise/lower the post.
The simpson brackets enable this - you basically wet set a 5/8" piece
of galvanzied all-thread into the concrete, and then drill a hole in
the post. Screw the bracket to the bottom of the post, and start
sliding it down the all thread. Slip a couple of washers and a
nut in the depressed area in the bracket, and spin them down the
all-thread until you get the height you want. This bracket
provides both support, and uplift protection (should a big wind come
along and push up on your exterior overhang or deck.
Interior, I've heard that it's much less of a problem, and that over a
30' span, the shrink/swell expansion would be less than 3/8" in an
unloaded post (say, a ridge beam). That said, if you don't have
to worry about uplift, using the all thread and washers/nut as
mentioned above would work great and saves the cost of the simpson
bracket. spinning the nut would allow for height adjustment, but
if there was a real load on the column, you'd need someone to spec the
adjuster, perhaps substituting the commercial equivilent.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/3/2005
I just ran through this - It was low by about 35%... But I
suspect that the big difference is that most OB homes are custom, and
this calculator makes a lot of assumptions... For example, It listed ~7k for windows, when I've not seen a custom house go up around here with less than 21k in windows. Ultimatly, get lots of bids before going to the bank! j
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/3/2005
I selected the top finishes, and some things, like heat came out right on, excavation, foundation, framing, and windows came out low. But a good start.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/23/2005
I would look at the open-cell foams (Icynene, bio-based, and other
competitors) differently than the closed-cell polys. The
closed-cell polys are higher R-value, and stiffer, but have some
drawbacks (urea spray agent, trapping water). As Ken alludes to,
do a search on Icynene in this forum and you'll find several threads. My
house is ICF, with a framed section where I have a vault. The
frame is 2x6 and 2x12, with the sprayed foam (I used the BioBased, an
icynene competitor) used to insulate the framing and my entire
attic. The sprayed foam does reduce the sound transmission
dramatically, but it's nothing compared to the ICF portions of my
house. My only regret with my house is I didn't come up with some
way to do the vaulted area with ICF (some tricky engineering as
is). If you really want it quiet, ICF will beat the foam.
The foam isn't cheap - ICF will probably be about the same, possibly
cheaper, than stick frame with Icynene.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/24/2005
Pricing was as follows: 10" of the biobased in ~2,700 sf attic, low-pitch roof (1/2 : 12) - $1.48 per square foot. 3-4"
in 1,045 sf garage attic, sprayed at the same time - $1.02 per square
foot (low-pitch roof). As you can see, most of the up-front cost
is in the prep work, only $.48 psf difference between R-10/R-12 and R-40+ Icynene
was almost exactly the same price. Went with the guy who was
closest geographically. I'll post pictures.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/15/2006
As mentioned by Mark, these can be VERY loud. We had some friends
who installed a downdraft for the real vent system, that pops up out of
the countertop, and a fake one above the stove (large clearance) for
looks.
Obviously this doesn't save any money, and you still have to clean the decorative one, too. But it works, and is pretty quiet.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/2/2005
Nice wiring job! I'll post mine when I get it looking as nice as yours!
A couple of things to consider if you are going the wireless only route:
1) Wireless needs to be properly secured, and kept up to date. 2) Wireless speeds will generally always lag copper (wired) speeds.
3) If you build with ICF, plan for installing multiple access points or repeaters if your house is large or has an odd layout. I've experimented with a couple of different brands, using both 802.11b and 802.11g technology, and they pretty much won't pass through ICF walls well. They do work, but the signal is weak and the endpoints do a lot of channel hopping trying to get the speeds back up. 40' away, around an interior ICF corner the signal is pretty weak on both Linksys and D-link wireless routers.
You may also want to wire for other things: -phone -alarm -cable/sat TV
Looks fantastic!
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 6/23/2005
I installed a tankless, but it came as a built-in into the boiler
that supplies my radiant heat. When a call for hot water comes,
the boiler automatically switches the heated fluid from the boiler into
a small heat exchanger mounted inside the boiler that heats hot
water. It is 200,000 BTU, and is in the range of 6-8 GPM,
depending on input temperature. It runs both our showers and the
dishwasher at the same time without problems. Since it came as
part of the boiler, the added cost was minimal, and the venting was
already in place. however, should I have the boiler fail,
then I'd be looking at my hot water going out too... A mixed bag,
but it works well, and the cost recovery is advantageous, since most of
the infastructure was paid for for heating the radiant heat. The boiler is made by NTI. Endless hot water is great. Thanks, J
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/7/2006
You have to ignore the teenager and compare like-use models. What about the other 22 hours a day when no teenagers are showering? Both units will use nearly identical amounts of energy to heat the water, that's given in the laws of thermodynamics. The tanked unit will keep using energy to keep that water warm. It's a bit like choosing wind-powered batteries vs. the utility grid for electricity because you can't leave your lights on as long before they go dark. :)
I think it requires comparing apples to apples. If you have two regular hot-water heaters (common in many homes), you'll use a lot more energy and hot water too. You have to compare similar/like use models. (Although relying on the tank heater to close down the shower could be handy). It seems that most O-B homes I've seen either have a huge tankless, or multiple 50-60 gallon tanked units ganged in parallel - the culprit - the Jacuzzi tubs; a single 50-gallon tank won't be able to fill most of the 'modern' Jacuzzi tubs going into custom homes.
For a family of four, each taking a 15-minute shower that uses say, 1.5 gpm of hot water (quite possibly reasonable). A 50-gal tank unit with decent recovery would meet this need, but so would a tankless.
Our 200K BTU on-demand unit came built into our radiant boiler. I spent $10-$12 on propane heating domestic hot water from April through today this summer. My last house, with an "energy efficient" but standing pilot light, never had a gas bill for less than $30/month. Heating water when you don't use it won't ever be efficient. I'd guess that I'm saving a minimum of $150 during each 6 "summer" months (Just noting the summer months because the only propane draws are the grill and the hot water). So I'd guess $300 per year. Part of this "differential" is that I'm now on propane (more expensive per BTU) but I don't pay a minimum-monthly gas-company surcharge.
Pricing the boiler without the on-demand, I recall it was ~ $600 cheaper, although the radiant vendor shipped all their boilers with it. You will be hard pressed to find an energy-saving upgrade that will cover itself in two years.
Now, if you are comparing a good power-vented, quick recovery, Energy Star tanked unit (Around $1,000 when I looked), versus an on-demand (I have no idea what the Rinnai et al standalone units are running now, I wouldn't be surprised to see a $2,500 price tag, time to recovery is going to depend on the service life of the equipment.
As I did my calculations for geothermal, I wasn't willing to gamble the equipment lasting more than 10 years, although it is very likely that it will; for me, 10 years is too long of investment-recovery time; if the equipment fails before I've recovered my extra investment, I get nothing and lose the time value of the extra upfront cost. For my house, the monthly cost savings of geothermal (since I was using less energy upfront) took nearly 25 years to recover; I can recover solar hot water in 7-8 years (close, but a decent gamble given energy prices) and my ICF walls will cover themselves here near the end of my second year.
The other way to compare these is that it always takes a finite amount of energy to raise a given mass of water by one degree in temperature. It doesn't matter if you are heating the water right before use, or in a tank, given similar burner efficiencies, it will take pretty much the same energy to heat, plus energy to maintain.
All of this is difficult, because it's easy to know what you are paying now for energy, and how much you are using, but it can be more difficult to know how those factors will change in your new house. The calculations, and recovery times, will vary by owner-builder, so ultimately, the decision needs to be made on your specific house.
Good luck, J
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/24/2006
Passive solar is solar oriented design where the benefit (reduced
heating bills) is realized without any extra "equipment". Active
solar is where solar panels of some type (usually hot water or hot air)
are used to bring energy into the house, usually using some type of
controls, pumps, valves, etc.
There is a lot to good passive solar design, but in simple terms, it
might be orienting the house & selecting/placing windows to capture
winter sun to reduced the time the furnace runs, perhaps having a dark
thermal mass that the sun shines on inside an area, to release heat
later.
The converse to this design is that you can get too much of it!
Too much passive solar gain will make a structure a bear to cool during
the summer. This is often countered with covered porches, decks,
awnings, etc. Good passive design will let the winter (low angle,
at least in my area) sun in, but block the higher angle sun during the
summer, so that the homeowner doesn't have to move shades around all
the time, etc (thus becoming a little more 'active' than many of us
want.
There are a ton of aspects to it, Hopefully dale will add some of his
insight. I have lots of early AM east sun and south sun through
the day until about 4:00, so I tried to design to take advantage of
this, while protecting my south/east glass from the sun during the
summer through a covered deck.
Knowing your location, you can site your house, and orient it pretty
much exactly to take advantage of the potential solar gain in your
area. There are sites on the internet that can help with this.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/26/2006
It will be specific to your area, your soils, and your codes.
Here, everything has to have footings if you will heat it, or be in
caissons if your soils are bad. If you are building an unheated
structure, you might be able to get away with slab here. There
are 3,000 sq.ft. "barns/shops" out here that have no footings, and small
sheds that do.... I would call your local building department to
be sure.
If the garage is going to be attached to the house, it would be advised
to have footings no matter what, unless it's really uncommon in your
area. If the house stays put, but the garage moves or heaves, you
could have a very difficult problem.
You could get an idea of the costs by calling local foundation folks
and finding out what they charge for a typical stemwall, per linear
foot. Add to that the excavation, and then the costs of
backfilling/compacting inside the foundation... Not huge, but
definitly additional cost as you have noted.
Good luck!
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/17/2006
Arnold,
Your local code will dictate sizing - they pretty much don't care about
HRV, but bath fans are sized per some odd formulas in IRC. If you
are going to use the HRV in place of bath fans, you'll need to
demonstrate that it will pull adequate CFM from each bathroom - this
can be tough depending on your inspectors; mine didn't hardly care, to
the point of not even looking at the nameplates on the fans I did have.
As far as overall HRV exhaust/entry, there are some rules of thumb in
terms of whole house air exchanges per unit time. A lot of the
HRV sales sites will have these guidelines. Typically, if I recall
correctly, some of the biggest HRV's will only do a 3,500 sf x 9' high
house by themselves, implying that you need more than one for larger
houses. These calculations use entire house volume, so your
basement often doubles your volume.
I elected to undersize it, and see how things went. Adding the expense of a second HRV seemed overkill.
What we have found in practice, is that even with super-tight
construction, we end up getting good air exchanges pretty much just
letting the dog in and out every few hours. The HRV is on a
periodic timer, but the overall run time is pretty low.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/9/2006
I can confirm what a Arnold has illustrated - I have real-time
telemetry in all of my ICF walls - I get temperature readouts on the Web of my interior, exterior, roof, boiler run times, boiler water
temperatures, and yes, the concrete core of my ICF walls.
This time of year, in Colorado, we are having 60-degree days, 20-degree
nights. At 3 am, the coldest part of last night, my thermal mass
temperature was 50.5 degrees, but at noon yesterday, we had an outside
temp of almost 70, and my thermal mass temperature was around 54
degrees. So the mass will move toward the outside temperature,
but do so slowly. So during winter, when I have to heat, at
night, when it's 20, I'm heating more like it's 50 out.
And
during the summer, while the thermal mass does warm up some, it's
reversed; at night, it cools off, and during the day, it warms up, but
the mass is so large that it never moves up enough that the HVAC system
would notice... So the mass tempers the temperature swings,
reducing the heating and cooling loading, and acting like a
flywheel. In climates like ours (Colorado) with large temperature
swings each day, the flywheel effect has the benefit of storing a bit
of heat for use later, and likewise with the cooling, in a passive mode.
In another month or so, my heat will quit turning on entirely... The heat during the day will offset the losses at night... L)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/11/2006
I'll post some data soon, but even when things warm up here, the mass
does not move as much as one would think. It takes a LOT of
energy to raise the temperature of a lot of mass. Also, I think
it matters how the building is designed. If you have good passive
solar design, thermal mass is key, and will do more for an energy bill
than any amount of insulation. (For heating climates, obviously).
Thermal mass is common in the desert - Ever seen adobe? The best
case might be two insulated thermal masses, some of the ICF's do
this... Expensive adobe homes do this with two stacks of adobe
and an insulation void - Remember, your energy in a tradition ICF
"leaks" out through insulation into a mass, and then "leaks" again to
the outside, with warm climates being the reverse. I've seen
houses in Arizona with super thick concrete roofs. The thickness of
the mass is such that there is not a significant increase of the surface
temperature before nightfall, at which point heat is radiated
out. I don't think I'd want to gamble on it, when my parents are building with SIPs right now, they didn't want the extra
time it takes to get everything formed up; but we have found huge
variations in the quality and safety of SIPs. Pick a good one,
and make sure they are structurally rated, many that are priced on the Internet are not.
As far as comparing prices, ICF to SIP, for a finished house, that is
simply not reasonable. What granite, what flooring, what
location? A water tap here costs $30K ($5 psf on a 6,000 sf house),
and labor rates are outrageous. The only real thing you can
compare between the two is per square foot cost of wall, excluding
foundation...
For an indicator though, I'm building a barn/shop this summer, and
using ICF again. ICF's are pretty reasonable, if you shop and
have reasonable rates on concrete. For me, I place a premium on
the quietness in a high wind area, and the fire protection. Using
ICF, I can avoid almost all of the structural steel and LVL I need
framing or using SIPs.
After we get the SIP shell completed on my parents' house, I'll post
prices as a comparison. I'm all for either; anything is better
than stick framing. I believe SIP will be cheaper, but not by a
huge margin.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/9/2006
Lee,
I've used both, but primarily insultarp under the slabs in my
house. I ran out of insultarp and have 2" polystyrene under part
of my garage, I cant tell a difference, although the insultarp is very
easy to install. All slabs have radiant heat.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/24/2006
Search icynene and biobased in these forums, there has been a lot of
coverage. There is a recent thread covering poly (closed cell) vs
open cell foams.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/24/2005
We put in a couple Danze because of the finish. They are MUCH nicer
than the Deltas we installed elsewhere, and nicer than the Kohler and Moen
at the big box stores. I'm sure the big guys (Moen, Kohler,
Delta, American Standard) probably have different "levels" within their
lines, so it would probably be best to compare apples to apples.
Compared to Delta, the Danze are wonderful. O-ring, stainless
supply lines, great cartridges, ALL the parts are there. The
pullout sprayer on the kitchen faucet we bought has some real heft to
it, much heavier than any of the other ones we looked at, and the
supply hose for it seems to be holding its finish nicely.
We've only been using them since April, but so far, I wish I had put Danze everywhere I didn't.
Parts are available from my local supply house, you might check your area.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/15/2004
I wanted to add some perspective here. Everyone on this site is generally interested in saving some money, and doing it yourself. I'm doing some of each in my project, but there are some limits/considerations that I think everyone needs to consider, HONESTLY. I did my own ICF work, during a leave from my daytime job. My walls went up straight, solid, and came out fantastic. I also worked for 10-12 weeks on it, every day, no vacations, no breaks. I have a very understanding wife who helped me on the weekends, and no kids. It was a LOT of work, but I saved a lot of money. Progress on our house continues, although I've gone back to work. In keeping with my continual DIY mentality, I work on the house before and after work. It's going to be a great house. However, no breaks, a normal life (job, kids, dog, etc.) and dealing with the scheduling can stack up. Inserting yourself into the labor supply (or relying on family) can pose a VERY SERIOUS risk to your lifestyle and your project that you need to evaluate before you commit do doing the work yourself. Along those lines, make sure you don't put your family/lifestyle in jeopardy with your project. I darn near took my finger off the other morning with a RotoZip, getting some last minute critical path stuff done. I'm a very handy guy with all kinds of tool background - I was just tired (first thing in the morning, after back to back to back morning and evenings working on the house and a day job) from working non-stop on our project. One mistake is all it takes. I could probably still do my day job without a finger, but what if I was a surgeon, or guitar player? In all seriousness... It's a tough call - building your dream home, hoping to stretch the budget to add features that you couldn't normally afford. Or just being cheap. Whatever the reason, I strongly suggest the following: 1) DO NOT, UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCE, FAIL TO BUDGET TO HAVE ALL WORK DONE BY SOMEONE ELSE. REPEAT. If you plan your project assuming you do a piece, and then your circumstances change (injury, job obligations, travel) you put your project completion (and your equity, both hard and sweat) at risk. I think you can do this if you are very careful and realistic, but in general, I suspect this is a failing of many owner-builders. If you don't have any budget for an item, you can really get your back against the wall, I suspect. I did budget for everything on my house, but in getting cheap, and finding sometimes it was easier to do the work myself than go through the trouble of finding good help, etc, I started doing more and more. This was in violation of my initial plan, to only do the stuff I really enjoyed or that had a high rate of return. It took my little wake-up call to set me back on the path. I certainly didn't plan on going that route. I still plan on doing a lot, but plan on trying to keep with my original intent. You will need help from your friends and family throughout the project (clean-up days, someone to meet the window guy while you are in a meeting, etc.). Be careful about scheduling them in at the start.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/25/2006
Ralph,
I had the same dilemma - I opted for the Owens Corning Plankfloor, it's
1/4" of wood, over a 7 or 9-ply engineered substrate, which can be
refinished pretty much the same number of times as a solid 3/4" floor.
My original plan was 3/4" hickory over the gypcrete using the standard
sleeper method. After doing about a quarter of the house in sleepers,
and realizing how long it takes to do them, I decided I was going with
a glue-down product, either the lumber liquidators Australian cypress
prefinished, or Owens Plankfloor hickory, site finished with a Bona
traffic finish. We opted for the latter, and are glad we
did. It has no gaps for dirt to collect in, and the floors are
perfectly smooth. It has been a fantastic performer over
radiant.
I installed the Plankfloor myself, after sealing the gypcrete using the Therma-Floor supplied product. The adhesive for a proper glue-down project is expensive, but it was worth it.
I had the floors professionally finished, and the finisher was amazed
with the floor - The Plankfloor is milled, so it really fits together
like a lot of the engineered laminate products, but doesn't have the
floating "plastic" sound when walked on of a lot of laminates.

| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/27/2006
FWIW, my radiant was installed using a thin slab over my heated
basement. I had planned on insulating below my great room floor
because of downward loss, on advice of the radiant installers I had bid
the job out to. I've not done this yet, and don't think I will
now. (Still debating, or waiting for a free afternoon. My
plans was to get a roll of the Insul-Tarp that I put under my slabs, cut
16" wide strips, and staple it up under the floor in the TJI
bays.) The heat just does not run enough, and it's relatively low
water
temperatures. With geothermal, your water temps will be lower
than a lot of boiler installations anyway, which will be good for wood.
All of my tubing is on 8" centers. I will post my slab
temperatures when I get that telemetry subsystem up. As for the
comfort of radiant heat, check out my graph in the green building
forum. We move within a two-degree window, primarily due to the
daytime passive solar gain we have.
As for the foil products, I can vouch for the Insul-Tarp/Astro White II
products. My basement slab performs as well or better with Insul-Tarp under it than the garage floor with 2" EPS. Insul-Tarp
seems to be the standard among the higher-end hydronic installers here
in Colorado. I ran out of Insul-Tarp on the garage, and had to use
EPS to get everything poured on my time frame over a weekend. Both
slabs are inside ICF envelopes with biobased attic insulation. My
cellar slab has no insulation, and not that I heat that loop anyway
(the PEX was originally for chilling, but it's connected to the heat
from when I had my tools locked in there). It NEVER heats up, so
the Insul-Tarp clearly seems to do the job.
(As for the 'radiant foil barriers' on eBay, etc., those look like they
might be bit iffy, but my perspective is primarily a heating climate,
they might be common in more cooling dominated environments).
I think the earlier advice to avoid refinishing at all costs was
perhaps made in reference to most engineered products are not designed
to be refinished?? I know the Owens plank is, which drove my
choice. I believe Owens actually warranties their product over
radiant. Ours has been fantastic - it's still like glass after a
full season in very dry Colorado.
Back to wood:
What are typical indoor humidities? I find our house varies
between 39% and 44% always, which seems comfortable. I was
wondering what others humidities tend to range in. Outdoors we
vary from 3 to 100. This might be part of my luck with the wood
floors, a constant humidity.
We had the flooring shipped out from Michigan (where we bought our
plank floor from) and it sat in our garage (conditioned, but not the
final installed location) for about 8 weeks. We then moved the
bundles to the rooms where we were installing them, broke the boxes
open, and spread the wood out on the floor for about three weeks... Some
was only out about 10 days, some was out for about 3.5 weeks, depending
on where we started installing flooring first. I think the
acclimation is really important.
Hope this helps,
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/21/2005
I decided against working with Lumber Liquidators - I am doing 2200 sf of hickory.
We liked the product, and I wanted to buy it. I needed a quote that I could take to the bank and get a check for.
They WILL not do quotes, nothing in writing. "We'd have to honor that price if you came back later" they whined.
funny, the rest of the industry puts expiration dates on their quotes.
So for me, it wasn't worth the headache. I bought it elsewhere, with 50% on order, and 50% on pickup, via my bank.
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/21/2005
I understand protecting a quote, but the other places I got quotes
would make a quote valid for 7 days, or 30 days, or whatever.
Without anything in writing, I'm supposed to plop down 12k for flooring
that won't show up for 6 weeks??? I'm sure I'd get a reciept once
it's paid for, but my bank won't issue a check without some
documentation.
All in all, it worked out better. We went with owens plank floor,
which has a full thickness wood layer over an engineered
substrate. Full mfg warranty over radiant heat, and site
finished so there are no little dirt bevels. The product is
available a few places, and I worked with schacht millworks, who did
everything in writing with a 30 day expiration on their quotes.
Stayed within 0.10 psf of the LL prefinished price.
LL can do business how they like; it's a free market, and I prefer not
to work with folks who can't at least write their price of the day down
for my bank.
Other than that little thing, I wouldn't have hesitated to work with
them. While rude on the phone, in person they were great,
and they do keep overhead to a minimum.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/18/2005
I did my own ICF walls. You can see details on my site. It
is a 4 person job, at a minimum. 4 people works good, if they are
reasonably educated about ICF and what you can/cannot do. Some
subs will pour walls for you, but you will pay a premium. They
are taking the time to work with you for a 1-day pour, so the overhead
cost is going to be higher. If you have a good ICF dealer,
often they will help, or even pour your walls, as part of the price of
the ICF. My ICF sales guy was out helping me pour (I had a crew
of myself plus 3 plus the ICF sales guy, plus some gophers). He worked
hard, and was previously an installer, so he came out the day before
the pour and double checked/marked areas we needed to brace or
reinforce. You really need 4 folks for the following positions: 1) Pump hose "operator" - The guy actually pouring the mud, and using hand signals to communicate with the pump truck operator. 2)
Wall "slapper" - When you're pouring the first few feet of height of
wall, we'd have one person with a 2x4 smacking the wall so that we'd a)
help consolidate and b) know how high we had poured (we did 4-6' lifts,
back to back. Staring down the top of a 12' wall, it's hard to
tell how high you've placed concrete, so having someone below pounding
on the wall helps. 3) Concrete consolidator - the poor schmuck
running the vibrator. My block was strong enough that vibration
is recommended, and we vibrated through each lift to the lift below to
get good consolidation. This is hard on the hands and wrists, and
ends up being messy. You need a small tipped pencil on the end
(we had a 7/8" head, 16' cable). 4) Well, if you don't
have a 4th, you can get away with it, but our 4th usually carried the
vibrator motor and managed the power cord on it, swapping positions
with #3 - Even with a continuous fresh guy, the vibrator guy was always
lagging the pumping. It's REALLY hard to run the vibrator
PROPERLY and carry the motor.
We'd keep 2 people on the ground to watch for problems (they got
bored, we didn't have any bulges or blowouts) and clean window sills,
subfloors, tools, etc. They would also ensure consolidation around
windows, lintels, etc. My first pour had problems with truck
staging, and it took about 8 hours to place 100 yards of
concrete. The second and third pours each placed around 60-80
yards in 2-3 hours. The difference? On the first pour, the
pump truck didn't have the fitting we requested, so there was a 30
minute delay. The delay blew the concrete company's schedule, and
then they started sending trucks every 45-60 minutes instead of every
20 minutes... A very expensive mistake. The second and
third pours, we switched pump truck companies, (got a more professional
company with better truck operators) and made sure, under no uncertain
terms, that any delays or missing fittings would be charged back.
Fortunately, the second company was fantastic, and had great operators
who arrived prepared and ready to go. I assume you are pumping. I think trying to place concrete in ICF any other way is foolish. Take a class if you can, they will tell you a lot about what to expect. It's very tough work.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/20/2005
The class costs $150 for a two-day class, with the amount credited on
your first order of ICF forms. It was absolutely worth it.
While in that class, listening to these "professional" foundation guys
try to figure out if a set of walls was square using a calculator, or
the linear footage of a perimeter, I realized that with a little care,
I could do a better job than most, if not every one of these
"professionals". My ICF sales guy agreed.
I was right. I did a better job than just about any professional job
I've seen. My sales guy also agreed.
Ralph is right on on the waterproofing - I know some folks only do the
spray-on stuff and then backfill. I had rocky soil, so I did the
spray-on route (same as poured wall) and then put up sheetrock to
protect the
walls during backfill.
Another, very nice system, which I might have used had my ICF dealer
been selling it when I was doing my walls, is the dimpled plastic mats.
I'd combine them with the spray-on stuff, and probably end up with a
pretty good system, but if you have rocks, I'd go for something a
little stiffer.
Regarding the spray on stuff - Be ABSOLUTELY sure it is compatible with
the ICF foam, or you'll turn your superinsulated basement into a poured
wall foundation pretty quick! It needs to be water based, and for good
measure, check with your ICF dealer/sub.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/26/2005
Not sure about Texas, but in Colorado, my understanding is that
there is technically no such thing. Ultimately, if someone get's
hurt, pull out the lawyers... Which means you'll have to lawyer up at
the minimum to defend yourself against the workman and enforce the
insurance waiver if it is even allowable. Nobody has workmen's comp? Yikes!
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/18/2006
I used biobased in my attic; Open cell foams have a lower R value, but
do still provide a seal. Polyurethane closed cell foams have a
higher R value, and are often cheaper. They will not pass water
over time, open cell foams (icynene, biobassed) will. In an attic
application, this means your roof can fail but you will never see a
leak, while the water could be channeled other places, causing
rot/damage, FWIW. Also, most jurisdictions REQUIRE that
polurethane foams be covered by an ignition barrier, which is no
problem for walls (sheetrock) but can be difficult in attics. A
good comprimise is poly in walls and open cell in attics, a buddy just
did that with his stick framed house.
I did 11" of open cell in my attic, and it averaged about $1.50 (perhaps a little less) per square foot.
Some folks have concerns on the poly-urea's outgassing in the standard
polyurethane foams used in these applications and some
SIP's. Do you own research and decide, pretty much all
building materials have something. :)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/19/2006
Just from what I've seen of the poly on my buddies project, poly will
probably attenuate slightly better, but not much. Both will need
one side of the interior wall to be finished so that the product could
be sprayed in.
I've heard somewhere on this forum that double drywall is the way to go for sound attenuation.
Hope this helps!
J
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/16/2005
For 2,700 sf plus the exterior walls in my basement, above code, I'm
paying $14K, excluding all fixtures, but including cans, switches,
outlets, and plates. This is in CO, which has pretty high prices, so
your builder's price sounds pretty decent to me. :)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/8/2009
I used HomeWrights, and have no problem recommending them 100%. You don't have to have them; I think paying their fee saves a lot of legwork and learning that you would do as part of your preconstruction prep work.
They are a good resource, but not 100% necessary. That said, if I were building my first house again, I'd use them again absolutely. Second house? By the time you've built a house, you've learned and you don't need much help.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/26/2005
Around here (CO) everyone uses the two "interchangeably" during
conversation, and true 1/2" is often a special order item. I was hoping that is the case there, but I don't know about those
hurricanes and whatnot. :)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/14/2005
Ralph,
I looked at using the HV stuff with geothermal - Price sent me back to
a conventional system, but I did hear some rumors before I gave up.
The water/coil temperatures of geothermal systems are not as hot/cold
as conventional systems. The hot water/heating side isn't as hot,
and the cold isn't as cold.
The high velocity systems need a minimum air flow to work, and this
minimum is pretty high. Because the air is moving so fast, it
tends to cool off (or warm up) the coil much more than a regular
system. I couldn't find anyone who would try, because they all
said it wouldn't work. However, most of these folks don't know
anything about geothermal or HV systemes.
I'd recommend talking to the folks at arit/ACC. (Ryan/ACC in
loveland can find the right technical people for you at ARIT to tell
you if this stuff will work.).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/14/2005
Not that I know for sure - I just know the water/coil temps are lower,
and I couldn't find many people who really knew what they were talking
about. The mini ducts looked nice, and looked owner-friendly, but I
wasn't finding any really great prices when I factored in that I was
already installing radiant.
Valley Geothermal knows a lot about geothermal, and they are out of
longmont. They are busy, and their geothermal, which is pretty much
guaranteed to work, will probably cost a little bit more.
The unico variable speed quote I got was 18k for equipment and install,
versus 9k for a more efficient conventional system... I was looking at
the unico and another one, similar design.
I think the key to making geo work with these might be the new variable
speed units. I'm full of bits, but you'll want to find a good sub for
that. Definitely make them show you calculations for anything involving
geothermal. Did you check out my wiring when you visited? It's not
punched out, but might give you some ideas.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/29/2005
John,
This statement you made caught my eye:
The
water/coil temperatures of geothermal systems are not as hot/cold as
conventional systems. The hot water/heating side isn't as hot, and the
cold isn't as cold.
Conventional meaning conventional heating/AC - I don't know how they
compare to air-air heat pumps. The coils are definitly not as hot
as furnace or boilers - The maximum water temperature for radiant
sourced geothermal is typically 130 degrees. Your
system/performance will vary, hence the need for a good system design.
I know the hot isn't as hot - I've seen the systems in the field,
and smart radiant installers will space the tubing at a tighter spacing
than conventional boiler fired systems because of the lower heat input.
I believe the cold is also not as cold, but the difference much less
significant than heating situation. In a conventional AC
condenser huge fans cool off the radiator. Remember also that the
temperature difference for cooling isn't that high (cooling a room to
69 degrees or whatever to a sink at 50 or so degrees).
I would really research and get a good installer to couple High
velocity with geothermal. There's a lot involved, and imagine
some good experience goes a long way.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/14/2005
The crossing @ 90 degrees minimizes crosstalk and interference.
I pre-wired 5E and 6 everywhere, along with all the other goods.
The Cat-6 is the "next cable" which will also be obsolete in a few
weeks, but it was free, so I did it. A couple of things about
wireless:
1) Security - Every wireless system out there now CAN be hacked.
Even when you enable all the goods/options/bells, it can be
broken. Not that it is likely in a rural environment...
2) Speed - Wireless will pretty much always trail wired in speed.
As mentioned above, you can always add wireless for working on the
deck. (Although I'm convinced that I'm going to have problems with ICF
and wireless, so I pre-wired/crafted a future location for outside
wi-fi.)
3) Interference - It's going to get better, but right now,
sometimes microwaves, cordless phones, and wi-fi don't play along
well. Add the Bluetooth for your cell phone, your PDA,
etc... Each of these technologies is getting better at
minimizing and working around interference, but they still have
problems.
Carlon makes some great LV conduits that are flexible, along with
boxes. They are all orange, and make it easy to upgrade your
cables in the future. I elected not to, simply on price.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/15/2006
Yikes! At $140/yard, I think it would be better pouring molten gold. I don't think much could be cost competitive with concrete at that price!
For my barn this summer, my ICF cost, materials (steel, bucks, block, cement and brackets) is going to cost me about $4.90/s.f. My parents SIPs project is going to come in around $4.60/s.f. of wall, with some luck. All in all, relatively close, but a fair bit more than typical stick frame.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/18/2006
My experience was virtually identical to Mark's - ~3K s.f. main level, ICF walls. Doing SIPS roof was going to require 100's of feet of LVL and thicker gluelams, and my SIPS bid seems like it was $18K+, plus gluelams, shipping, connectors, and a LOT of engineering fees.
My sprayfoam (biobased) insulation was pretty cheap relative, it's an almost flat roof, and it seems like it was about $1.55/s.f., 11" of foam. Although the icynene rep said all that anyone needs is 6", and I'd probably have to agree.
Seems like roof sheathing was ~0.50 psf, and trusses were about $2.00 psf. For a total of ~4.05 psf, versus $6.00 psf plus beams, which are not cheap. I would estimate that the beams would have cost me at least $2.00 psf in material and engineering, but that is a guess.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/5/2005
If you own a home now, (or even if you don't) call your home/car
insurance agent, and tell them you need a homeowners policy with a
builders risk rider/addendum. Oftentimes you can save if you already
have some other kind of policy, and when you finish, you can modify the
policy to just be a straight homeowners policy.
When you call/meet with your agent, you'll need to be able to give a
street or legal address, an approximate value, details on construction
materials/siding/roof, and distances to things like fire hydrants,
flood plains, etc. I know American Family and Farmers both offer these
policies.
Hope this helps,
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/4/2005
I have looked at the Robinson Rock product, and it's the only stone
veneer I'd install after seeing the others. My current project doesn't
call for stone, but it looks really good.
Not sure about DIY installation - I'm sure you can do it, but it might
take some time to get the technique down.
Finally, Robinson has specially cut corners so you can make it really
look like a solid rock in the corner. Take a look at them, it's one of
the best implementations of a veneer I've seen.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/30/2004
Diane,
Be sure to have an engineer involved early in the process. I was planning on using Rastra in my design, but I would have had to cut the material out of the inside of the Rastra form in many places, which would have dramatically reduced the R-value, and taken a lot of labor. I ended up using a conventional flat-wall ICF instead.
If your house is only one level, and nothing too out of the ordinary, then you shouldn't have any problems. We had a walkout basement, and wanted the entire envelope to be an insulated form (like Rastra, Nudura, etc.) and the forces were way too high for Rastra, since it is a screen-grid ICF (meaning the bearing/structural elements are the 6" circular rows/columns that are filled with concrete).
Also, in building with Rastra, or any ICF, having an engineer involved will make everything a lot easier with the building department, unless the building department has done similar buildings before.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/25/2005
I was all set to use Rastra, but their pricing made every other
method (stick, ICF, SIP, etc.) look cheap. Plus, for our design
(with a walkout basement) we'd have had to remove most of the
insulation material from inside the block to create concrete beam,
reducing the efficiency and increasing the expense (why pay for Rastra
to cut it out and throw it away?). But that was my design; I
digress. I also didn't buy the greenness factor, since they were
trucking peanuts long distances to the plants, creating the block, and
then I'd have had to truck the Rastra back to my site, at considerable
freight expense. That said, it's still a great idea. I
think more distributed, localized plants would alleviate the (IMHO)
hidden "non-greenness'.. Now, all that said - I just got a note
from the SW Rastra manufacturer - Rastra Corporation (the big parent
company) is exercising their right to purchase the 'Rastra'
manufacturer, so for a very limited time, you can purchase Rastra from
their remaining inventory for something like 20% off. If you are
using Rastra, try to buy now! A couple near here built a
beautiful Rastra house. Midway through construction, a fire hit the
area (the roof was framed on the Rastra, and firefighters kept it wet
and it didn't burn, but the partially completed house was the only
structure to not get destroyed. The pictures I saw were amazing,
an entire hillside gone, except for the house. That said,
when it came time to build a garage, they ditched Rastra and went with
a regular ICF. Rumor has it that the Rastra was much more labor
intensive. It's a neat product, and really, I think any of
these methods (SIP, ICF (Rastra, too), etc.) are all a huge step
above stick frame.
Good luck! John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/25/2008
I've not had the time to frequent these forums, but had to chime in...
I actually toured the site where the fire went through the O-B's Rastra house. The fire never came in contact with the house, as there was a clear defensible area around the entire house. Had it actually been subjected to flame, most of the R-value of the foam in the wall would have burned and melted out.
I believe the issue of fire burning the matrix (interstitial foam) out of Rastra is a legitimate one. As pointed out, it does rough up the surface, as the foam that makes up most of the block is burned away, only the "slurry" that bonds the foam beads is all that is left after the foam burns/melts away. The "structure" of the Rastra will still be there, but it will not be strong (i.e. recoating with stucco would be difficult, and drywall that is glued to the inside of the wall as recommended by my Rastra sales guy could fall down if enough of the foam is burned out). The concrete pillars will still be there and remain strong, but overall, if a real fire hits a Rastra wall, it will not burn much, but you will lose the foam/insulation component as the foam is burned or melted out.
I decided against Rastra, opting for a conventional flat wall ICF, primarily because I'd have to remove most of the insulation properties of the material by cutting out the center of the grid to allow for more concrete to meet basic design criteria for beam strength, and the cost was significantly more than other ICF's, while not requiring a crane to set. I believe a flat-wall ICF would be easier to repair after a severe fire event.
All in all, it is a decent material, just be clear what the limitations are. I'd use it if it were halfway affordable, but it wasn't, and still isn't. Add the constant political wrangling of the former U.S.-based Rastra plant and the parent company, and it just isn't worth messing with, IMHO.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/9/2006
In my locale, you need a working kitchen sink and something to cook on,
a full working bathroom, heat, and approval/complete electrical
trim. You don't need flooring, paint, other bathrooms,
etc... Also, any life safety issues (missing elevated decks,
etc.) need to be mitigated. It's common to see a couple of rails
nailed across a second story door while the owner finishes a deck, so
that they can get a CO.
I've seen folks install their kitchen sink on a cardboard box, (but connected to plumbing) and pass.
It's not ideal, but for a lot of us, it can be a reality. We
moved in without countertops, a couple of bathroom sinks installed, and
some minor trim work remaining. Still, we were able to get out of
our old house, and some people really balk at it "Oh, what a horrible
mistake, you will never get finished now," but I do a little here and
there, and after a year, we are pretty much done (except for
landscaping, which will be this spring/summer's project).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/4/2005
Depends on the quality of the material and the local labor rates - I
got pricing around $760 per square, installed, plus gutters. Welded stainless steel sheet was ~ $1450 per square! Very nice, very expensive.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/3/2005
I would check how current your sources are. Steel prices have
made HUGE jumps over the past year and a half, and continue to
climb. I don't think you will find that they are at all cost
competitive with lumber right now, but your locale may be
different. I believe there are some people on this board who
planned on using steel and switched when they saw the costs.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/24/2005
Anyone who is quoting BTU's over the net without running the numbers
is blowing smoke. How much insulation? What type of
construction? What climate? How many windows? There
are lots of variables.
I really wanted to do geothermal, but my ground was too rocky for my budget. The
time for payback will depend on how much energy your house uses, which
will depend on comfort levels, solar, design, climate, etc... If
you have a super efficient, highly insulated envelope, it's going to
take longer to recover your investment since you don't use as much
energy. Now, for some numbers: To heat and cool 6,000 sf in
Colorado, plus heat the garage (all radiant heating) the heat pump unit
that did forced air heating and cooling, and hot water heating for the
radiant, was between $6,500 and $11,500 depending on manufacturer,
dealer, etc. Some dealers think this stuff is space shuttle parts
and price it accordingly. Now, you need a loop field or some other input for your heat transfer fluid from the ground. These are usually 1)
Open well, where water is pulled out of the ground, heat is extracted,
and then the water is disposed of either in an acceptable location, or
in a return well. this is considered an open loop geothermal
system. I didn't research one much because I knew they wouldn't
fly out where I'm at.
2) Closed loop systems. These are a length of tubing
that is placed in the ground, either in grouted vertical wells, in a
big slinky in trenches in the ground, or as big loops in long trenches
(made with a trencher) in the ground). The cheapest is the long
trenches, the most expensive is the vertical grouted wells. Vertical
grouted wells usually run $1,000-$1,200 per ton of capacity, but it will
depend on how your soil transfers heat, etc. For my system, I
needed a 6 ton unit. They would have also had to drill rock,
which would have added to my cost. All
said, it was going to take 12 years to recover my investment in the
system if energy prices stayed the same (which they won't, so the
payback would be shorter).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/24/2005
Oh, that 6000 sf is 3000 sf radiant heated basement 3000 sf radiant heated main level 1045 sf heated garage.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/23/2005
I installed owens plankfloor in an ICF house I finished - glue down
to lightweight concrete over radiant. It's about 1/4" or so
hardwood laminated to a 7 or 9-ply engineered substrate. It is
glued or nailed/stapled down, individual boards (with excellent milling
on the boards, my finisher was amazed at the tolerances) and the boards
are very smooth, and require very little sanding. The floors are
then site-finished. The result is amazing. My finisher didn't
realize that it was an engineered product until he was done and we were
talking about it.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/25/2005
I started out this route (nailers), and the labor for it is pretty
high if you have radiant tubing in, hence my opting for the Owens Plankfloor and a glue-down.
If you use a glue-down, be sure not to skimp on the
glue - I used Bostik's Best moisture-cure urethane adhesive. It
creates a barrier as well as gluing, and was recommended with Owens Plankfloor by all of the professional installers as the best
hardwood floor over radiant heat. Thus far we have been
very happy.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/21/2005
Is your loan to value ratio good? Some banks won't care - if your LTV and credit are good. We
built on 50 acres; by the time we started construction, we almost
owned our lot outright, with about a 50% LTV when we were done with the
house, based on the bank's appraisal. With that much invested of
our own funds, nobody blinked at the financing. We used Guaranty
Bank which might hopefully work for you, if they are in your area.
Another
subdividing idea might be to record some type of 'Rural Land Use
Plan'. Around here, you can break any sized lot into sub lots of
35 acres each, without anybody to stop you. Meaning, if you have
70 acres, you could subdivide into two 35-acre lots... But this is Colorado, how does that help you?In my county, to "protect"
land, they are encouraging a process they call the "RLUP" (Rural Land
Use Plan). The RLUP is a process that is reviewed by county
planners, and allows dividing into higher densities than would
normally be allowed, by having the owner put a certain percentage into
conservation easements that cannot be developed for X number of years. So
what you might do, is figure out a plan to subdivide say two or three
building lots of a reasonable size (say, 3 or 5 acres each). You
could locate the other two away from you, say on the other side, and
possibly sell them later. The remaining land you could have as
one "big" lot of say, 60 acres, and then put a protective covenant on
it if you need to, to prevent development for a certain period, say, 15
or 20 years.
This "big lot" would of course, remain owned by you, and the
easement conditions could stipulate that you retain all rights for
recreation, farming, minerals, etc., only no residential
development. Now, this can be tricky, but if you had a plan
like this, with a set of covenants that would travel with the land for
a little while, you might be able to breeze through a subdivision
process and your neighbors will be excited because of the "natural
space" that will be preserved for awhile. In 20 years, it would
be worth more and could possibly be subdivided then. Pick a
time frame.
There are some state and federal tax breaks for
people who sell conservation rights, but that can be a much more
painful process.
Not sure if this helps at
all, but perhaps it will give you some ideas. Are you planning on
farming the land? Perhaps there won't be much opposition if you
are farming it, and only want to break off three acres to build on....
Keep at it.. It will be worth it when you are done.Take care, John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/21/2005
Sorry, to add to above, since I re-read your post - Look hard at a
conservation easement for the balance of the land - It might really be
liked by your neighbors, since it will keep the rural feel for a
guaranteed amount of time.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/7/2005
It's hard to tell - They are typically made specific to your house, so
it's not like you can check the price at evil orange (HD) or another
big box.
Typically, I think you are best off if you can get a minimum of 3
bids. I was shocked by my first bid, and figured they were just
whacked. After I had a total of 4, it became obvious what the
general/average price was.
Be sure you are comparing apples to apples, and be advised, that if
anything is wrong with the plans/engineering that you sign off on, then
YOU will be paying extra for new trusses for the trusses which were
designed incorrectly. Plus, you'll lose a lot of time.
It's best if you can have your framer closely involved in the process,
and have them measure and sign off on the engineering too.
Getting them right makes things easy, getting them wrong adds a lot of
expense and delays.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/22/2006
Here (Colorado) everyone says it's strong, but a lot of people have bought houses using ARM's or interest-only loans, and we have record foreclosures and a glut of unsold homes, so I'd say it's lukewarm, but not cold. Production builders are building new neighborhoods like mad, but a new neighborhood down the road from my house is 30% vacant, full of new $500K dream homes... A lot of the production builders have neighborhoods up, but not finished past the shell state, (no mechanicals, no drywall or finish) until they are sold, so the production builders do see the slowdown.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/6/2005
My engineer designed my footings specifically for the bearing of my
soils report. I would expect that this would be the best way to go. My
soils report said 3,000 lb bearing.
With my design, I had a lot of concrete (cellar roofs, main levels,
etc). Some footings were 48" wide, which required multiple longitudinal
rebars, as well as rebar across the widths of the footing. I would
highly recommend having your foundation designed by the engineer
for the ICF weight.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/6/2005
Doh.... Sorry ralph, I didn't notice the poster name.
If you don't have an engineer /soils guy yet, Landmark Engineering in Loveland is familiar with ICF, and does both open hole inspections as well as the structural design.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/7/2005
The 48" footers were in the cellar area, where we have lots of 8" ICF
wall, supporting a 12" structural slab, hence larger footers.
The foundation was designed based on a soils report, which purported
soil that had 3,000# bearing - After digging, the open hole inspection
found we were pretty much on solid rock everywhere. Good for
foundation, bad for excavation budget.
The Nudura rep will give you a book/CD of all the details. Take
your design plans along with the book, and schedule a meeting with your
engineer. I didn't know my details at the time, but ideally you
know what TGI depth you want, what basement depth you want, etc.
If you have a framing plan, that will be great and save you some money.
The engineer will insert detail drawings for things like ledgers, floor
and beam pockets, rebar installation, rebar schedules, etc. They
will stamp a set of plans, and you can take the works to the building
department for your permit.
Be advised that you will have to pay your engineer or his agent to
perform on-site inspections of the steel installation of the ICF
walls. These generally cost me about $135-$150. Landmark
has several folks who are trained with the Nudura and the steel
inspections (I broke them in!). They will send you a stamped
letter that you give the inspector.
Initially, Larimer said that I had to have both the area building
inspector (there are 4 inspectors, one for each quadrant of Larimer)
and my engineer do the inspection, "in case the engineer missed
something" - However, when I asked my building inspector at the footing
inspection, he said "Nope. Just have letters for the steel
inspections when I come for Frame". So you end up paying for the
inspections, and you have the county guys out for:
-Footing/Setback Inspection
-Underground plumbing, and slab if you have anything unusual.
-HVAC/Electrical/Plumbing Top Out/Frame/Fireplace
-Insulation, Roof,
-Gypsum
-Final
It was kinda weird not having the county inspector out between the footing/underground plumbing and the 4-way/frame inspection.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/3/2006
Have you talked to any other contractors? My house is on solid
rock, and my engineer was tickled pink, no footer cushions, just
concrete on rock. In fact, my deck piers are poured with rebar
that was epoxied into rock where we couldn't go 4' below the grade.
Sounds like bunk to me, but perhaps local conditions dictate
otherwise. I'd talk to several others, or your engineer if you
have one.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/16/2005
PM me if you need more details, but I can give you this much - I
had lots of delays during the exterior/dry in on my house (Berthoud,
Colorado) because of all the rain we got last year (unusual for Colorado). I did some work, but hired most stuff out. I did most of my finish work (wood floors, paint, trim, tile, cleaning). I
pretty much started digging/blasting April 2004. January 1, 2005, I
had my four way and framing inspections completed and was ready for
sheet rock. It took me 3.5 months to go from framing completed, ready for sheet rock, to move in. Site finished wood floors. It could definitely be done faster than I did it, especially because I was doing it all myself. What
seems to be the factors slowing things down? Getting subs to show
up? Getting them to finish on time? (I had problems with
this). Write liquidated damages into your contracts, that usually
helps.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/30/2005
You need to get all of these in writing, and some contracts have these
built in... If your subs actually read the contracts, they might balk -
Liquidated damages and penalties are usually reserved for big
commercial jobs, very large residences, etc. It may be tough to
enforce them in your state, I'm not a lawyer...
Essentially, you can write contracts such that A) The sub pays a
pre-determined penalty for every day they are late, excluding some
conditions (that should be listed in the contract) and/or B) the sub
pays for extra costs (damages) associated with their delay of the
project.
I did not write these into my contracts, but when my electrician didn't
get electrical trim done (the only thing we needed for CO and closing
our permanent financing) I pushed on him and he credited me the half
cost of our rate lock extension... It was probably the best I could do
since I didn't get anything in writing WRT these kind of damages.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/14/2005
Depends on your code department. You probably won't want to
zone the HRV/ERV (I put an HRV in my ICF house). But I would set
it up to run non-interlocked (see your manufacturer's instructions). I
think the key will be convincing the building department that your
zoned system will work with all combinations of open/closed
dampers. Typically in the commercial world, a mechanical engineer
will stamp plans for his design, and thus "assume responsibility" in
the inspectors mind. I have an exotic home-brew zoning
system, but I only zone radiant heat (much easier) and our cooling load
is so small, zoning wouldn't really benefit it. The inspector didn't even know the radiant was zoned... looked the same to him (wires and valves).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/6/2005
I wouldn't rely on X10 for anything that needed to be reliable.
If you plug computers in without special filters, or units are on
different phases of your house, you need all sorts of repeaters and
bridges to make things tolerable, and they are still not 100% reliable.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/14/2005
I was at a talk on log homes about a year ago. The guy presenting built custom log homes. He opened with a line something like this: "If
your looking for affordable, low maintenance, and energy
efficient, go elsewhere, you won't be happy with a log home".... The
natural checking (cracking) and movement of logs make it hard to get a
good air seal, and at the chinking(seals) & gaps, there isn't much
thermal break. But they are beautiful...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/1/2006
Your best advice is to try to get some idea of the percolation rates
and then talk to a septic engineer. Out here, if a system
percolates badly, the prices for a typical 3,000 sf house can go from
$3,000 (for a regular system) to $25,000 (for a moderately engineered
system) very quickly.
The price of the lots may reflect this.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/1/2006
Getting 'Ballpark' bids won't help much; your subs won't honor them
when you have your plans done, and by the time the work starts, they
will probably have adjusted prices to meet material and pricing
pressures. Ken S had some GREAT insight in some of the other
posts on this. All of the quotes I got before plans, and most of
the quotes I got when I was going for bank financing were worthless,
because prices WILL change between the start of the project, and say,
the time you are ready for drywall. Drywall prices have jumped four
times in the last two months...
The one good thing is you get to meet lots of subs and figure out which
ones you want to work with. Just don't waste their time if they
are busy bidding on plans that are not VERY close to final, or you wind
up doing yourself a disservice.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/14/2005
SIPS are Structural Insulated Panels, which ARE NOT "panelized
building" (which, from what I've seen, is not usually done with energy
efficiency in mind, but there are good exceptions). To
manufacture SIPS, Urethane or another type of foam is bonded between
two sheet material layers, typically sheets of OSB. T&G
material and sheetrock are available in some configurations. SIP's
are manufactured to pre-set and custom lengths, and are essential the
structural components of the wall, with insulation, sheathing, etc. all
in one. They can go up very fast and make an efficient
envelope.
I built using insulated concrete
forms instead of SIP, but did do a SIP'ish style roof. I suspect
that your code department probably freaked out because SIP roofs are
un-vented, hence the apparent problems.
My
roof was conve
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/14/2005
My roof was conventionally
framed with factory engineered trusses and 3/4" roof deck, which had a
spray in place open cell foam that is air and vapor impermeable.
It creates essentially a one-sided SIP. There is an
amendment to the 2003 IRC that allows for unvented roofs, which are
proving to be more efficient than their conventional
counterparts. With this amendment in hand, the county easily
approved my unvented roof.
Perhaps you can list the details of what your code
department objected to, so that other SIP builders can prepare
for their processes.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/17/2005
Everything is in the details - The Alaska SIP roof failures were
because the SIPS were not tight, and moisture laden air passed through
them from inside the houses and condensed, and then rotted the roof
sheathing. By the same token, a framed roof with an Icynene
insulation will be identical from the sealing perspective, slightly
less in that you have an 11" 2x4 conduction bar at internal web
locations. (However, given the R of wood, at that length, it's
still very good) - again, totally depending on how the details of
the installation are done - Are the joints between SIPS sealed
properly, what about joints/interfaces between roof, SIP, foundation,
doors, windows?).
My blower door test freaked the operator out -
He thought his equipment was broken. Even a stick frame house
using conventional materials and barriers will do significantly better
with very careful attention to the details during construction.
When you are starting to pick these kinds of nits, and really pay
attention to detail, factors such as your vent fan design for bathrooms
and makeup air for combustion furnaces are vastly more significant.
Take an often overlooked element - The bath fan - People plumb these from
their bathroom out the roof, usually with a metal duct, and then don't
look at the thermal path - Right through conventional insulation and
behind the sheetrock. They rely on the typical built-in backdraft
dampers in the hood and vent (usually flaps of metal) and call it good
enough. But with a blower door test these will show up, unless of
course, the tester seals off all the "normal" leaks that they do when
they test - make up air for non-sealed combustion furnaces and water
heaters, vent fans, etc... Now, once the test is done, they
uncover them, but it's still an inefficiency. Alternatively,
sealed dampers can be installed in the ducting, and the ductwork
insulated.... but I digress.
The conversation here is good, but the details will vary between houses
and designs - conditioned attics and unvented roofs have a proven track
record in energy efficiency. Whilst they do not pipe in hot/cold
air from the HVAC system, there has been some recent study on the
design by the DOE and others. Looking at the 2004 amendments to
the International Energy Code covers them (for good reason), and take a
look at most of the Solar Decathlon Entries - They are generally using
unvented roof designs. (SIPS, horizontal ICF, etc.).
The CU Solar team (solar.colorado.edu) utilized the biobased spray
insulation I used in my attic to make what they call "bio SIPs" - To
avoid the oil costs and drawbacks of SIPS, they have done some
significant research in making SIP's green. (IMHO, while SIP's
and ICF are super efficient compared to conventional construction, they
are not really Green - They take a lot of resources to make.
Nevertheless, I built using ICF and we're building my parents house now
using SIPS provided oil prices don't climb any higher)- Ultimately both
help my utility payment...
Imagine my surprise when I saw my insulation guy on the front page of
the local paper spraying CU's solar decathlon entry. (They are
defending champs!).
 | | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/16/2004
I used VBuck - it was great that it was light, but you still have to
brace a lot. The installer I hired to help me had only used PT
lumber on previous jobs, and after using it, hates to go back to PT
lumber. I bought the bracing pans, and have lots to sell, so if
you decide to use it, I can make you a deal on the corner bracing
pans.
It is light, and a single person can handle most window bucks by
him/her self. I filled the voids inside the Vbuck with foam
before pouring, which makes for a very efficient window buck.
Drawbacks - It costs a pretty penny, and you do need to brace it per the directions.
Hint - For the sill plates, I drilled 6" holes with a hole saw to
ensure I had good access to the concrete. For the basement, I
drilled these with a 1/2" chuck corded drill. That was OK, but
took a while. For the main level, I took all the sills home one
night, put the hole saw in my drill press, and drilled all the holes in
less than 1/2 hour. (As opposed to 1/2 the number of holes in 4-5
hours).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/17/2004
Ken is correct - the holes are for ensuring concrete flow/consolidation.
One thing I did, is we were recessing our windows a bit from the
outside of the exterior surface to give a deep adobe look. We
framed our VBuck bucks 3" larger than the window RO, and then after
everything was poured, I rotozipped the outermost 'L' channel from the
VBuck, and inframed a wood buck from dimensional lumber. We set
the wood back in 1/2" from the rotozipped edge, which was 1.5" from the
outside edge. The stucco guy simply wraps the stucco in, and we
get a nice relief that softens the lines of the house, without leaving
much sill for snow to sit on. It also gives you some wiggle room
should something get racked or bowed, but I found the corner braces
from the vbuck folks held everything square, including my wood bucks
(garage doors).
The real advantage of VBuck is if labor is really expensive in your
area. 2 guys did all the bucks for my main level (30+ openings)
in less than a day. Otherwise, I'd probably use PT wood.
Another alternative I've heard of that my building officials would not
approve is to make the bucks out of conventional lumber, and then
staple 15# felt to the concrete contact areas before
installing/pouring.
Good luck,
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/21/2005
Just my experience... Our ICF walls came out great. My
distributor really prides himself on helping DIY'ers and his installers
get things straight, because he doesn't want bad ICF jobs to give the
products a bad name.
I had seen both extremes (very straight, and barely on the footing, as I did my research).
I think plumb and straight walls has a lot to do with the installer and
the tools they have (lots of adjustable bracing), and I think the block
can help. I did 6000+ sf of wall, and the walls are all within
1/8" of plumb over a 25' tall wall. Straight is easy, if you are
prepared. On my basement, I rushed, and I got two small waves
(~3/4" over 4-6') over two large window openings on a 60' long
wall. We rasped the foam to make them straight, but I was pissed,
I could have done better. On the main level, larger openings, but
more experience, we kept things right on - within 1/8' over 60'.
The trick is lots of bracing, enough hands on pump day, and lots of
exterior stringlines. We would pump the level in about 1.5 hours,
plumb up the corners, and then adjust the turnbuckles on the bracing
until pre-cut spacer blocks just touched stringlines run along the
outside of the forms. This made plumbing/straightening easy, and
a couple of crews of 2 (one to hold the block, one to adjust the brace)
could plumb everything up in 10 minutes (2 complete passes around the
perimeter). Some ICF contractors were impressed with the
straightness. My sheetrock guys loved it, straight, lots of
support for the rock edges, and attachment points every 8".
That said, I think the longer blocks, with lots of steel in them,
helped a lot. We had a #5 rebar on ever level, along with the
nudura form lock (steel ladders inside the ICF).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/21/2005
Hello John<
I'd
like to ask you how your distributor was helpful beyond selling you the
ICF's. For example, did they supply the bracing and have an
experienced installer onsite for the pour etc.? Also, what was the cost
per sq. foot for materials including rebar, labor & ICF's? Finally,
what ICF product did you use? Thanks for your help & ICF experience!
I used the Nudura product - I took their class first, and the
diwstributor support was great. They delivered materials, even
single cans of spray foam, saving me hours of driving so I could focus
on the ICF's. The salesman used to be an installer, and would
come out and check on things and offer ideas and advice.
I spent ~$9.15 per square foot of wall. This covered ICF's,
footing concrete, form-a-drain for the footings, structural steel
(beams), rebar (lots of it, $$$), concrete for walls and footings,
window wells, VBuck and bracing for windows, and a helper. The
helper and I did all the ICF work, and then a few extra friends and the
ICF sales guy would show up to help us for the pours.
The distributor/salesguy:
Had contacts for helpers/installers
Offered the class (2 days) learning to do ICF.
Delivered Materials.
Helped set first course
Came the day before the pour to do a 'pre pour
inspection' to make sure we wouldn't have any surprises or that I
didn't forget any utilities, etc.
Rented bracing, special (tiny) concrete vibrator, and other specialized tools.
Came the day of the pour to help pour, and not just
help in 'supervising', but actually working his a$$ off pumping
concrete, consolidating, or checking plumb.
The middle bid I had to do all the work with pressure treated lumber
bucks was ~$16.00 psf of wall. I saved around $41k doing it
myself, it took almost 3 months of solid work to go from empty hole to
both ICF level's complete, main floor in, basement cement floor in,
radiant tubing/perimeter drain/radon in. So It was a lot of
work... We could have gone faster, but rain was a problem, adding
about a month in delays. A good crew of 4 could probably do it in
3 weeks to a month.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/21/2005
Definitly local market forces at work - My locale is expensive, the
'average' used house, old, nothing fancy starts at almost $300k.
A buildable lot away from the city, 1 care, can run $150k, plus water
tap ($30k), septic, electrical, etc..... When everything costs so
much, all the costs get passed on.
I figure VBuck cost me ~0.50 or so per square foot of wall more than PT lumber. It wasn't cheap...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/23/2005
I just had a mud pan installed for a master shower, $750, shower is 5x6 or so with a curved wall and a bench.
I think the mud pan with a tiled floor makes for the nicest shower, abit more expensive.
Not sure about the price of the shower wall tile.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/7/2005
You can pour below 40, but don't let your sub order concrete until he has
given a quality plan on how he will protect the concrete. (Not that
this has much to do with mud pans, but it's a great discussion).
1) If you have ICF's, the sub simply needs to cover the top of the wall
in cold weather, and leave the bracing on an extra day. This is a
reason that ICF's are popular in Canada. Eh?
1a) Conventional foundation - If it's a regular foundation, the entire
foundation needs to be protected, sides, footing, and top. (Concrete
blankets, tenting, and very likely, tenting with propane heaters.) This
isn't cheap, and takes a lot of manpower and rental equipment. Thus,
your subs won't want to do it. If your sub knows you know a thing or
two, and are expecting the concrete to be taken care of, often they
will wait the extra day(s) until a regular pour can be guaranteed,
rather than have you jumping their case and expecting the rental
heaters out there.
Same goes for exterior flatwork - they may order a hot mix (with
additives) and hot water usually comes on the truck, but make sure they
(or you, depending on the agreement) have made provisions to protect
the concrete.
Along the lines of freezing weather and concrete - don't let anybody
pour concrete on frozen soil. (Footings, flatwork, etc). If you end up
with a frozen basement and have not been able to get your basement
floor poured, hold off on pouring the basement floor and go ahead and
start framing the house. Once you have the basement capped, you can run
some heaters down there and get the frost out of the soil before
pouring the floor.
Sorry to hear about your crummy pour - thanks for sharing though.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/20/2006
I've started getting some really fantastic information on my ICF walls. This is a
12-hour graph from this week (Tuesday). During the day we had almost
70-degree outdoor temperatures, and then that night, we hit single
digits. This is the extreme case of thermal mass, but from the
graph attached, you can see the sun set at 5:30 (significant drop in
temperature) and the temperature of the thermal mass continues rising
for several hours before starting to cool slightly.
For this instrumentation, my indoor temperature is measured in my back
hall where I have a weather station mounted; it is a lot of west-facing
glass, and tends to pop about two degrees during the day, whereas the rest
of the house is more constant. We typically see the indoor
temperature vary from 71 to 73 (my wife likes it warm).
In this graph, you'll notice after the sun goes down, the indoor
temperature is virtually constant. In this type of scenario, we
usually see the boiler turn on around 3:00 am for an hour or so, and
then usually stay off, even in sub-30-degree temperatures, until the
morning sun takes the heating responsibility over via passive solar.
I've got lots of other stuff to share. One decision I'm going to try to
make with this is if I should roll my black EPDM roof with a
solar-white type product. I could get thicker, better roofs with
longer warranties in black, so I elected to install the black roof,
then roll white liquid EPDM over it, adding a layer of protection to
the real roof, and reflecting sun. I've not done this yet, but am going
to try to evaluate the winter benefit (the hotter roof surface
temperatures reducing the entropy/heat flux via the attic) versus the
summer heat increase. In a 50/50 climate, it would be a toss-up,
but I'm not sure... I may just have to wait a year to get better
data on that one. We have huge amounts of east-facing glass, and
a fair bit of south glass (views on both) so summer gain is slightly
higher than I'd like (we get into mid-upper 70's) but we don't have
these windows screened from the high-angle summer sun yet...
The last five days we have been in single digit and minus temps, so I'll
add more data. I think the thermal mass is less optimized in
those cases, but interestingly, the core (concrete) temperature only
varies by a few degrees... Temperature swings are free reloading
of the flywheel, and are best, but not exclusive.

| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/23/2006
I need to get my boiler data graphed against this graph - I have it all
in data files, I just need to build a routine to graph the two in one
place.
I'll get a floorplan up. It's a piece of my system (a floorplan that
shows real-time temperatures) I've not worked on, but a few bits about
my system:
The basement is 8" concrete, 2 5/8" thick foam (each side) Nudura
ICF. The main level is 6" concrete core, same foam, Nudura
ICF. My attic is insulated with 11" of biobased spray foam
applied to the underside of the roof deck. We are situated on the
first foothill of the mountains, looking out at the plains, so our east-facing wall picks up sun exposure starting first sunrise, which I've
found seems to support slightly higher ICF wall temperatures than even
the south wall.
My house is a Santa Fe adobe style, with a flat roof concealed within
the ICF walls. My attic, before insulation, ranged from 18" at
the low area, to 30" at the peak. With the attic effectively
"conditioned", heat from cans, etc. is contained within the attic. However, the attic air temperatures do not seem to move at all with
cans on/off, so I suspect the overall contribution is small.
My roof is currently black. I've got some graphs of my attic
temperature (air temperature, conditioned air) vs. the sheathing
temperature I'll post, too.
On this particular night, we had a big front of arctic air hit which
subsequently held air temperatures (outside) in the single digits or
sub zero for days. I can correlate this to my weather data, but I
wouldn't doubt some intervention that night.
If I could get away sleeping cooler, I would!
I need to add one more sensor too; right now, we use the hot water on
demand feature of our boiler for domestic hot water, i.e.
tankless. So washing dishes looks the same as HVAC heat on my
graphs. With a temperature sensor on the DHW line, I can
distinguish between the two.
I'm currently testing/correlating this system with my monthly propane
use. I'm measuring the output of the boiler (it modulates, so it
might be on, but at a low 'power') and integrating that, using the
"standard" BTU output of propane and known boiler efficiency curves to
try to "predict" my bill real-time... Once I know my daily usage, for
heat, I think I can build a function predicting use given an average
daily temp.
All of this, besides an interesting academic exercise, is hopefully
going to allow me to put the boiler into backup duty and add a properly-sized active solar system to the hydronic heat. I really didn't
know what the use would be, and didn't want to delay getting into my
house, doing solar up front. The boiler was the quick way in, and
will be a nice backup should the clouds hit.
I'll try to shore this up later this week. Thanks for the great input!
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/15/2006
I had been meaning to update this with some more information... Some of these graphs have some aliasing, as I've been playing with some
control algorithms and using the econo-cool feature of my HRV just to
see what kind of transfer function describes the cooling ability.
The first graph here is a two-week period of typical Colorado spring
weather, followed by a cold storm, which we are starting to come out
of. I've superimposed a boiler run state (light blue) but it does
not show the modulation (45K-200K Btu), so it's not all that helpful,
except that you'll notice that the boiler is almost always a late
evening/early morning run time. The boiler also runs for hot water
demands (on-demand only) so dishwashing/showers show up in here too.
Notice the sinusoidal nature of the ICF concrete walls
(blue/green/yellow). The peak temperature of the wall occurs shortly
after the sun sets for the night. The integral area under the
curve until the next morning is essentially energy that is dissipated
~1/2 through the outside foam to the environment and 1/2 to the
inside. I think this is key to high thermal mass designs (adobe,
AAC, ICF). Although each 'insulation mode' has some
advantages/drawbacks, the nature of the graph is a good talking point
for thermal mass in general.
It takes several days for the ICF walls to cool significantly, but they
do trend downward. If I were building in an area with consistently
cold or consistently hot climate, I'd probably consider either
uninsulated concrete, very thick (for hot) or SIP, with solar/passive Trombe/internal thermal mass.
The second photo here is the cellar telemetry. This measures the
open air temperature in the ceiling of the wine cellar, along with the
outside temperature. Currently the cellar is ICF on four walls, with
a steel door, an ERV exhaust with a fresh-air intake from the basement,
and a 12" thick concrete roof with a black EPDM roof. The roof
will be covered by stamped concrete when the freezing quits around
here. The time constant of the concrete is huge, and the interior
temperature of the cellar is maintained very nicely, with no HVAC other
than a few CFM of stale air exhausted every 6 hours by the ERV.
  | | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/15/2006
In this graph, which is not thermal mass, I have the sheathing
temperatures of my roof sheathing (under black EPDM) versus the attic
air temperature immediately inside the 11" of biobased spray insulation
applied to the underside of the roof decking. You can see where
we move into a steady state (constant heat flow from inside the house
to outside) during the cold last week, versus the transient period
where heat is moving both ways. The overall performance of this
assembly would be similar to SIP or spray-foam stick framing, although
this has 11" of foam, versus the typical wall assembly, so in a wall
assembly the temperatures will track closer together.
Overall, the roof sheathing tends to track the outside temperature, but
is much more volatile as the black EPDM roof collects sun during the
day. During continued cold, solar radiation gain on the south
roof vastly outpaces the north roof, which has significant architectural
features blocking it from the southern exposure. Perhaps the best
energy balance over the course of a year might be to keep the
south/east roofs black, and roll the north roof (the majority of the
structure) with white EPDM... Hafta think more on that.
Oddly enough, my south attic has higher highs (as I would expect) and
lower lows, than the attic on the north side. I suspect that this
may be a combination of factors, including that the boiler exhaust is
on the north roof, and the north roof has more protection from
prevailing winds than the south roof does.
 | | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/16/2006
I buy that 100%. My dream configuration would have been two adobe
walls separated by 4-5" of EPS, but practicality said ICF would be the
way to go, for cost and schedule reasons. :)
With the EPS on only the outside, you wouldn't split the integrated
energy under the curve 50/50 with the outside, it would be directed
inside, and thus, more efficient.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/12/2006
Regular steel wall forms have ties every few feet to hold the two sides
together, so you'd have to use a bigger tie and spear the foam, which
would make forming more difficult. But I think that this method
is probably the closest way to implement it.
The ties would bridge, but it would probably not be outrageous.
I know there are systems that do this (I believe they pour flat and
tilt up), but I suspect their popularity is limited because this is
going to be an intensive system to install and finish. Rastra
blocks are almost a variant of this, which I had seriously evaluated
before opting against it. Rastra is a great product, but is
nowhere near as popular as a conventional ICF... Why? I suspect
that having to bring in cranes to move blocks around makes installation
difficult and expensive.
I would believe ICI would definitely be better, it was in a way my first
choice. But actually _doing_ ICI was a challenge
(adobe/insulation/adobe) - The masses of everything start to get really
big.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/12/2006
There are some commercial ICF and SIP buildings here (same builder)
that are hoping to implement the monitoring, and do some active solar
control. I may have a night job!
Contact me off list if there is anything I can help you out with!
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/12/2006
The thermal mass to get the flywheel effect is substantial, SIP skins (unless we are talking 4" thick skins) won't be adequate.
ICF _can_ go up very fast. (Seems like mine, DIY, was around a month
per level with rain delays). We (myself and one other person)
were stacking a level of my house in three days (two guys) but the bracing
(carrying it in, etc.) took forever. My distributor (a former
installer) said his four-man crew would finish a level of my house in one
week, (then a week off for steel and floor framing) and then another
week of ICF, for two weeks total for the ICF's. It took me usually three
days for a level, weeks to brace and do blockouts and other small
details, and a day to pour.
Actually, the first pour (basement) took us about 8 hours. Some wall
sections were 15' tall (walkout frost wall). That was a tough day,
but mostly because the concrete company had us waiting for trucks.
On the main level, we poured 12' and 15' walls in less than 3 hours.
Now - We are building an SIP house here (spray-foam attic like mine)
with a brick exterior, geothermally heated with a 10 kW solar PV
array... I won't have the time to instrument everything (like
confirming the COP of the geothermal unit) but if we had 10
temperatures to measure, what would we measure... I'll take some
input here, and then when I instrument this house, we can try to get
some comparisons. (I'm actually thinking about integrating my
instrumentation into a plug-and-play system, so it would be easy for
anyone to install).
How about:
1) Exterior skin temperature
2) Center of foam
3) Interior temperature.
(Do these for north and south sides).
7) Attic Air Temperature
8) Roof sheathing temperature (concrete tile roof, versus my black EPDM).
Others?
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/12/2006
Therein is the problem - cost, or finding someone to finish the interior
and exterior of Rastra at a reasonable cost is difficult. Anytime
you mention interior plaster, even over ICF (interior stucco even) in
my area, you are a minimum of $4.75 per square foot of wall, about the
same price as exterior stucco. (That is the cheapest I had bid, stucco
prices here averaged closer to $8.)
I have seen Rastra sheetrocked using glue, but I don't know what this would cost.
With my design, to get the required strength from Rastra, I would have
to cut out the dividers in most of the cells of a significant number of
walls prior to pouring... Like Mark said, playing to the strengths
would be key to making it cost-effective and a good
application... (My walkout basement and sloped lot weren't
helping my design). This was essentially turning it into a
conventional ICF, with a lot of waste. Rastra was also not cost-competitive with conventional ICF for my project.
Local Rastra plants could help a lot. Rastra's distribution has
changed recently, so I'm not sure how it is working now with the 'main' Rastra corporation owning things.
I had the occasion to visit this house during construction. After
I had visited, a fire tore through the area, the Rastra house (barely dried
in) was unscathed.
Very cool (page through the pictures):
mmcmillen.com/rastra/pages/08fire
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/26/2006
I would add that Direct Buy only works if you are willing to sometimes settle for, other times upgrade to, the exact product that they sell. Second, there is still a huge risk - if you find the products you are looking for, they may not be available when you try to buy them. I know people who priced all their cabinets, fixtures, etc. A month later, after the construction loan was approved, they went in to place their orders. The tub they had selected wasn't available because the manufacturer wouldn't sell to Direct Buy any more. The cabinets they selected were not available until two months after their construction schedule needed them because of problems with that manufacturer. Making a construction budget based on Direct Buy is a gamble, because they do have problems maintaining relationships with suppliers at times.
If you are using Direct Buy to build a house, be prepared to switch cabinet styles, pick a different flooring, or change a fixture when your supplier is unable to deliver.
Of three people I know who built houses with them, only one felt that they got what they wanted and got their money's worth. (These are $600K-$1M houses, so there was plenty of opportunity to make it back).
Direct Buy will also be a pain for your draws - Be sure you have a BIG up-front chunk of change, because Direct Buy will want a check up-front, and then your bank will probably not pay until it's on site, sometimes even installed. (As opposed to local suppliers that offer accounts).
Finally, be sure to add up all the Direct Buy handling fees/commissions and freight/shipping - some products are not as good of deal as they seem.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/9/2005
I really wanted geothermal, but am in one of those "hard dig"
areas. Geothermal is a great technology, but smart design can
virtually match geothermal performance for the same money, depending on
climate. I'm heating 6,000 sf for $1 per day (during
the heating season) with propane, but instead of putting the money in
geothermal (which was a significant investment in vertical bores) it
went into top line insulation, ICF walls, etc. Coupled with high
thermal mass, passive solar design, and good windows, we're not
spending much on heat. Moral: Using less energy is better than using cheaper energy. Using less, cheaper energy is best of all. Once
my structure was up, I was still considering geothermal. However,
it became pretty apparent that the structure wasn't going to use much
energy at all. Investing in geothermal in this situation is not
wise, since it will take longer than the expected lifetime of the
equipment to recover the investment. Now, if you amortize the
cost of the bores over several compressor lifetimes, it might be a
consideration, but it's still close. Not to bag on geothermal -
There are some great systems and great companies, and then there are
some companies who sell it like it's space shuttle parts. The
loop field costs are significant, and a higher risk investment than say,
spray seal insulation and good building science/design.
I instrumented the house with distributed
real-time temperature sensors. My plan was to measure the COP of
my system and make the manufacturer deliver on their claims, if
required. I didn't end up with geo, as much as I wanted it, but
the instrumentation system has been great. Generally, with 20-30
degree outside temperatures, the propane boiler turns on for about an
hour every 48 hours, and modulates down during that hour. If
I were going to do geo, I'd work with either a reputable local company. You need a local company if you are looking at vertical
bores with thermally enhanced grout. The going price in CO was
about $1,400 per well, typically one well per ton of capacity.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/10/2005
I did go with the soy based stuff. It was within $0.05 per
square foot of the icynene, but it worked better for my schedule (there
is one installer of each in the state that is competent and returns
calls). The Icynene guy was 8 hours away and would travel, the
biobased (soy) foam guy was 20 minutes away. On my
heating/cooling - I ducted and installed a 4 ton air handler for AC,
but thus far we have not needed it. I have an HRV with an
"econo-cool" option that keeps the house very comfortable thus far. On
my heating, we have radiant with a 200k boiler that moduates, so we
when only need 45k for heat, we only run at 45k, etc. It also
does hot water on demand, and thus far appears to keep up with hot
water for the dishwasher, master shower, and a sink no problem. When
the local geothermal guy spec'ed his geothermal (waterfurnace,
expensive, proprietary and poorly tempered circuit boards) system to
drive my radiant and provide forced air cooling, he was spec'ing a 6
ton unit, which appears to be way overkill. Realistically, the
house could be cooled with 2-3 tons of cooling, a bit more for heating
with forced air. The high thermal mass of concrete and radiant is
a great mix. A smaller boiler would have worked fine for my
installation, but since it modulates, I don't really suffer much
(probably less than 1/2 of a percent) for the oversizing.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/16/2005
I think it will depend on your installation and local costs.
For my installation, the geoexchange folks said I needed 6 tons, WITH
the ICF house. 6 tons of geothermal infastructure was WAY too
expensive to recover in the life of the house. That
said, even with calculations, I believe the geoexchange folks were also
CYA - I think 6 tons is too much for my particular ICF house, but I was
relying on their expertise. The tonnage of the
loopfield will also vary with your climate and soil - Your geothermal
designer will need to account for soil that does not conduct well or
very cold/warm climates to ensure that your loopfield does not
saturate, or it will not perform well during the later portions of the
heating/cooling season. In some cases, you end up needing 6 tons
of loopfield for a 4 ton unit, etc because of un-optimal soils.
But I think that's pretty rare.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/30/2005
SIP just didn't have quite the right properties for us - I wanted
strength, thick wall (we built an "adobe" style) and the thermal mass,
plus we are in a high fire area. SIP's were pretty expensive too
around here. SIPS are strong, but limit some design points, and
would have required special steel headers over a lot of our big
windows. ICF lintels span 12 feet on both our walkout and main
level. Also, we get a lot of huge chinook winds, ICF was quieter
in the houses I looked at. My brother is a builder and is big on
SIPS. SIPS have gone up a lot with increases in oil. The
fire and architectual features (thick walls) were the key drivers
though. My uncle builds 60000 sf office buildings
with steel frames and SIPS, but has switched to ICF for cost and
performance. I was hoping to do geothermal, but our soil is just too rocky - We blasted out 400 tons of rock for our basement. I
installed a modulating boiler that does domestic hot water on
demand. The standard on demand units really didn't have the
capacity to heat ~6000 sf in Colorado, and the flow rates throughany
boiler really need to be matched properly to your radiant system.
My plan with a modulating boiler is that I can tie in solar next winter
and only have the boiler kick on when it is needed. The boiler is
97% efficient. In winter (below 32) our boiler only turns on for
about 2 hours every 48-60 hours.... I have temperature
sensors in the concrete inside the ICF's - In summer the walls
(concrete inside) sits at about 70, and in winter, they sit at
55.
We ducted for AC and installed an air handler &
HRV, but realisitically, we don't need it. In our area, we get
1-2 weeks in the 95-100's when it would nice, and even with efficient
windows, it does get warm. We are probably going to go ahead and
install it (3 tons) because my wife is preganant and so she's always
warm. :) Also, right now our roof (EPDM sing le ply
membrane) is black, we have a solar reflective coating on order, so
that will reduce the load too.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/30/2005
4 ton air handler installed, but I think 3 tons would do it...
Our last house had a swamp cooler, and was GREAT! but with a
house so quiet that a clock ticking echos, we like the quiet... And
swamp coolers are a bit loud. When you look at swamp
coolers, I'd personally look for a plastic one (no rust, easier to
clean and last longer) and one that has a belt between the motor and
fan... The diret drive units are cheaper, but a lot louder.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/4/2005
You got it. Generally, when navigating in the northern hemisphere, "West is best".:) You
might do a little poking around - I found by spinning my house so
it is skewed slightly off of South, favoring East, I would increase the
overall solar exposure about 20%, because hills to the West of me
prematurely cut off the solar gain at about 5:00 PM. It's designed
to maximize gain during the winter, but shield the windows from direct
solar during the summer.I don't remember the exact location, but
if you don't have any other close topographical features that might cut
off the exposure early, you'd probably be fine to just stake it. Good luck, J
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/4/2005
My brother is a general in NM. NM is owner-builder friendly, and in many areas, for better or worse, codeless. You will find it harder depending on what style of house you are building, depending on your area.
Getting pitched roofs with gables will be more expensive than the
traditional flat roofs used on adobes, etc. I kinda found that
out building a adobe in CO, I was paying a premium for good quality
flat roof systems over slate pitched roofs that are common.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/30/2005
I would be careful spec'ing your foundation walls based only on thickness - My basement had 10'6" walls, 8" thick - The rebar, placed correctly (on the tension side) is what is really critical here. Extra wall thickness never hurts, but the steel schedule is where your backfill height is really determined. The same 8" walls support a main level of 6" concrete walls.
Steel is expensive, but cheap insurance. We had #5's on 24" centers vertically, and on 18" centers horizontally (24 was spec'ed, but it was easier to do 18", so it's overkill.
Do your online plans specify a rebar schedule? If not, you could probably get an engineer to whip up a quick rebar schedule for your 9' walls and throw a stamp on a letter for a couple hundred bucks.
Also, setting the foundation higher is great if you can do it. Makes for more flexibility in setting your final grade later.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/28/2005
You won't be able to get a traditional construction loan if there is
already a line of credit on the property - the bank making a
construction loan will probably insist on being the first mortgage/lien
holder. If you can swing it on only savings and the line of credit,
then it could work.
I'm finding the discount for cash versus a
check in a week or two isn't that big - also, you tend to do better
finance-wise if you have accounts from your material suppliers, and
make use of their money/products, paying the monthly.
My subs
would knock 2% to at most 3% off for cash - Tight market, lots of work,
no need to get the cash in pocket now. If everyone offered the
discount, it might be worth it, but most subs thought I was odd. :(
Good luck,
J
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 6/28/2005
Good luck! First, on the T&G - Price it at
your local lumberyard or sawmill. I bought 1x6 T&G pine here
for $0.45/lf, which is just about $1 per square foot. I doubt
you can hire people to remove the ceiling for that.
On
the copper sinks - The differences in copper sinks, and prices, is
generally with the thickness of the copper. There are some really
thin ones, and some thicker ones, on eBay. Either one will work,
the thinner ones sound a bit "tinny". Now, there are
some really expensive copper sinks here at the design houses that
retail for $2000+. They don't sound tinny at all.I took a
mid-grade eBay copper sink and wrapped it in fiberglass, then a layer
of grout, and a layer of fiberglass. They are solid, and unless
you look from below, you wouldn't know they weren't the "expensive"
sinks. But, as a sink, without all the mess, the eBay sinks work
fine. Most copper sinks don't have overflows, so check into your
codes, or try to keep the inspector distracted if it matters in your
area. My inspector didn't care.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 6/22/2005
If you are building using borrowed funds, doing the work yourself WILL cost you more money than subbing it out in the long run. I
built ~2,700 sf, my cost was ~$160 per sf, excluding land. I did
foundation, radiant heat, flooring, tile, finish, paint/stain, and a
million other things. I took 6 months off of my job, and worked
16 hour days for weeks on end. I wouldn't do it again. Darn
near lost a finger during an exhausted pre-work building
session... It will wear you out, unless you plan on taking a long
time to get stuff done. From start to finish was one year. I
subcontracted excavation, blasting, flatwork, framing, stucco, drywall,
air conditioning, plumbing, heating, and fireplaces. Be
sure you have a realistic time schedule and don't expect to do much
else except build if you do a lot of work yourself. I put off
hobbies, recreation, vacations, work, friends, family, etc. for a year,
and missed a lot... The stress during the project is incredible
(see the deconstruction thread)... When I was done,
I had added another $240k of equity... I figure I made 1/2 of it
just being the general, and the other 1/2 doing a lot of work
myself... If I work that out per hour, I didn't do that well...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 6/23/2005
Ken, Very well put! I didn't realize what I really enjoyed about building and what just burned me out until I read your post...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/29/2004
With excavation, that is partially the nature of the beast. If your
excavator finds that right where you want to put your house, there is a
giant alien solid rock monolith, he's not going to dig through that for
the same price as if it were a nice pile of potato dirt.
Get several bids, and make sure each bid lists what he is going to
do, what is/is not included (culverts, pipe, bedding material for water
lines, etc.). And what he will do if he encounters unforeseen subsurface
surprises. (i.e. is he going to dig through and then send you an extra
bill, cover it in his bid price, or call you and discuss possible plans
of action).
It's hard to beat someone who is highly recommended and interested in your project. Be sure to check references and insurance.
I am spending about 15% of my budget on excavation-related
activities. My site has lots of rock, and long utility runs. (I'm
betting the tremendous view offsets the increased cost :)
With all the excavation work I've had done, I've learned a lot.
1) Soils reports give you a good idea of what to expect digging wise,
but are still a guess. My soils said great dirt, and then we ended up
blasting 100 holes. Big $$, and virtually wiped out the contingency.
2) If you have rocky soil, you will probably need/want to have
your utilities "bedded" in a sand or fine gravel. Good excavators worth
their salt will recognized this and include it in their bid. Foregoing
bedding just means you get to have the utilities dug up and replaced
when the rocks damage the lines.
3) There are vast differences in the qualities of the septic
line pipe that different excavators will use. There is a heavier,
rubber gasketed pipe versus thinner, glued pipe. (There is also heavier
glued pipe). My excavator is using the heavier pipe throughout my
system, citing that by code; he has to use the heavy pipe on each side
of the tank, and the thinner pipe appears to weaken/crack over time as
people snake rooter, etc.
Be sure that when you compare bids, you are comparing pipe diameters
and sizes, etc.
The costs sound pretty reasonable, but it's different in each part of
the country.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/19/2006
Pretty neat, but I don't see the cost savings.
I used some 12"x20' logs in my interior, and I paid around $100 for
each log, and we boomed them into place when we had the boom truck out
for upper level lifting. Cost of boom time - $150, cost of logs,
$1,400 (14 logs). The cost for 14 similar faux logs is over $10K.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/18/2004
I am in the framing portion of my ICF house right now.
I shopped five different framers, and ended up going with some guys who
have seen it all. My house is their second ICF house, but the first
with some new stuff in the way I did my roof. What I found shopping framers is that some guys couldn't frame anything
without a super-detailed drawing of each wall. I can do drawings, but I
had what most people and my engineer consider a full set of plans. This
framer was getting panicky, and his price showed it.
Another framer took a look at my site (ready for interior framing) and
then gave me his price. His price was his standard price per square
foot, multiplied by the footprint size. (Keep in mind, with 11-13"
thick walls, there is a lot of square footage that doesn't have anything
done to it). He told me that even though the exterior walls were done
(and all the openings framed, no headers/lintels required) that I
really didn't save anything by doing the exterior in ICF, and that
framing was going to cost as much as a regular stick-frame house! Hah!
I had three framers (two who had not yet worked with ICF) who gave me
bids and all three were in the same ballpark. Each was reasonably
excited to learn, and none were worried about the learning curve - the
ICF distributor is in the area, which helped too.
I ended up picking the most experienced crew, even though I was only
their second ICF house. They are thinking about installing ICF in
addition to their framing, as they really think it's the way to build,
having helped out on two projects. On labor costs (labor here is
expensive) I paid about $2/sf for the framing of the subfloor and about
$4/sf to frame the roof (trusses) and interior walls and a large deck.
That price also included setting windows and doors.
As mentioned in other ICF posts in these forums, take a class. The
information in the class will help you guide the subs and other trades
and make everything easier for everyone. My electrician actually gave
me a slightly better price because he wanted to work on my job
specifically to gain knowledge on the products.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/13/2005
I took the Nudura training class (2 days, $150, credited on first
purchase). I highly recommend taking one of the ICF classes, and
with that class, a good dealer, and a little attention to detail, you
ought to be able to get great ICF results with most of the popular ICF
blocks.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/24/2005
I used a flat wall also, but here is what I have 'heard' so take it
with a grain of salt. Finding anything objective about ICF's is
darn near impossible. The market for this product is growing, but
tight, so most of the ICF dealers are beating the kidneys out of
everyone else for each sale, and a lot of FUD gets thrown around.
Do as much research as you can. A lot of the ICF sales guys don't
even really know their competition's ratings, but will misquote them at
the drop of a hat. There are some good ICF sellers too that will
just sell their product and provide good support. Keep searching
until you find the guys that sell their product instead of bashing the
others.
I've heard:
1- Consolidation
2- Strength/Extra steel
3- Fire protection
4- Possible gaps between foam blocks in non-concrete areas providing an air pathway???
On the other hand, they will have a higher flat-wall R-value, but a
lower thermal mass. That is really a building science issue.
After pouring my own ICF, I'd agree that consolidation could be a
problem with some of the grid ICF's - A lot more channels to flow
through. This could be taken care of by a good sub who knows how
to pour a more fluid mix without bows or blowouts, so this can be
mitigated.
The strength will not be as high, so you may end up with more steel,
but only your engineer can make this decision. Steel ain't cheap
either nowadays.
Finally, a firefighter was out looking at my walls, getting ready to
build his own. He had seen a fire melt the foam off of a screen
grid ICF, all the way through. If the fire rating is important to
your application (i.e. you are building in a high fire area) then it
should be considered, but if you are building in a typical
neighborhood, then it may not really be an issue. Perhaps he may
have more insight...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/5/2005
Joe,
I feel your pain - I'm getting close to done, and we are going to pretty much hit our budget, but there was some ebb and flow. By the time I had the structure dried in, I was burning money fast. But as I continued, I started coming under budget, and the unders are starting to counter the big overs.
I'm assuming you have a budget for each item, i.e. ICF, footings, floors, appliances, trim, etc.? Are you consistently going over on everything? You might need to initiate a corrective steering now to be sure to finish the project if everything is coming in way off of your budget.
If it won't cause problems for your final appraisal, you may be able to leave a couple of rooms unfinished, or downgrade the finish materials, to be sure to complete your project.
My plan was to install carpet in a couple of rooms that we had planned wood floors, until everything started coming back into alignment. Now I've recovered most of my overages, and am within the margin of my contingency, starting paint next week. In my case, my budgets were pretty good, but the volatility of steel caught me off guard, and I went over 100% on my structural steel, and 100% on my rebar. Ouch!
Good luck. Hang in there!
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/29/2006
If I had to choose an ICF product, I'd pick the Nudura ICF again in a second, since I installed them myself. I think it's all-around the best form for installation, plus slightly (1/8", which is minuscule) thicker foam, easy instant assembly, and lower shipping that most other forms, but they are all pretty much the same.
Owner-builders tend to overthink everything, from my historical perspective. Most ICF's are concrete and foam. With a good installer, they all pretty much look the same. Better forms can compensate for an inexperienced or lazy installer.
I think you probably find fewer installers because it takes a lot more effort to learn than, say, conventional framing. With fewer installers, the seedy ones seem to be the norm, but with other trades, such as framing or conventional foundations, there are just enough decent guys to dilute the bad ones and make it seem more legitimate.
Also, you'll find fewer installers because it costs more than conventional building most of the time, and most people won't pay extra for it, period. You'll find the EXACT same problem finding SIP installers; we had a lot of framers bid my parents SIP house way high because they didn't want to bother with something different. With a higher install cost, there is a smaller market, and thus, fewer installers.
I don't think ICF has anything to do with the weather - In fact, from my in-wall telemetry, ICF's perform best where you get temperature swings, and are probably better in slightly heat-intensive environments rather than cooling environments. I know ICF's are really popular in Canada. Mine in Colorado are amazing.
I don't think the lack of ICF installers is related to the weather
per se, but probably more typical construction for the area, and
construction prices.
Regions where concrete is more expensive
will have less ICF, too... I've seen ICF's dry up a lot around here when
concrete went from $61 to $110/yard.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/3/2007
The $40/month includes DHW. We are on propane, but our DHW is done via our conventional boiler, with an on-demand sensor - When someone turns on DHW, the boiler starts moving the heating fluid through a heat exchanger instead of the heating system, until the DHW demand is satisfied. Avoids heating a tank of water, and we can run everything at the same time (Boiler is a 200K Trinity), but technically I'm not running the radiant heat while doing DHW. However, my radiant heat typically only turns on once a day for a few hours anyway, so I'm not usually depriving myself of heat. :)
I do have a lot of intentional passive solar design which I believe is helping a lot. I have a lot of south, some east, and some west glass. We are high on a hill, looking east, so we get the sun the instant it comes up.
I was going to do geo, but I think once you start stacking multiple tons of energy efficient systems together, you have a harder time recovering each incremental additional cost. On my house, I don't think I could recover my investment in geothermal, although the geothermal guy thought I could. However, he uses software designed around conventional residential stick-frame construction, and SIPs/ICF is quite a bit different. If you use less energy to heat in the first place because of better insulation, then you won't save as much money with geothermal, and it will take longer to recover the cost. I'm happy with the conventional boiler, it's still pretty efficient (high 90's I believe, although slightly lower efficiency on propane vs. natural gas).
My parents are building with SIPs right now, so I'm getting to compare my O-B notes on ICF/stick/SIPs (Mine was ICF w/Icynene attic, my friend's was stick with Icynene, and my parents is SIP with Icynene roof). They are doing geothermal and a 10kw solar PV system, so they won't have any utility bills other than the water bill...
Calculating utility costs is rough at best. I was guesstimating $65-$70 per month, and it's come in quite a bit lower. My telemetry system will soon start monitoring actual gas usage if I get a little more time to work on it, which will make utility calculations easy on a per day/condition basis.
My experience has been that the biggest savings come in the spring and fall, when we get 60-80 degree days and 20-degree nights, so the daytime warming of the walls offsets the nighttime temperatures.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/2/2007
I would second some of what Joe said: -Costs more - in materials, time, and interest. -Deep windows/doors require more $$ to finish. -Bracing is critical.
But, my experience on several of the items was probably better than Joe's.
I used VBUCK for my window/door bucks and didn't have any problems with pulling away of the window bucks. I've never seen problems with wood either, but the wood ones I saw had lag bolts run through the bucks for the concrete to form around.
My basement had one small wave in a wall because I was pouring a 12' wall and only had 10' bracing for the pour. Of the 350 linear feet of basement wall, the only wave in the entire thing was about 1/2" on a 2' high by 8' long section. I was able to rasp the foam and adjust for it in the framing. On the main level, I had 12' bracing, and everything came out incredible. On my main level, I'm out less than 1/8" over a 65' wall - you can't really do that well with wood framing.
I think some forms are better than others when it comes to straight walls and ease of pouring/lack of blowouts. I have personally never been to a PolySteel pour that didn't blow out. I've never seen a blowout at a Nudura or Quad-Lock pour.
I missed a couple of 8" penetrations, but was able to get them core drilled for $50 per hole, so forgetting penetrations means a big drill, but you can recover.
Most of the stuff I learned to keep walls straight and prevent blowouts, I learned at the Nudura two-day class taught at my local dealer. Without this class, and the almost-daily support of my dealer, it would have been tough.
You definitely don't use ICF for cost, but the same goes for SIPs. My energy bills are virtually nil for a 6,000 sf house ($40/month), and when the wind picks up coming off the foothills, I don't hear it until it crests 50 mph. It is amazing. I'd use ICF again in a second. My only regret was that we had a complex bump-up area, that using ICF would have been more expensive and taken more time because of the large open spans. I framed it, and regret it.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 6/16/2005
As mentioned above, my rep, and all the installers, really try to
avoid 4" forms, no matter the brand. Getting good consolidation,
especially at lintels and other steel-rich areas, is tough. Every
installer I considered hiring would "push" for 6" walls, for a
reason. Placing concrete in 4" can be tough - some guys use
additives to help it "flow", but some of these additives cause problems
because they rely on certain "charges" (ions and whatnot) which can
negativly impact consolidation in ICF foam walls (where the foam tends
to already have a charge on it.). I believe the arit folks have
done some pretty significant research on it.
One possible savings might be doing 6" walls all
the way up. I, like Ken, used 8" basement and 6" main level, but
around here it is common to do 6" the whole way, which makes the
"joint" between the two levels easier, and saves concrete on the
basement level. You're engineer will need to decide if that is
appropiate and what steel will be required. You can use the
manufacturers tables to see if it is reasonable for your design, then
hire the engineer if needed. Also, you'd only save 1/3 the concrete using a 4" cavity, not 1/2.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/14/2005
Ditto on my bank. I write the checks, the VP approves them.
We talk construction. He offers guidance and passes on the trim
carpenter he used or a good supplier.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/15/2006
I think most engineered floors can't be finished at all, maybe once with the 1/8th.
An exception; I installed a bunch of hickory Owens Plankfloor, which
has a full thickness wear surface over an engineered substrate,
so you can refinish it the same number of times as a traditional 3/4"
T&G floor. We have been very happy with the product installed
over radiant heat.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/14/2006
This was a gray area, but I think you are justified in holding to the
contract price. My excavation contracts (provided by my
excavator) specifically said that there would be extra cost incurred
for unforeseen conditions and rock, debris, etc., but that approval would
be required to proceed when these conditions were encountered.
On my driveway, my excavator went ahead and blasted a couple of
boulders and kept his price as is (and I got a 20' wide road in most
places that I paid for 12').
On my basement, we hit rock very early, and I ended up paying time and
materials as needed to get the job done, initial bid out the window
(lots of rock, 96 holes of blasting).
Hope this helps. Sounds like your excavator is new?
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/20/2004
Liability and Builders Risk -
I would recommend getting a homeowners policy with a builders risk rider, and then look at an extra umbrella to give you a little bit of extra coverage if something happens where liability would be in question.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/4/2004
Yikes. It must be a regional thing.
I think most areas (CA excluded) you can buy a homeowners policy with a
"builders risk" rider on it that will cover you (but not for workmen's
comp if you are hiring people directly). Add an umbrella for $1 million
(usually only a hundred bucks a year) and you are reasonably well
covered. (Of course, depending on your assets).
I know a guy out here who went this route, with a two million dollar
umbrella, and he spent ~ $900/year for the house/builders risk policy
and about $200 for the extra liability.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/23/2005
Can you frame boxes covered with one or 2 layers of 5/8" fire rated sheet rock? Then the "path" through a can would have to pass through an equivilent? barrier?
How far along are you? Not granting a waiver sounds petty, esp. if they are changing the rules.
What might you be able to do to make the piers not considered a level..?
Good luck, sounds like a toughie.
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/2/2005
I have the Sonos system - It's great, but I run it over hardwired Ethernet. The latency is better, and you have less interference
with other Wi-Fi routers and all the other things that make wireless
networks not work as well - some microwaves, some wireless phones,
etc.
Pricey, but definitely the caddy of the group, IMHO. You still need
to plan and pre-wire if you want all the speakers hidden in the walls.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/2/2003
It is priced below market for a reason - Get a soils truck in there
where you want to put the house to see what the soil is like. If you
find rock, you'll probably be paying for blasting. Out here (CO) that
typically adds $15K to a house. Definitely get some experts in there,
it will cost more. Also, if you have to import soil to build up a level
spot., that will cost, and your foundation will probably need to be
engineered, which might add some more.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/10/2005
Get real bids for your area, anything else will leave you disappointed.
My house is ICF exterior, and the basement had already been capped.
Framing bids ranged from $4sf to $10sf huge variety. All are expensive considering the exterior walls were done and the main level TJI's sub-floor was already installed.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/10/2006
Search these forums for more details on pricing and general ICF
experience. There are quite a few ICF owner-builders here, with
the range from doing the ICF themselves to hiring it all out. Costs will vary widely depending on local costs for labor, concrete,
and proximity to the ICF plant for whichever block you choose. Like Ken, I've found the energy efficiency to be remarkable. We
used some passive solar design with radiant heat (to add geothermal or
active solar in the future) with an ICF envelope, and the results are
amazing.
That said, we had to evacuate two nights ago from our new home, during a
sudden and volatile nearby wildfire. We already had most of our
important stuff in the basement safe room (which was minimal additional
cost due to the concrete walls everywhere) and so we just had to load
up our animals and a few things and roll.
Something I had considered, but didn't do (at least yet) is
building/installing fire shutters. We have located our house on
the topography as best we could to avoid draws and chimneys that would
focus hot gases, and if you have soffits/fascia I'd recommend a cement
board type product (we don't have any)... Perhaps those of us in
the dry west could get some info on the hurricane shutters should we
want to add something like that?
Here's a picture from Sunday night...
 | | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/10/2006
I meant to add, we didn't worry much leaving our house, and the
firefighters came to check things out should the fire have progressed
our way. Once they found out the ICF construction, A) all of them
wanted to defend our house B) They were very happy. Besides
construction, don't forget defensible space, etc.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/2/2005
Do you have the magazine and reviews? I'd be very
interested! My parents have a Sub-Zero that they have moved from
house to house - $300 in repairs over 14 years, due to some sticky
material damaging the seal when opened. Other than that it's
been a trouper. It's hard to find good objective reviews of these
items. Thanks! John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/5/2006
Check with local distributors of ICF products in your area, most
have a class every few months. Here, the Nudura dealership offers
a 2 day class every couple of months.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/26/2005
Watch that you won't need new engineering in your jurisdiction - 8'
can be a 'trigger point' at which going higher would require additional
engineering work... But you can do the research up front and know
in advance... For example, in my jurisdiction, any ICF wall
over 8' high requires an engineer to do the inspection; The building
department won't inspect it. This added $150 to the cost of the
basement, but the height is great. As mentioned above, the
materials and labor cost is pretty minimal. We did 10'6" high
basement walls, which puts the bottom of the steel beams & AC
ducting at 8'6" - It doesn't feel like a basement. Good luck, m
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/28/2005
Be sure to map the ducting versus your structural drawings - If you
have stacked beams, you will have to located the ducts to avoid them. Also,
talk with your HVAC guy - Not only is right down the center typically
cheaper, but it also usually comes pretty close to the shortest set of
ducts. If the ducts get too long, costs will go up as you buy
bigger equipment. Finally, if you have steel beams, they will
typically lower your ceiling around 12", so running the ducts next to
them is typically not a big deal. Good luck, J
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/16/2005
Jim makes a good point - make sure you know who owns the plans. I paid a designer to get my plans into a buildable state, but still had to hire an engineer to get the structurals, and train my CAD person on my building techniques.
I made darn sure I owned the plans, rights, and everything else we did. I had spent 200 hours doing solar design, HVAC loads, mechanical routing, and supplied my "designer" with .dxf files before we even met. Just be clear who owns what when you work with a designer, or better yet, as Jim points out, get a CAD package and do your own. I've been an AutoCAD guy for a long time, but wasn't familiar with construction when I started; I wish I had done my own drawings, because most designers I've worked with are slow and missed deadlines.
Depending on the designer, it might cost more to "own" your plans; some will care, some won't.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/16/2004
Rough cut on driveway in Colorado: ~ $1 per square foot, so a 12' driveway 1000' long is 12k. This is for a rough cut, clearing, grading, but no top material.
Shop your excavators, especially those that are used to working in your area. They will all have clauses to get them out of their price when they hit unexpected underground problems (rock, shale, etc) but some are better than others.
I had two good excavators bid on my project, one indicating that rocks would be removed at additional cost, the other indicating that his price was to get the job done. I went with the second, (who had a better price anyway) and he even ended up blasting to get the road in. No extra charge. I was surprised!
The difference was that the second one was used to the area, knew the geology, and did his own blasting, instead of hiring it out.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/21/2005
While factory made trusses can have their own challenges (measurements,
design errors, etc) your framers WILL charge you more to stick build
your roof trusses. A LOT more.
In a factory, with jigs, it is easy to get a consistent product that
will meet the loadings that the truss engineer (paid for as part of the
truss package) designed.
You can't get that consistency from a field built truss, and it takes a
lot more labor, in the dirt and weeds of the job site, as opposed to
the machines and jigs of a dedicated factory floor.
The other issue is the engineering - With factory made trusses, you'll
get a stamped engineering packet of truss drawings that the building
inspector will use to verify proper installation and that the trusses
were not compromised (webs cut, etc). With a field built, you
will first have to have an engineer (perhaps a structural engineer or a
truss designer on the side) draw the trusses, the framer will have to
frame them, and then someone will have to verify them. Chances
are, the building inspector will not want to, so you'll be paying the
truss engineer for a field inspection.
Now, all of my above rambling assumes that you are doing a typical
construction roof. If you are using TJI's, or some other engineered method,
as rafters, with a central set of support beams, and then in-framing the
ceiling joists, then framing labor would probably be about the same.
I could have done my roof (low pitch flat roof) either way, and
sometimes wish I had used TJI's for the roof rafters instead of factory
trusses. I was a little dismayed that my factory trusses looked
so wimpy, but they have proven to build a strong roof, and have an
engineering stamp. Now that they are installed they are solid as
can be.
Hope this helps. It took my framers a day to set all the trusses
on my house, but if they had to frame them, I think it would have been
5-6, plus a lot of wasted material.
J
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/25/2005
It's hard to quantify 'a lot', because it will vary on the design...
If I had my flat roof stick-framed, I'd suppose the cost would be
within 10%, because the trusses were similar... But a flat roof
is easy.
On a complex slope, where angles are involved, then the cost goes up
because it takes more time to get everything laid out right.
However, you CAN combine truss and stick framing if needed - The
structural portion of the roof can be truss, and any architectural
features stick-framed.
If you have a really good truss company, they can do almost
anything. They have software to visualize the roof, and you can
fly around the model and look at each hip, gable, and intersection.
Even so, I saw a project where they had a truss package, and still
ended up doing a lot of stick framing, partially because the truss
company screwed up. (Probably $25K of trusses, and another $20K of
stick framing, for the roof, but it's 9,000 sf with a very complex roof).
Either way, the more complex the roofline, the higher the cost.
By the same token, if you can get a framer who needs the work (not
always a good thing!) you might get a better break. Also, as
another poster pointed out, attic storage is a no-no with regular
trusses, you need bottom chord bearing trusses to store stuff up
there. Around here, any roof with any decent pitch comes with
these trusses, they are pretty much standard, as everyone likes to add
a bonus room.
To get a feel for it, imagine the amount of work it takes for each of the two options:
1) Framer brings in a boom truck (expensive) and
hoists trusses onto the roof, where other framers nail and brace
them. You can install trusses almost as fast as the boom truck
can lower them into place. After the big ones are installed, the
little ones are carried up by hand and nailed into place (hips, etc).
2) Framer booms up a bunch of lumber, or worse,
carries sticks up, and starts measuring, sawing, nailing, etc.
Most of the time, the truss option wins out for price. With a
good designer, especially with complex roofs. But it also depends
on the cost of labor in your area... Here general labor makes a
pretty good penny because everything is so expensive.
Best bet - Go to the truss place with your plans, and get bids if you
can. Even if you are not quite ready, the truss designers will
give you a good feeling on what part might be truss, and what the cost
would be, versus having a framer do part of it. It also lets you
feel out the truss folks to see which ones you like working with.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/21/2005
You can do this - Setup a company, and pay yourself from that
company. The company invoices your bank for the work done.
I've seen this done frequently, but you have to do everything by the
book - comp, liability insurance, etc.
I didn't want to bother with that - I just decided before we started
building that we would save some money on the side for us to live on
for a while, and then our mortgage would come in that much lower, and
we'd come under budget on a lot of things. It's worked out pretty
well, except that some things (blasting basement, etc) were
dramatically over budget, so we are pretty much on our original budget.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/16/2005
Do
a search through these Forums -- one poster had some very good
information about potential problems with PEX and chlorine in an open
system. (Typical radiant heat systems are closed, so there is
no
fresh supply of chlorine). I had really looked into
using PEX, but none of the plumbers I liked to work with use it for
anything other than radiant heat. One plumber's (probably
jaded)
opinion was "that's for cheap spec houses."
Now, I think a big part of his resistance is adding another
set of fittings and tools to his
truck... As you'll find out, the
building industry is very stubborn. Good luck either
way,John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/16/2005
I'm sure it is. Time is always money. I
ended up picking my plumber based on his bid and referrals, and the
fact that he only ran copper was just an artifact of that. He
ended up being my best sub. He works nights, weekends, holidays,
and still can't get all of his work done, because he's popular.
But I can get three other plumbers who have all kinds of time during
the
same period. His bid for copper was cheaper than #2's bid for
PEX. Given same/better price, why take the chance? Given a
cost advantage to PEX, then there is good value in considering the new
system. Unless new systems can offer added functionality for the
additional cost (some PEX systems do with the home run manifolds,
pressure, etc.) then they won't catch on.
There is a parallel in the gas-piping world for
plumbers. My plumber had resisted using the new flexible gas line
"Gastite" system, instead opting to do everything in black pipe, the
way it has been done for a million years "cause that's the way it should
be" or whatever.Eventually, the suppliers convinced him to
try it. Less work, saves time, more money? Yep. He's
sold now on the Gastite stuff. Perhaps PEX is the same thing, in
it's infancy. The articles on chlorine and PEX were
interesting, but didn't really prove anything either way. They
look to me to be spreading FUD (Fear, Uncertainty, Doubt) as a bad
marketing ploy, but could it be the next PB? Possibly. I
personally doubt it.Copper will usually cost more in your
bid. Copper will take longer. Copper has a track
record. But if we never tried anything new, we'd still be living
in sod houses. :) Having installed 10K feet of PEX
in my house, I wouldn't hesitate to use PEX for my supply lines.
But I have copper actually installed in my house...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/17/2005
I didn't mean to be snobbish -- there are some valid concerns others
have been raised, and I passed on the current thoughts of the plumbers I had
had through bidding -- that is their thought right now, but we know the
building industry has its "quirks." No offense intended.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/31/2007
I'll throw my two cents in here and try not to hijack the thread. I'm big on solar PV, but despite my gung-ho feelings, I can't make an economic pitch for it yet; the equipment is just too expensive. Solar panel prices have skyrocketed over the past 18 months and there is currently no impending drop; the plants are at capacity. Someone is going to have to make a significant outlay of capital to bring the price down... it will happen, but not nearly as soon as I'd like.
I'd be wary of CitizenRe and the other similar programs that have popped up. You can't get something for nothing - lemme add some numbers. (I know you are paying for power, but even at 10 cents/kWh, it's a long time to ROI).
I know a PV dealer; he buys at cost. After ungodly generous rebates, doing the install himself, he'll pay on the order of $4+ per watt of installed power. He is putting 12kW in, a very big system. The retail installed rate is going over $8 per watt installed in this area.
If your house uses 500 kW/month, in Colorado, you'd probably need a minimum of 4 kW (probably more) to come close to breaking-even on power usage, probably a little more. That's a minimum of $16K, more like $32K, to try to cover your house bill. At $.10/kWh, (I think we pay 6-7 cents here), $32K buys a lot of electricity. This is way oversimplified (discounting the important fact that energy WILL get more expensive), but nevertheless...
There are a ton of solar installations going in right now, but every single one of them is going onto a $500K+ house that the owner has extra money, their house is paid for, and they want to have power when the grid is down or want to do it for green purposes... In every case, they have not rationalized it for economic purposes, because it's pretty hard to do.
I paid $8K for power to my site, rolling that back into my overall construction costs, solar still would have not been the economic choice... I'm planning on adding it this fall, but only because I want to, not because I can make a financial case for it.
Now, to the OP: 1) Figure out the location and angle for the panels. Make sure your trusses are designed for the load if they are on the roof. If you are locating them remotely, or on the roof, run conduits back to your main panel, or wherever you will install the inverters. The inverters will typically be 5' wide, 2-3' high, and 12-18" deep. Rough rule of thumb, you will need 1 per 6kW, but there are all kinds...
2) You will need big conduits, (3-4" electrical-rated PVC, 3-4 of them for a typical system). Solar will run DC back to your inverters, so the cables will be large to reduce power loss.
3) Check with your utility company now, they may require an extra disconnect or bypass on the outside of the building for grid-tied PV.
4) If you have an idea of local companies that might install, get a bid and walkthrough now - they will be more familiar with the codes in your areas. Some areas may not allow the cabling to run through the house, though it's not a problem here.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/11/2005
You will need to talk to PG&E, and have their engineer give you a cost estimate. In
my area, I had to bring in power 600 feet, plus pay for a
transformer. Cost to go underground was double the cost of using
poles. They would also not allow me to do or
subcontract any portion of the work. For example, the vendor that
supplies the special wire they use in their underground feeders offered
to sell me the wire at a discount (the owner of the wire vending
company was the seller of my lot) but the REA said no way. Ultimately, they typically "own" the feed lines up to the transformer, so they want it done by their crews to their standards. Since you are in CA, have you considered using the rebates and doing solar off grid?
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/9/2005
In our area, they are pretty sticky on dryer venting. I believe the code is IRC2003, and they allow: No more than 15' of duct, and 2 90 degree elbows. This makes venting from an interior room very difficult. Also, no venting into a garage. Nameplate
venting guidelines on modern dryers seem to allow 45+ feet, so you
might try lobbying on that. Our inspector said no. Good luck, john
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/30/2004
While not at all directly related to the above postings, this reminded me of an issue that one of my other owner-builder buddies came across last week. (He and I pretty much learned ICF's together, and we trade notes weekly).
He had access to a bunch of concrete tile roofing - someone was selling it, cheap. It had been removed from a two-year-old roof because the house had not been designed for the heavy concrete tile. Given the lifetime of the roofing material, it was worth consideration.
My friend was tempted at first, as the roofing was probably less than half what he would have paid his roofer for. But then he did the math.
1) Renting equipment (and time) to get the roofing loaded onto two semi's (or make two trips).
2) (Rent the semi(s)
3) Rent the equipment (forklift, and boom truck or conveyer)
4) to get the roofing loaded onto the roof.
After he did the math, despite some significant savings, it didn't make sense, because he'd blow the savings on getting the roofing to his roof. Add to that, if anything ever went wrong with his roof, his roofer would no doubt blame the roofing material he didn't supply.
Just a thought.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/31/2007
I'm kinda back here part time, I'll work on a detailed writeup in the next few weeks. I'm using a program called 'misterhouse' and some perl stuff I wrote for it, but it's really on the hardcore geek side. You can get expensive pre-packaged versions of sensors and software here:
ibuttonlink.com
I don't work for them, i use some of their goodies on my project, and you can buy virtually all of the basic stuff elsewhere cheaper.
I actually had some interest in commercial versions of this, and had gotten things to the point of a small internet router sized box that produced daily and yearly spreadsheets and graphs and an in-house web-page for up to 1000 sensors, but never quite had more than one contractor (4-5 projects interested) so I've not pushed it. I thought I could bundle it with a dozen sensors... Anyway, I'm not really selling anything, but will do a writeup on what I did, where I got the hardware and software, and how it's been working.
I've updated it to monitor the bathroom hot water pipes, and turn on the vent fans when my daughter forgets. :)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/22/2005
A 4 1/2" angle grinder with a diamond blade from evil orange (Home
Depot) will do a great job on any stucco (3 coat, FRS one coat, EIFS,
etc). The only drawback is that you are cutting with a rounded blade
which is no problem for 4" or 6" holes, but can be tougher for small
penetrations. No cracks tho - it leaves a nice stress-free cut if you
smooth all the sharp stucco edges.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/11/2005
Look close at them, in person, and get bids before you buy. I
was planning mini-duct, but I could get conventional ductwork and an AC
unit installed by a local guy for significantly less that just the
blower & ducts (materials only) for the mini-duct
systems. AC Direct now sells mini-duct, which might be good for a
bid.
The thing to keep in mind also is that you still need to duct air
returns, and you still have to run a supply duct; the supply duct
is smaller and much easier to work with than the conventional large
rectangular ones, but it's not quite like low-voltage cable or PEX...
The other thing I had heard mentioned was that they tend to be noisier
than conventional HVAC. I saw one in person (at a home show) and
it didn't seem bad, but everyone has different thresholds.
Another thing - you can use these for heat via either an electric strip
or water coil (fired from a boiler). I went through a lot of
research and numbers, and the mini-duct systems will not work well with
geothermal-supplied water for heating. The water from a
geothermal unit isn't hot enough to heat the air sufficiently when it
is moving at the higher velocity. Conventional air handlers have
more surface area and lower air velocities.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/11/2005
I realized that in referencing the supply ducts above, I was ambiguous -
There is a main supply duct, around 8-10" round, that you have to run
through the basement/attic. To this, you connect the actual mini flex duct, which can typically go up to around 25 feet. The mini
flex duct looks super easy; you'll need a hole saw to cut the mini-duct
connection holes to the main trunk-supply line.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/20/2004
One thing that everyone needs to keep in mind is the local geography. The poster's realtor is right for most places here in Colorado. Most smallish (under 3 acres) buildable lots do go for asking price, even after hanging out on the market for a while.
Still, make the lower offer, because if you catch the right seller at the right time, you can save some. Just don't be to bummed out when they do get full price. In organized neighborhoods where you are buying a lot from the developer, expect to pay full price in most cases, if it's a neighborhood where you can build it, and not hire "their" general.
North of denver, the first acre (and right to build) is costing 100k, with the second acre going down to 60k, and the third+ acres coming in at about 5-8k per acre. Limited supplies of water, and a very strong anti-development lobby is making building lots, and new construction, difficult in many areas. Water taps are in the neighborhood of 25-30k unless you are in a city or town.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/6/2006
You might be able to support the upper overhung section on cantilevered
TJI's that frame the floor for the second floor. In my area, an
engineered set of drawings would be required to build this.
TrusJoist has their TJI specifiers manual in .pdf format online, which
tells what cantilevers are allowable. A couple of feet is usually
doable easily.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/1/2004
Adding a second floor is almost always more economical than having everything on one floor.
Costs include:
Extra Foundation
Extra drain/dampproofing
Extra lot space
Extra truss/roofing
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/27/2006
My house is like that - I've applied the spray foam to the UNDERSIDE of
the sheathing, creating a conditioned attic with NO roof venting. It is part of the 2004 IRC code. It works. This saved
27 or so pop vents, and the inevitable leaks/flashing that would be
around each one. Plus, can lighting, etc. need not have airtight
baffles built around them to keep air infiltration down.
Do lots of research - this is the new high-performance envelope (it's
very common among the building science folks)... SIP roofs are
exactly the same, sealed, unvented. It can have some significant
HVAC and maintenance advantages over traditional methods. I did
this to my house, and there are three others in the area using a similar
method, even on roofs with steep pitches.
Different spray foams will have different requirements. Some
closed-cell polys will require a thermal ignition barrier over them,
others like biobased and Icynene will not, as their flame/smoke spread
index is pretty low.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/24/2008
The only way to know is to get multiple bids -- same as every part of a project. That said, given the work you have, it doesn't seem unreasonable to me.
Some excavators work on a flat bid, but they will always have a clause in there for rock and "unforeseen subsurface conditions" e.g. if they hit bedrock 2' under, you are not getting your foundation done for $10K. I worked with my excavator, who became a great friend, doing time and materials... Figure any single large piece of equipment will probably cost about $120 per hour, including an operator... Although I'm sure prices have climbed as diesel has risen.
I had a lot of rock, but think my excavation bill topped $80K. (That included a rough grade on 1,000' of road and a water line, though). If you are thinking you can do a 7,000' foundation yourself with a backhoe, you are obviously in the early stages of owner-building... ;) I have a backhoe, and wouldn't even consider it.
The digging is really an acquired skill, and if you over dig, you will spend many thousands or 10's of thousands bringing the grade back up with some type of fill and engineering tests of the compacted soil before you can put the foundation in on it... More delay.
It took my excavator about a week with a trackhoe, and articulated loader, and two dump trucks to do my basement, in heavy rocks. My parents had their basement in two days, but it was only a crawlspace, and much less digging.
Get multiple bids, and resist the urge to do it yourself. I've not posted on here much (too busy!) but find my old posts. I did too much myself, and at some point you learn how to pick high value things to do... Excavation is not one of them.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/2/2005
Really Really bad idea. You will get lots of settling, sinkholes, mold, bugs...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/30/2005
Asking on the internet won't help much, since it is 100% dependent on the locality issuing the permit and how prepared you are for meeting the requirements of your locality.
The county to the south of me requires environmental impact statements, site plan reviews, etc. by the county commissioners before they will even start down the permit process. My county puts out a book with all the drawings and paperwork they want.
My county indicated that they needed 1-4 weeks to issue a permit. This depends on the time of year and permit load.
Be sure you have all ancilliary paperwork like percolation test results, well or water tap paperwork, etc.
My county issued a footing/foundation permit in 2 days, and then the full permit in 3 weeks. That let me get going with my excavation and footings early without waiting much on the county. It cost me $100 extra overall in the project to get the F&F issued.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/26/2005
Everyone will think I'm some kind of sales guy (just an excited new ICF
home owner!) but one thing I wish I would have done that I didn't, was
change some of my 45 degree walls to radius walls - I only mention this
because you could make a really sweet radius house/wall with ICF.
Now ICF can be cut and formed to get radius curves, but you can get
some ICF (Nudura does this) factory made to any radius you want. Your
Nudura dealer will work with the factory and deliver ICF's that are
pre-formed to your radius walls. I'm going to try these with my next
project, my barn, for kicks. You could make a killer efficient,
fireproof, hurricane proof, house using the round design idea with ICF!
These round homes sound so cool - Too bad I've not yet finished my
current house, and I already want to change stuff!
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/26/2005
I think a lot depends on your market and your specific building location, as well as the price range that you are building for.
If
you have a beautiful lakefront lot in a nice neighborhood, you will
get a much better return on your land investment with a home that has
the higher level finishes than you would with a typical "spec built"
home... This is all really specific to your area, but (at least
out here) land is the number one cost component in a house, and to
build the wrong house for the lot/neighborhood would be the first way
to sabotage yourself. Don't rule out certain finishes until you
have shopped them. I have a granite guy who does some of his
cheaper granites for $25 per square foot, as compared to some of the
laminates that are not that much cheaper. If the
house/neighborhood supports a nicer finish, you might make gains
there. But if the finish is "too nice" for the house, you won't
get much out of it because the future buyer probably won't have the
budget to demand granite, and thus the countertops would only be a nice
addition.
It might make sense to join one of the high pressure buying
clubs - You might buy enough material to make it worth it, - My
friend has done well with laminate flooring from Direct Buy. Another
thing - Perhaps ideal, would be to buy more than one lot, and perhaps
water/sewer taps, up front. The land/taps will appreciate while
you build/live/move.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/26/2005
I wouldn't buy Direct Buy stuff, and a friend who has used them has
found that they could really deliver very little of what they offered
in their catalogs. Back to Spec building - Obviously,
they can cut corners in hidden stuff (frame, insulation, etc.) but I
think that changes the definition of "nicer home", depending on how
savvy the buyer is. Minimum Insulation Quality of bath fans (louder ones, cheap vent terminals). Steel or Masonite garage doors, uninsulated. MDF etc. trim and doors Carpet/budget pad. Formica Cheaper windows. Vinyl windows save a lot because you don't have the intensive labor in interior/exterior finish. "Minimal"
jetted tub. The jetted tubs vary in quality and features a lot
nowadays. You could get by with the cheapie 3-jet type tub and
still have "a jetted tub" in the bath. Fixtures - You can buy
much cheaper than HD/Lowe's - Take a look on eBay, there are some
no-name brands from who knows where that look pretty nice, but you will
never find parts for. Concrete flatwork - Go with lower strength, less/zero steel. Could backfire if cracking starts within two years though. Dampproofing instead of waterproofing if code allows. Roofing - Lower warranty shingles, 15-lb felt. Backfill
- Saw a spec builder down the street backfill with rocks that were left
from excavation. Pretty nasty, and not good, but cheap.
1/2" sheetrock on ceilings. PEX is to the point where it's used pretty commonly in spec houses around here, but not the custom homes. Builder grade AC/heat...
Yeesh. Glad I built my own house. :)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/22/2005
I use about 800 gallons per year for heating, hot water, and cooking. Very energy efficient construction, Colorado location.
I certainly wouldn't pick electric over gas for heating.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/22/2005
Here in Colorado, the price of electric just jumped dramatically
because of a state law mandating that utilities buy 'green' (solar,
wind) power, up to a significant percentage. So counting on electric
costs to be more stable might not be the best idea. Overnight they went
up here, no natural disasters. Of course, gas is more volatile, but
most electricity is produced by gas and coal (hydro, wind, solar
account for a small percentage) so rates will climb.
Going electric, and they feeding it with your own PV array is the way
to go. I am about to install solar hot water to my radiant heat, and
then add the grid intertie PV electric array next fall. Then I'll fill
the 500 gallon propane tank to run the gas cooktop and the boiler as a
backup should the solar hot water have an extended grey period (I can
tolerate about four days with no sun before the boiler needs to turn on).
If you want the best stability, go ground source heat pump. A small
portion comes from your electric, but most from the ground. It will
cost; expect installed costs to be 3-4X a conventional HVAC system.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/18/2005
I think owner-builder is still the right term... I did a lot of
work (see my other posts) myself, and it has tradeoffs. I was
owner/designer/gc/surveyor/foundation guy/hardwood guy/low voltage
wiring guy/tile guy/radiant heat guy/cellar guy/ deck
guy/painter/garage door installer and a few other things. I hired
excavation/blasting, framing, stucco, flatwork, drywall, plumbing,
electrical, vent. Doing a lot yourself is a BAD idea if you are
borrowing funds, unless you are hiring some people to work alongside
you. It will burn you out, and you will very likely spend more in
interest than you would had you hired the work out. If you have a
hoard of cash and can take time off from a real job, I can't imagine
anything more rewarding.
Nevertheless, I really enjoyed doing a lot of the work myself.
There is another thread (titled 'Are there any REAL owner-builders out
there') on this site that has a bunch of good insight on the advantages
and pitfalls of doing it all yourself.
As far as nomenclature, I think it's about as good as it can get.
Kinda like 'DIY' can mean anything from you installed some shelving you
bought at home depot to you stacked and poured your entire ICF envelope.
Most of the hard-core owner/real builders I know (2) don't even mess
with the Internet. They know what they want, how they are going
to do it, and pretty much ignore the rest of the world. They are
also building way off the beaten path, which is probably a good reason
to DIY most stuff, since labor costs skyrocket as you get away from
populated areas.
Hope this helps a little, at least with the pointer to the other
thread. Even real 'Builders' don't build, they hire it all out
too. The folks who really can do it all are pretty rare, by
either lack of skill, or the outright specialized nature of the tools
and experience needed to work with a lot of today's building materials
(not that they are all that exotic, but stucco, LV wiring, roofing,
insulation, HVAC, even electrical and plumbing to a lesser degree have
all evolved a lot.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/18/2005
You want the gardenweb forums... There is a lot of chaff to sift
through (there is a lot of unrelated landscape stuff to sift through),
but some of the folks there do a lot of DIY stuff, so you can talk
details. Like I said, I think most people who do this don't have time
to fool around on the internet, so it becomes a smaller and smaller
pool of people to interface with.
There is also a great group on tractorpoint.com, where we talk a
lot of details, but you'll have to pay $20/year to get at those forums,
and it's not just construction, but it's a big portion of the site
(~20-30%)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/25/2005
I think "value engineering" isn't the right term. You are
interested in maximizing the return on your investment - value
engineering generally refers to designing to reduce costs. However, as Ken pointed out, all your hard work locating bathrooms,
sizing for standard lumber sizes, etc. just saves your subs money and
time, but doesn't generally reduce your bid prices. Your subs
don't have the time to calculate exactly what it costs them to plumb a
house or frame a floor, they do many bids each week. So they use
close numbers, and plan on winning some and losing some and hopefully
making some money. If you are planning on selling, don't
bother doing it right. Slap junk together, make it look good,
and get out. Doing it right will drive up the costs a lot. The
appraiser doesn't care if you have anti-fracture membranes under the
tile, or if you use PEX versus copper, or that there is 15-lb felt on
the roof. Buy cheapest where it won't be seen, and put the glitz
where it will. Most of your subs are used to building this way,
so they won't have any problem. (It's when you want it done right that
it takes longer and confuses them). The problem with value
engineering is that you need to know what value is and where it's
relevant to the project. Value engineering a special roof system
means nothing when you are turning a property, but might mean a huge
cost savings if you are staying in a house and get a hailstorm every
spring. I think the correct term is spec building,
but the best you will do as an O-B is shop hard for the stuff that can
be seen, and scrimp everywhere you can on the stuff that won't be
seen. Also, if you are spec building, (to live in
and then sell) you really need to have your schedule together. A
month delay will start eating into a significant percentage of your
return, because you will be amortizing that cost over only a two-year
period.
Good luck!
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/23/2004
For those of you using steel in your O-B projects, if you are not
underway, go get all your steel re-bid. Rebar for the concrete, steel
for supporting I-joists, or (gasp) steel buildings. Most steel is at
least 3X the price it was last year. Most steel quotes are only being
honored for a week or so, depending on the item.
Most of the scrap steel in the US that is used to make new steel is
being sent to China and India, where they are in the midst of a
building boom, hence higher market prices.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/26/2004
As usual, Ken and I have similar stories! I had all #5 grade 60 rebar in my walls, and by the time I had bought rebar, it had doubled from when I budgeted. By the time I started building my walls, it had gone up another 50%. I bought my steel and let it sit there for a few months - My location is very private, so I wasn't worried about theft. Moral of the story - Be sure you keep in touch with your suppliers, and have a contingency in the budget to cover these kinds of things, because NO amount of planning will get you out of the surprise increases. On a side note, the HVAC bids I'm getting now are all 30% lower than the bids I got during planning. I hate to say it, but most all of the planning/bid work you do is to make sure your budget is good and you find people you want to work with. Re-bid everything if there is a big gap time-wise between your planning bids and actual construction. Part of the bid delta (at least with my AC / ducting) is that now a sub can walk the site, see the runs, and give me a price to install into a known entity. When bidding plans, sometimes some details/ease of installation isn't clear, and you end up with bids that are higher to keep the sub in the black on a difficult install.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/21/2005
Kevin, what you are needing is really a taller foundation wall
on the back - this is done all the time for walkout basements, and is
usually called a frost wall there. It will probably be simplest
to continue the ICF there - it can be done as one pour. If you
have engineering, have your engineer double check your steel schedule
for that wall, otherwise follow your ICF manufacturers recommendations. You
don't have to insulate it - It will be below grade. However, for
best performance, you'd want to, and if you do the ICF, it will be done
already.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/18/2005
I used Sierra Pacific, and highly recommend them. We got one
of the upcharge semi-custom colors, and great windows, and they ate Andersen/Pella/Marvin's windows for lunch. Look
close - the
normal lines from Andersen/Pella/etc. don't compare in quality to the
Sierra Pacific windows. You have to buy the higher-end
Andersen/Pella/etc. windows to match the Sierra Pacific windows. SP's prices were much better. I think SP does it by cutting out
all the window dealers, and dealing direct. The service has been
great, and my window salesperson did a great job helping me make sure
that everything would meet my requirements and code. After
installation, at trim, they sent out a crew to install
screens/handles/locks. Those guys were kinda idiots, but all in
all, I'm very happy with SP. All of our window interiors were
clear pine, but the SP French doors have Douglas Fir, which takes the
stain a little differently, so that is one thing to keep in mind (you
can get all Doug Fir, or have your painter match). The windows
are very well built and have been holding up to 100+ mile per hour
winds without letting _anything_ through.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/19/2005
BTW, my windows were the aluminum-clad wood.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/19/2005
I did casement and awning units, with three double-door French door units, and five single French-door units. All are fantastic, really solid. And no noise in high winds (ICF house).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/31/2005
Diamond blade in a wet saw and nippers work fine. Some cuts
will require more care than ceramic tile; it's softer. The
natural shapes to it make it tougher to lay, and you will have some
variety in the heights. One installer I talked to makes people
sign a waiver that it will be uneven, since it's hard to control
exactly.
But we love ours!
Install it, then seal it with three coats of sealer BEFORE grouting.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/1/2005
Actually, we only used it for a bathroom floor. A friend used it for floor, walls, and tub surround.
One thing we noticed is that it is really porous... It soaked up the sealer, coat after coat after coat.
So far we've not had any problems cleaning it, but the bathroom is
seldom used, and we've only been in 6 months... We'll let you know
how it works, but it looks awesome.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/10/2005
I used V-Buck for most of my windows, but things like garage doors, etc. were PT lumber. The
new PT will eat regular fasteners, even galvanized. Now you have
to buy "double galvanized" (Simpson calls theirs Z-Max) or other
fasteners that are compatible with the new chemicals. Expect
lots of coatings, and a higher price.
The best bet, spec'ed by my engineer if I used PT bucks, was stainless steel. Not the cheapest though.
I bought a load of 2" & 3" #8 and #9 stainless steel screws
on eBay. I used them anytime I had to hit PT lumber, and more
often than I should have elsewhere, since they were so handy, and
relatively cheap off of fleabay.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 6/30/2005
I used a lightweight concrete product, with double top and bottom plates. You must have your structurals designed for this added weight by your engineer, and your structural steel and TJI's/framing/subfloor will cost more. Some installers used large (1/2 or 5/8) redheads with washers and nuts on both sides of the wall attachment point.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 7/5/2005
The 1/2" or 5/8" redheads were handy and on-site - but definitely overkill for attaching partition walls to to ICF. The limiting factor seems to be how long of an anchor you can get, since you need to go through 2 5/8" of foam, 1.5" of 2x, plus get embedment in the concrete and have some thread to attach the nuts to.
In my application, with the lightweight concrete, I used in-floor hydronics. The concrete definitely made everything solid...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/11/2005
Ditto on Peter. Everything he has said is _exactly_ what you need to do. (I was on rock, so these issues didn't pop up) but don't listen to the developer when it comes to this, and do all this research BEFORE you buy the lot. Also, make any lot contract contingent upon accetable soils test results. If soils tests (paid for by you, not the developer) come back indicating an exotic foundation, but you really like the lot, you can use this as power to negotiate your lot price down.
Good luck,
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/2/2006
You'll need to bid /research your exact types of beams/wood, but I
suspect it will be significantly more expensive. To do a ceiling
using 8-10" natural logs on 32" centers, with T&G planking over it,
cost about triple for me over TJI and sheetrock.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/15/2004
Usually an engineer will have to stamp them no matter what, but it depends on your jurisdiction. IMHO, using a draftsperson and an engineer works well for owner-builders because you can save some money, but more importantly, you can talk directly to your engineer about critical parts of your house, so you can make sure they go together properly. This will save you costly mistakes. Even though you are generally hiring pros, they will probably have never built _your_ exact house before, so things will be new. By understanding the construction details (where beams are supposed to rest, etc.) it will make your project better and run smoother.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/14/2006
Tom,
You're looking at some of the right things.
1) Make your HVAC subs show you their load calculations. If they
can't, move on. The cost of finding a sub that knows what they
are doing (they will probably charge a little more than the average
guy) will be offset by the reduced size of the equipment.
2) There are good and bad subs with every product. I've seen
stick-frame houses that are all messed up too. If you can't find
a good sub, then that may be a problem, but I suspect most people who
can afford it will rebuild their hurricane hit houses with something
better than they had, so there will be more subs with more experience.
3) CMU, besides lacking attachment points and insulation, does not come
close in strength to a poured wall, ICF or plain. If you are
building for survivability, I'd look at poured walls of some sort.
Hope this helps.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/15/2006
I believe amvic did just come out with one, it actually "locks" into
the walls for a monolithic pour I believe. My uncle builds
commercial buildings and selected amvic to replace his steel/SIPS
structures he was building because of the floor.
Also, I think there is a product called 'insuldeck' that can be used with most of the systems.
On my house, we poured the basement in 8" concrete ICF, the main level
in 6". In a particular area of the house, we used the nudura
brick ledge with stirrups (and the extra 2" of wall thickness, plus
excavated foam) to support a 12" concrete slab for our cellar/safe
room. I think we ended up with about 9" of bearing there.
Rather than using the commercial insulated products, we framed a 2x10
"floor" to support the concrete pour, (hanging from J bolts in the
concrete), put 1/2" OSB on this, and then put 2.5" pink foam, which we
poured the concrete on. (Lots of shoring underneath). It
worked like a champ, and we only wanted enough insulation to keep the
inner surface above the dew point, since it was a cellar after all.
The engineer called for a #5 grid, 6" on center, in this slab.
Hope this helps,
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 5/2/2006
Here they use flex duct in tract homes, sheetmetal in custom homes, with many exceptions.
Flex duct will have higher "losses" as the air flow will not move as
smoothly, but if they are sized properly, the end result will be
similar to sheetmetal.
Perhaps you can talk to some other clients/homeowners whom he did flex duct for, and see how the houses heat/cool?
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/17/2006
Ken,
I did put in the HRV, but with our dogs going in and out, I'm not sure
it was worth it... Opening a 3' door every couple of hours, plus
usual entry/exit seems fine. (i.e. we don't really notice if the
HRV has been running or not). We still have it on a periodic
timer, but the air always looks the same. :)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/8/2005
We don't do crawlspaces here very often, but here is what we did... We
have a full basement, with a concrete slab. Colorado is a very
high radon area, and all new construction in most counties requires a
test, but our lot didn't... We formed our footings using the
form-a-drain product, with an inlet set to the high side as directed by
certeeneed for radon mitigation. This inlet is then piped through
a T and into a vent stack that runs through the house and out of the
roof for passive radon mitigation. For active, you can cut this
stack in the attic and insert a powered fan; the passive mode uses the
heat on the pipe from inside the house to create a thermal convection
and draw air out of the pipe. The area under the slab was filled
with porous pea gravel, covered with poly, and then covered with
insul-tarp before pouring concrete. We also have an HRV which cycles fresh air into the house.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/8/2005
Also, I would point out that while it feels beefy, rough-cut lumber
is not guaranteed to be as strong as a stamped/graded 2x4... Why does
this matter? Chances are your inspector will want to see
everything graded. Check with your framer and your inspector (and
your engineer if you have engineered framing plans) before going this
route. Otherwise you might make a very expensive mistake... Now,
I've used a lot of rough timbers in my house, and the inspector doesn't
even blink when he sees a rough-cut 10x12, but using it in place of
stamped lumber might be a headache. Good luck, John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/23/2005
The services/transformers are usually installed by the electric
company, but at the expense of the developer. If your developer
sold the lot as having the electrical, it's his responsibility to
remedy the situation. If you bought it without that guarantee
(power to the edge of the lot)., you might be stuck for getting the
transformer upgraded or digging across the road.
If you technically fall as the role of the developer, then you have to
pay it... We developed our lot, and had to coordinate and pay for
bringing the service off of a pole and underground 600 feet to a
transformer for our house.
I suspect if you end up digging up the road, you'll need approval from
the development, and may need city permits, etc. If you can, you
might be able to pay for directional drilling, which would eliminate
the damage to the road surface, but it will be costly.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/28/2004
Dan,
For what it's worth, you might consider paying for a subsurface soils report. If you know where you want the house sited, and where your septic would be, you ought to be able to get the boreholes and percolation test for about $800-$1000. I know that sounds like a lot, but it might help you a bit...
If you spend this money, and it looks like you cannot afford to build because of the local site conditions, you can probably mark up the lot by another $500 - $1000 and advertise that a full soils report is available (unless of course it's really unfavorable).
What the soils report will do is it will tell an engineer exactly what it will take to build your house there. You don't have to go with engineered fill in many cases, there are other options - fancy caissons, surevoid, etc that can be done, depending on house design.
Perhaps others can read between the lines here, but I highly recommend making your land offers contingent upon a soils report, because if it comes back needing expensive excavation and engineering work, then you have some serious leverage on the seller. And if it's OK, thats great, and chances are, in most jurisdictions, you have to do this work anyway, so you have a head start on your project. It also shows some more equity/soft costs when you are selling your project to the bank - It shows that you have done your homework.
I have a friend building about 1/2 mile from my construction site, and he found that there were a variety of options for his expansive soils, with various positives and negatives, that add between 10K and 30K, depending on his choices. But he had a variety of choices in the solution.
---
On the other hand, soils reports occasionally are not all they are cracked up to be. In my case, soils said bedrock at 15', fantastic soil, etc. Once we started digging, we hit solid rock under 1/2 the basement at about 4', and ended up blasting, etc. (Add 30K and erase our contingency fund). :( My excavator and I were totally fooled, but he said that is pretty rare.
Most anywhere in Colorado other than the plains, you will need heavy equipment, period, but it's not as expensive as many would say. You should be able to get a 60-80 ton trackhoe to dig a basement with some rock in 2-4 days at a cost of ~1100 per day (say 2000sf basement). Big/Solid rock will require blasting, I paid about $1500/ 20 holes, needed 97 holes to do it all.
If you hit rock, the expansive soils are much less of an issue, but your engineer will decide. Some great firms have a geologist and a structural engineer on staff, whom work together to figure out how to make it work.
Good luck! Don't give up without something in writing!
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/24/2005
Agreed! A starter lot here is $200K plus utilities.
I'm hoping I'm not really a bad shopper - Our project is going to come
in at $130 psf, plus another $30 psf for utilities, plus land. Top
finishes, sheetrocked/wired basement and finished/insulated garage,
but still. You guys are doing GREAT!!
If I hadn't done the ICF's myself, and been the general, I figure our
project would have been about $230 psf, plus land. Our utilities
are expensive.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/13/2005
Definitely go to a real lumberyard. If you are doing a house, they will do a takeoff for you 90% of the time. Then, you can see if HD will match... then decide IF you really want to deal with HD. My
lumber guy is great. I call him, and magically, my lumber appears
at my front door. Hangers, nails, special cedar, glues; all
delivered, no charge. Then, when the deck is up, or
the roof capped, I collect all the unused material, call my lumber guy,
and it goes away, and my bill goes down. No restocking, no
carrying materials. I'd say it's the way of the future, except
that real lumberyards have done business this way for a long time, and
HD doesn't.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/19/2004
Did you go
closed or open, and what heat sources did you select? I'm planning on
closed with a Trinity or Munchkin boiler depending on the supplier I
choose. Did any of you use the Polaris system? Any problems with
igniters or anything? I've heard they are pretty solid.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/8/2005
Rub-r-wal has a spray formulation that is ICF safe, but there are
others that are spray on and also fine. Call around, chat,
and if they don't know, move on. :)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/31/2005
Weather conspired to make concrete trucks slide down my
driveway and that put my garage floor finisher behind. He elected
to cut them later, and came back about 3 days after the pour to cut
them. Cutting them early is better, the concrete is softer, but
if you have to wait 30 hours, I don't think it will be the end of the
world.
Best of luck,
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/17/2005
I think that wood will usually be cheaper than SPEEDFLOOR, unless you
are doing radiant heat. If you are doing radiant heat, I'd expect
that you will save $2 psf using Speedfloor.
I built with wood, but would have done Speedfloor if my distributor was carrying it when I started. :)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/30/2005
Check your local regulations, though. Some areas (mine included)
won't allow anyone without a license to install septic. The
license is trivial, but expensive to obtain here.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/28/2004
Well, having both in the same house, I have found that heating the air
and pushing it around in a plenum DOES indeed "dry it out" - My RH goes
down (I'm already in a dry climate) when we run forced air, but if the
hydronics are doing the heating, we are within 1-2% of the outside.
Perhaps heating the air (it's being heated a lot hotter than the
thermostat temperature) is drying it out, whereas hydronics are heating
objects and generally relying on conduction/radiation instead of
convection???
Not sure on the answer, but I do see a difference.
On a side note, for owner-building, the hydronic heat is nice for
trying to keep the project moving in winter - My sheetrock guys are
thrilled, and I don't have to worry about them burning my place down
with kerosene/propane heaters. Some builders do run forced air
systems during sheetrock (to get the job done) but the guys on
hvac-talk.com indicate that this is the surefire way to fill your coil
full of junk and invalidate your warranty...
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/29/2004
The geothermal heat pumps can end up being pretty expensive, but a lot
of it depends on your site conditions. Do you have good diggable
soil? If it's sandy, that will reduce your efficiency and require
more pipe in the ground.
A 6-ton geothermal water/water and water/air combo heat pump ranged
from $6,000 - $11,000 for the heat pump installed. The exterior loop
field for that heat pump would have been $7,100. Then I would pay
for my radiant system (tied to the water - water side) and ducting (for
AC and quick supplemental heat). Ducting (including all vent
fans) was $4,500.
As you can see, in my case, geo was pretty expensive. I opted out
of it for now, but designed my radiant system to use low temperature
water (closer spacing, slabs everywhere) because geothermal heat pumps
don't produce really high temperature water (around 120-130 max).
Along this line, you need to know that during winter, when heat is
being used also, your system will not produce hot enough water to be
the sole supply of domestic hot water - at best it can pre-heat the
water so that a regular gas or electric heater does very little.
Conversely, in the summer, when you are extracting heat from inside
your house, the unit, if equipped with a desuperheater (highly
recommended) it will provide all of your DHW using primarily the heat
from inside your house!
A very cool system in my opinion. Finances drove me out of it, as
I put a priority on the flexibility of heat sources that radiant
offers, figuring I can switch fuels later if needed. Just the
geoexchange side of the system would have cost ~$18K ($3K per ton),
whereas my HP and boiler cost a total of around $5,500.
Also, I think I figured out a bit of the debate on RH last night.
In Colorado, it's always so dry, nobody ever notices dry versus drier,
but I walked down into my basement last night, remarked at how warm it
was, with the thermostat set at only 55. 55? Yeah, 55 as an
air temperature. Then it dawned on me, something I had read, but
never really thought about, and didn't experience until I fired up the
radiant a few nights ago. You have a lower air
temperature/thermostat setting with radiant heat for the same level of
comfort, at least from what I've heard. I thought my basement at
55 was vastly more comfortable than the house I live in right now with
forced air at 70 (to keep my wife from freezing).
So perhaps the RH difference is for a given level of comfort, but the
same level of comfort will have different air temperatures due to
radiation?
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 1/3/2005
Arit is great. Other O-B's in my area have used them with great success.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/20/2004
Yep, but the manufacturers have already taken care of this.
The manifolds look a bit like a circuit breaker panel - usually a column along the left with one temp of water, and a column down the right with the other supply. Each "column" (adjacent valves) services one fixture, so there is a red handle and a blue handle for each fixture. The rows are marked with each fixtures name, so if you need to turn off a fixture for service, you just turn off the hot and cold for the fixtures right there.
Pretty neat. I ended up using copper in my house, mostly because the plumbers don't seem big on it. From what I can gather, the plumbers around here don't want to carry another set of fittings and tools to deal with PEX, but I don't think it's really that many more fittings. Probably just a good excuse to keep doing what they have been doing for years because it worked?
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/21/2004
My plumber is doing supply, waste, drain, vent, trim, and gas piping for $13,500, which includes building a mud pan for a large walk-in shower. This is 2 1/2 baths, plus a shower and wash basin in the garage. My fixtures I purchase and supply. I'd say your plumbing budget is generous!
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/21/2005
DWV needs certain specific dimensions, 2-3", etc. for the materials and solids. While PEX is available in those sizes, it's not cheap nor advised. I doubt there are fittings for it either. PEX is really suited for lines under pressure, in smaller diamaters (3/8" - 1").
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 4/3/2005
I drew my own, and was able to negotiate my fee with my designer down
because we didn't have to go through many iterations because I had the
design on paper in a workable state. That said, I'm
pretty technical and know CAD, and knowing now that the building
department isn't a bunch of boogeymen, I should have done it all and
saved time and money.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/7/2005
Everything Ken hit above is right on! 4" is nice on material costs, but consolidation is a lot tougher. You can easily do 6" below/above grade, but it will require more steel below grade. I did 8" below and 6" above; I didn't want to mess with pouring 15' of 4" for my main level.
Any cost analysis is going to be very specific to your design and climate, but with ICF, the extra concrete doesn't really add anything insulation wise. I used Nudura on my house - I don't know much about the other products, but the Nudura @ 2 5/8" works well with dimensional lumber for bucks (i.e. 2x12 @ 11.25" fits the Nudura 6"). I did look at Reward, PolySteel, Rastra, Nudura, and Formtech before selecting Nudura. Nudura offers a class, which is great just for becoming an educated owner-builder. Murph
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/15/2004
Please post back here if you learn anything - I'm a week or so from
installing Icynene, but would like to see the bio stuff. I've
contacted the manufacturers three times over the past 10 weeks and they
won't return phone calls or emails, so I'm already starting to write
them off.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/20/2004
BioBased has improved a lot in 6 months!
I called today and immediately got the number of an installer in my
area. Had a walk-through today and should be getting a bid in the
next couple of days. The installer only started the bio-based foam four months ago, so we'll need to check out some previous jobs.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/31/2007
If your house and the foundation interface is done correctly, then you'd have the OSB pretty much flush, and flashed over, the top outside edge of the ICF's - So the water will be clear of the foam.
On all ICF's, virtually every manufacturer requires A) that the exposed foam be covered, either with siding/brick/stucco (exposed above grade) or parged (kind of a gray cement stucco) or waterproofed (below grade). So really, your foam is covered and won't deteriorate in properly installed ICF.
The real additional cost is that you are insulating the entire basement of the ICF wall, and it does cost more up front. Both foundations generally require waterproofing, ICF installers tend to be fewer and are charging a little extra if there is good work in the area, but if nobody can afford them around you, you might be able to bargain some.
If you go ICF, be sure your waterproofing is compatible with the foam. Most are, some are not. It would be heartbreaking early in a project to get your foundation in, have the waterproofer come in, and spray your foam and have the foam melt away. Water-based coatings are generally OK, but check and test to be sure.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/21/2004
I suppose it depends on the area. A guy who has been helping me build his ICF house found that SPEEDFLOOR is within $1 of conventional steel beam/TJI framing for his house, so I'm not sure they are that out of line when you look at the whole project. Obviously, regional labor and material costs can change the value a lot.
It's also common to pour lightweight concrete toppers on a well-built conventional deck here, with the deck being decked with 3/4" treated plywood prior to pouring the 1/5" topper, and the whole works sloped for drainage.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/18/2005
I'd have to ditto most of Ken's points - I was all set on Rastra,
and ended up switching my criteria three times once I had actually used the
forms. Regardless, get your engineer
involved before you go far down the road with any ICF product - esp.
with some of the more "non-traditional" ICF's - They have special
criteria and often will require some specific implementation details
(that can be expensive) to execute a particular design (i.e. a really
open plan might require special steel or banding to keep the walls from
bowing, which in turn might drive a particular wall thickness and
concrete strength, which may or may not be doable with a given wall
size/thickness/configuration. Also, I'd triple warn
against pouring any concrete that soupy without having a materials
engineer take samples and test/supervise the pour - It will be
expensive to make sure that it is done right. Pouring that soupy
is difficult to do right, but the pitfalls would probably not show for
a couple of years... Good luck, John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/1/2005
Too late, it's already happened. Rough guestimates for Colorado,
Concrete up 14% and rationed, OSB up 15%, shingles up 10%, most other
lumber up 10+%. Sheetrock has jumped 20% in some places.
Along with the steel price pressure, that has made everything more
expensive. cutting teeth for excavation equipment, furnaces,
pipe, wire, etc....
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/14/2005
This is how pretty much all ICF houses around here are built.
Often some insultarp or other foil is put down, along with radiant
tubing, before pouring the slab, but the slab is completely encased
within the ICF walls.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/22/2004
I will be having icynene installed in a couple of weeks. I'm utilizing a 2004 ammendment to the IRC code allowing unvented roof assemblys if the proper type/amount of insulation is applied to the underside of the roof deck. Icynene meets this requirement.
I'm doing it becacuse my roof design has only 20-30" of attic space, and icynene is pretty dense per R value, but sprayed to the underside of the roof deck, eliminates the need to vent the roof (which cost about $900 on my house) and also eliminates 26 intentional penetrations through the roof (likely points of leaking in the future).
THe concept is that the attic becomes conditioned space; Icynene also seals openings/voids so you reduce/eliminate air infiltration. In my house, this will seal the roof deck to the ICF walls, and should make things tight.
The last thing I'm going to do, after insulation, before drywall, is a blower door test. Doing it before drywall will let you find the leaks before they are covered, although obviously this would be harder with conventional framing/vaporbarrier.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/27/2004
I persued the unvented roof application with a fury - my design has a virtually flat roof (1/2 : 12 pitch, aka southwestern adobe) - it was going to cost me $900 for pop vents, and with a flat roof, I didn't want to make any additional (intentional) penetrations. :) I'm sure it will leak (as the flat roof saying goes!) but doing the best practices to try to avoid it.
I installed an EPDM membrane roof, but the killer roof, which I've yet to find anyone who can install (not that I could afford it) is a welded stainless steel roof - I've seen some on fancy commercial, the guys have to fly in from germany or something to do it...
Probably only useful information for those who are building rustic adobe's or modern contempory flat roof designs. :)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/29/2004
That's it. I'll bet that roof costs more than most very nice houses!
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 8/6/2005
My buddy just used Direct Buy, with mixed results. He had
purchased flooring and tile without problems, but a lot of the higher-end stuff, THEY CAN'T REALLY GET. BainUltra tubs, many of their
cabinet lines, etc. It cost him $2,000 in interest. The cabinet
they had picked wasn't available for three extra months because Direct Buy
was "having a fight with the distributor" - whatever! He ended up
buying a different cabinet locally, after a lot of delay and wasted
time. He did get most of his stuff, but was pretty miffed that
the tub they had spec'ed (because they liked it and Direct Buy sold it)
wasn't really available. Beware.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/21/2004
Would you pay $1000 now to ensure that you didn't have to abandon the
house later?
That is the drastic case, but I would strongly consider it. Talk to
other projects in your area to get a feel for if these folks are having
soils tests done.
In my area, they are required. Entire developments of show homes have
had to be knocked down because after a good rain, the soils expanded
and crushed the foundations.
I had soils and a septic percolation done for $1200, and would strongly
recommend doing some research on the local soils before skipping the
test.
On the other hand, the tests don't tell you everything, but it's a good
measure to help ensure that you don't have unstable or expansive soils.
It will also tell you where the water table is.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/15/2005
12" high footers? Wow! I used their 8" without problems,
and it really pays for itself in schedule and labor. The drawback
is you really need to stake it every 3-4' or so, to keep it from
getting wavy. If you do need footers greater than 12", one thing you could do is screw 2x material to the top of the Form-a-Drain. As
far as I've seen, Form-a-Drain is the only leave-in-place footing form
with a perimeter drain. Great idea, expensive, but I'm glad I used
it. John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/1/2004
I would second the above post. If you are going to DIY ICF, buy a good block, and buy from a distributor who really knows what they are doing. I did my own ICF work.
The only block I would be willing to install myself is Nudura, or maybe Reward. Nudura's price was better than any other block at the time I did my project, but I think the prices are pretty close right now. Nudura folds flat, so shipping costs are a lot less than many blocks. It also goes up in 8' sections, and you don't really have to assemble it like some of the blocks. The ties lock the courses together, so there is no need to glue seams unless you end up with a bastard joint.
So, either way, here are some guidelines and experience that I either learned on my project, or other ICF projects I helped with before my project.
Buy from a distributor who has the experience and equipment to help you do it right. There was a PolySteel project I helped with that had nothing but problems on the first level, the second level was better, and the last pour went great. Why? Because the distributor was no help, didn't really know what concrete was, and the owner had to learn it as he went. I learned a lot watching his project.
Rent the bracing/wall alignment systems - don't try to make your own bracing out of 2x material - you will waste a lot of time, and you won't get as good results. Also, if your block allows for vibration, your distributor should have a vibration/consolidation tool for you to rent/borrow. If you can, take a class. Nudura offers a two-day class, when they then credit the cost of it back to you on your first order. Even if the class isn't for the block you will be installing, the techniques they teach will apply to any ICF you choose to install. They will save you a lot of problems and you will get a better result.
It usually took us about 3-7 days (two guys) to stack a level, and then another 10-14 days to get all the bracing installed, pour, and then cleanup/teardown. We lost a lot of time due to weather, but we finished quicker than one of the contractors I was considering hiring, but we worked hard. (9 working weeks, 12 weeks total) That included a vault roof, basement floor, main subfloor framing, and the garage out of ICF.
One thing that I'm glad I did was using VBUCK (vbuck.com) for the window buck material - it is much lighter and easier to work with than the pressure-treated lumber (needed in contact with the concrete) and doesn't warp/twist. Two guys were able to build and set the window bucks on a level of my house in one day. The guy I had helping me had done a dozen ICF houses, and was astonished with the ease that the window bucks went in.
I would strongly recommend visiting job sites of each block you are considering. You will see dramatic differences, in terms of waste, problems, labor, and overall quality. There are lots of good blocks I've seen, and some I wouldn't want to use.
Good luck!
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 10/1/2004
Double good Ken! I think you summarize the pluses and minuses of ICF and methods. Your point on classes is RIGHT ON! I hope more people look into ICF's - I think it's a great way to build a house.
The V-BUCK was expensive, and I only justified it because of the price of labor in my area. It was nice, but there are some great alternatives as you pointed out. There is also a product called Easy Buck that you assemble with lumber to make bucks, but I think it only works with the Nudura forms. If I were doing it myself again, I'd pay for it, but if I was hiring it out, I wouldn't ask for it, because of the premium cost. I'm a wimp, and didn't want to haul the lumber around.
I also doubly agree with you on the class. I actually took the class with the intent of hiring one of the subs I had bids from. After sitting in the class, and realizing that most of these "professional" foundation guys couldn't calculate square diagonals, I decided I'd do it. My DIY cost was less than half of the cost from my sub, and I got the V-BUCK and Scapewel window wells as an upgrade, but I wasn't exactly paying myself anything there.
HINT! - If you can, get a couple of drawings with some diagonal distances for the major boxes, all corners, and 45-degree angles marked on a separate sheet. It will improve the quality and speed of your foundation layout. It's not worth paying a lot for (from your drafter, etc) but if you have your own CAD system, or they are nice (it only takes five minutes) it's a great tool to have.
I did it with time off from a job, some very experienced help, and excellent factory support. I would caution people against the DIY route unless you have really done your homework. In hindsight, it's something I would have done again, because of the money I saved, but it is a big time commitment.
I also offered my "hired gun" (experienced help) bonuses for uneventful pours. (I had been to some pretty awful pours with blowouts and concrete everywhere). In hindsight, I didn't have anything to worry about with my block and the factory support/bracing, but I offered him $100 per pour (two pours) for no blowouts or surprises. I figured it was cheaper than another hour of a pump truck and cleaning up a couple of yards of concrete at $60/yard. Of course, if you hire it out, then it's no worry at all!
The only other thing I would add is that ICF homes do take a lot of labor to do right - the bracing if you want really awesome walls, takes time. But every trade that has been on my site says this is how they will build their next house. (All these guys like doing it right, it seems).
I believe Nudura was formed by the guys who invented Amvic - the blocks have a lot of similarities. :)
Enjoy your concrete home.
Once I get the house finished, I hope to hook up my in-wall sensors and see if I can quantify the "thermal effect" of ICF houses. (i.e. track inside temp, outside temp, and inside concrete wall temp) to see if the buffering effect really works. (I'm sure it does, I'd just like to put science behind the "performs like R-50" sales poo).
Murph
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/30/2005
How does it fit with the rest of the house? If you are going
granite and marble, the parquet would be a draw-down I think. But I have seen some installations where it works out nicely.
I pulled out some carpet in a rental and installed parquet on the
cement. It looked great, but does not wear or re-finish well -
You might be able to finish it twice before the sanding takes it
through to the wires in the back. I have seen a lot of it, but
mostly on older homes... But I'm no decorator, it might really
scream 70's.
If you guys like it, put it in, unless you are planning on flipping the
house soon. Then just put in the Realtor beige and plain cheap
beige tile. :)
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/30/2005
My footings were designed for 2,500 psi soil (the basis from a soils test, although we ended up resting on solid rock after the blasting). Our footings varied in width from 16" (ICF garage walls) to 48" (ICF basement and main level, with a 12" cement cellar roof cantilevered off of the ICF). The width of the footings was varied based on the loads that would be in that area by the engineer (or his computer program).
The zigs and changes in width equalize the pressure under the house - You'd find that walls with lots of windows (and thus, less ICF) would have thinner footings. All my footings were 8" thick, with 2 #4 bars longitudinally, and all footings over 24" had #4 bars across the width of the footing every 3'.
My materials costs (steel, pump truck, form-a-drain forms, and cement) ended up running around $3.5K for the house & garage). So a very rough guess for bid purposes would be $7K. (Note the form-a-drain was a significant cost, but overall savings with the built-in radon vent/perimeter drain).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/6/2004
If I had it to do over again, I WOULD HAVE DRAWN MY OWN PLANS.
I have a strong AutoCAD background, but didn't know much about the
building industry. Also, I had the (wrong) impression of the
building department being mean ogres. (They are not).
I hired a construction consultant (kinda like UBuildIt or Owner Builder Network
or whatnot, except I paid only a flat per finished sf fee. No
mandatory products or suppliers, nothing to do with my bank, etc.) He told me early in the process that he could give me
examples of the kind of details that the building department wanted,
and that I should do the plans myself. I chickened out, but wish
I had done it.
My draftsperson/designer was fine, but I already had the rough design
done and in the computer. It took her months to get little
changes done, and that wasted a lot of time.
My college buddy is drawing his own (he's a super AutoCAD jock) and his
experience has been much better - He's been in control. He was
able to hire the draftsperson at the engineering/soils firm he used to
act as a consultant. Overall, he probably got his plans done for
$2,000.
Now, $2,000 you say, that's expensive! Well, not really. It
would cost a minimum $2,000 or so to get any plan you buy on the Internet approved to build here - and a stamp from a company in some
other state will NOT do it. All the homes here require engineered
foundations, which are specific to the soil, lot, and topography.
In my buddy's case, ~$1,500 was foundation/structural engineering, and
the remainder was costs to print lots of copies and pay the
draftsperson for consulting. In my case, I paid $3K to the
draftsperson, and then another $2,500 in engineering. I blew it
there! Should have done them myself.
My hindsight is so good now because I've been fine-tuning the plans as
I build (for instance, I nudged a wall 1" to make the ICF layout
better, so I updated my plans, so new copies exactly match the house as
built). Doing all these changes, I realized I could have easily
drawn them up front.
Hope this helps.
John
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/7/2005
The costs per square foot can vary widely based on finishes, locations,
and labor costs. Your numbers would not be out of line for my
area.
I forgot our exact costs (I've probably posted them if you search the
forums on this site), but I think it was around $150 psf, but that
included my utilities, which amounted to several tens of thousands for
my location. It appraised for around $250 psf.
Some folks here are able to do it for very low costs per square foot,
either because they do a lot themselves, or because they have lower
cost markets where labor is more affordable.
A local builder in our area was charging $100K plus costs, for a reference.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/12/2005
In my house, the plumber set the tubs. Well, kinda. I
left a cast iron tub in the hall next to one bathroom, and the plumber
installed it when he did the rough-in. The fiberglass magical
expensive Jacuzzi the framers unpacked and installed for me, smashing
up the digital controls in the process. :( The distributor for
the tub was great though, and sent me a new control for free. The
framers are generally apes. So talk to your plumber, usually they set the tubs. And they actually care how things look/work when they are done. J
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 3/8/2005
Indeed, there is a huge variety in pricing WRT dealers and window brands. I had a $25K difference between my bottom and top supplier quotes.
Not sure of what areas Sierra Pacific (SP) services, but I bought SP, and they were beating Andersen/Marvin/Pella/Weathershield aluminum-clad wood windows into the ground on quality and price. It's so bad around here that if a window dealer gets wind that you are getting a bid from SP, they won't even bother finishing your quote.
SP deals only direct, no window distributors, lumberyards, etc. I think that is how they are eating everyone's lunch on price.
Now it's not by a huge margin. But for a remotely comparable Andersen window, I was looking at 50% more in price, and Andersen still lacked some nice features that were standard in the SP windows.
By direct, I mean you sit down with the SP rep, they go through your plans and work up a complete window design, and price it. If you buy, the truck comes straight from the factory to your house, and you unload. When it comes time for trim, their crew comes out and installs the finish hardware (cranks/screens/door locks) and you're done. Great service too.
I think they may only service the western states though.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/2/2004
Do you have a picture of what you are trying to accomplish? Is
the dissapearing walls for security reasons? (I'm not from
hurricane country, so I'm not sure of all the issues). Check the
ICF threads though - they make a fantastic hurricane proof house.
I suspect it will be hard to make a regular garage door flush, since
they are designed to rest against the inside edge of the wall.
You could perhaps have some large custom doors made that swing , and
could then be finished with a stucco (EIFS would probably be good
there) or something like that.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 12/2/2004
See the Icynene thread below - I am about to try it, because I want to use the new amendment to IRC code that allows unvented roofs. Ken S. also did a lot of research.
I think (IMHO) the summary is that they might be worth it if you have a compelling reason (unvented flat roof in my case, or perhaps an attic or wall that is thin and does not have enough space for a normal amount of insulation). Otherwise, it's probably not worth the extra cost.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/12/2005
Technically, SPF, SIP, Icynene, icynene.com etc. are all variants of sprayed polyurethane - The difference (and difference in R-value) is open cell versus closed cell. Closed cell is much higher R-value as pointed out above. Beyond that, the differences are spray agents, etc. Some older variants of both used formaldehyde, but I believe the newer ones are well past that.
I looked at regular SPF, Icynene, etc., and ended up using bio-based, with an Icynene as my second choice. The one reason for me, I was insulating an EPDM roofed flat roof building (ICF walls) and wanted to air seal and insulate, but if I have a leak in the roof, polyurethane seals SO well that it will usually seal water leaks too. So if your roof (shingles, tile, rubber, asphalt) leaks, and you have an attic with SPF, you will probably never know it leaked, until you have to replace the roof and find the rotted roof sheathing...
Icynene and bio-based claim to allow the water to eventually get through - water vapor isn't a significant issue here, and since it met the IRC /IEC code, I didn't sweat it, but it didn't seem like it would let much water through...
Interestingly, the Icynene installer here in Colorado only does attics with 6" generally - All of the houses he insulates in Breckenridge (A mountain ski area, with a starter home at $2 million) he insulates with only 6". As he explained, the first 6" seals everything up and brings the inner surface up to room temperature (with an R3.7) via the drop across the foam. Each additional inch doesn't get you as much, because the temperature drop is smaller and smaller - So the ROI is less and less, to the point of being unrecoverable.
Well, I didn't have time during construction to figure it out with my thermodynamics, so I hired his competitor to spray 11" in, but I think he might be right... Let me do some looking and I'll follow up here.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/12/2005
Probably very similar, SIPs are probably more efficient. SIPs can have the benefit of providing most of the structural support too. (You still need beams/gluelams/timber trusses or whatnot to support the SIPs).
I evaluated both, and SIPs were significantly more for my project, enough more that I ended up doing trusses/sheathing/biobased (spray foam) for significantly less than doing SIPs.
If you are going to have exposed timber frame, then you'd come out way ahead to use SIPs I believe.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/12/2005
I think you'd just have your timber frame, then lay SIP's down on the timber frame (perhaps with some sealant between the SIP faces and the timber frame, and then use the big long screws that comes with the SIPS to fasten them to the timber frame. Over that you put your roofing.
This then becomes an unvented attic. Nothing wrong with that in this kind of application, but you will need to dig up the 2004 IEC amendment to the 2003 IRC code book. A lot of research is showing many unvented applications to be very efficient, but obviously there is a tradeoff if you have a large unvented attic.
Now in your case, you will have a great tall ceiling - So putting a fan up there to push hot air down might make sense. At least rough it in and put a plate over it. If you are using radiant, radiant generally heats the people/objects, not the air, so it's not as much of an issue. I have a room with 16' ceilings, and a fan roughed in, but no need for it, as the heat in the floor makes it nice for people all the time.
When you install your SIPs, make very sure that all the gaps between the panels are sealed up good. Sloppy SIP installation will make your expensive panels perform worse than stick frame trusses/plastic sheeting vapor barrier/fiberglass batts. In extremely cold climates, water from inside can collect on the outside sheathing if the gaps are not sealed right, resulting in roof rot.
But it's easy to seal them up. The panel supplier will provide a foam glue that you glue the panels together with, and it will seal these gaps up nicely.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/12/2005
You might have your electrician wire for a fan (or fans) in that area
and put covers over them, that way if you want to add one (say for
cooling) you can, without trying to figure out how to get power up
there after everything is finished.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/30/2004
Follow Ken's advice -- it is VERY common for HVAC installers to oversize
equipment. Why not? Bigger equipment is more money for
them, and will err on the side of not getting a call back. Plus,
then they don't have to do a real calculation.
The fact that your UBuildIt guy was using rules of thumb is scary too
- They ought to know better if you are really trying to build a quality
house.
I had some HVAC guys try to sell me 11 tons of heating and cooling
based on my square footage. Real load calcs showed I only needed five tons of heating and 3.5 tons of cooling.
If the HVAC contractors can't show you calcs, then you might try other
guys. I was going to go with a guy that had a good price on a five-ton unit, but my gut told me I'd be sorry. His price was good,
but when I worked with a better contractor, he did the load calc, whose
results matched mine, and the smaller unit that was all that was really
required allowed me to get a "brand name' unit as opposed to the larger
"builder grade" unit.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 2/7/2005
David,
I did my ICF walls, also on rock, and have some tips:
Break
down and buy a decent hammer drill. You can get some okay ones on eBay,
or bite the bullet and pay for a new one. I did the first 2/3 of my
project with a battery powered DeWalt hammer drill. Dumb. Once I bought
an AC powered one, I'll never look back. Virtually all of my footings
and thus ICF walls are pinned to rock, a requirement in my area if you
are on rock and footings or walls might get shallow.
Also, when forming
up my footings, I needed to hammer drill holes (3/4") for the form
stakes. For pinning to rock, I hammer drill 12" into the rock, blow the
material out with compressed air and a long handle (wear eye
protection), run a brush down it, and then blow it out again. I then
put epoxy in the hole (there is a special 2-part epoxy with a mixing
nozzle that mixes the parts, it fits in a standard caulking gun) and
insert your rebar.
The second great item is the Tapcon fastener. I used these all over to
secure ICF's to the rock (I also used foam glue). Tapcons work great on
rock as well as concrete.
Good luck - you'll do fine. Take your time, and get everything set
before you call for concrete. I guarantee your work will come out
better than any sub's - you really care, whereas most subs want their
check.
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 11/26/2004
A lot of firms that do structural engineering for houses will have a
guy that can do your soils test (usually a geological engineer or a
geologist). That (IMHO) makes for a really good match, as if the
two work under the same roof, you will have a foundation design that
really matches your soil and won't have any bad surprises later.
As a plus, they usually give a bit of a discount for using several
services (I had my surveyor, engineer, and geologist all out of the
same office).
| | 2004, 2005, 2006 Merit Award Winner John's Forum Posts: 278 Interview Answers: 69 Average Forum Rating: 4.21

 Randomly Selected Image
Log-in to vote!
| By John in Erie, CO on 9/28/2004
Ours is www.murphyacres.com - Still needs a bit of formatting, but we switched to a blog (Using the blosxom program) format so we could update it without a lot of effort, and send entries from phones ,etc since we don't have a ton of free time, but wanted to keep a chronology.
| |
|
| Top Forum Evaluators | | Mark in Provo, UT(507) | | Maria in Cincinnati, OH(49) | | Gail in Glencoe , CA(14) | | P in North, FL(7) | | Michael in Cave Creek, AZ(5) | | David in Fredericksburg, VA(5) | | David in Soddy Daisy, TN(3) | | Chelesy in Pleasant Hill, MO(1) | | Chris in Platte City, MO(1) | | RogerC in Phoenix, AZ(1) | | Brian in Dome-ville, central, FL(1) |
|
|
|